It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
^ Back to Top
The MI6 Community is unofficial and in no way associated or linked with EON Productions, MGM, Sony Pictures, Activision or Ian Fleming Publications. Any views expressed on this website are of the individual members and do not necessarily reflect those of the Community owners. Any video or images displayed in topics on MI6 Community are embedded by users from third party sites and as such MI6 Community and its owners take no responsibility for this material.
James Bond News • James Bond Articles • James Bond Magazine
Comments
Here's an interesting notion. The Quantum logo could easily pass for an octopus with one tentacle. Put some more tentacles on the little Quantum lapel badge and hey presto you've got the SPECTRE logo.
Perhaps this retconning stuff is not quite as bad as we thought?
I also like the fact Greene was found with two bullets in the back of his head and Hinx has a double-barrel pistol.
It makes so much sense - they should have had a line about Quantum being a tentacle of Spectre.
I am sure it is completely involuntary but.... Oh that would be great if it was Hinz who killed Greene. Although then Greene would have had no head left.
EON could've connected SP with the past three in a lot of cool ways, but they decided instead to spend a minute (literally) showing us that Quantum was somehow involved with SPECTRE and that was the end of that. I'm not a fan of how it was done, but it's too late to do anything about it now.
So what you're saying is that the grass is much redder on your side?
So that's why they call you Thunderfinger. You squeeze the trigger and the sound of thunder erupts.
The mods here have spun it the wrong way.
What makes you think that? He postulated and won a specific position in the organization but it might have been a promotion, not a hiring. In fact that he was in such meeting seems to indicate that he was at least trustable enough not to be a mere newcomer. I'd say Hinx must have done some contracts for them either as a freelance or a recruit.
This was my take, too. Also, it seems that his appearance was encouraged by Blofeld. What I have not been able to figure out, though, is why Hinx tried to kill Bond and Madeleine on the train when Blofeld wanted them at the crater lair. My guess is that Hinx's job was to kill Madeleine. Period. This may explain Blofeld's sarcastic line, "I'm glad you could join us, too, dear Madeleine." On the other hand, Blofeld had her room set up as though he couldn't wait to get into her head, too.
Oh what a mess SP is in some spots.
So what? He just used a nicked ring and used the Mickey Mouse line to get in like Bond?
If he just walks in out of the blue and starts killing people from nowhere Blofeld would scarper just like the moment it kicks off with Bond so Blofeld at least is aware Hinx is outside.
But it's far from clear. Is Hinx sanctioned by Blofeld to come in and kill Senor whatever his name is? Has Senor thingy been on the rob and this is a standard SPECTRE execution? Seems a bit harsh if Hinx just kills a loyal SPECTRE member to show he can do the job.
It's sloppily written - but this is SP remember. Which scenes aren't?
That's a bit thin. I didn't read this from body language and I doubt one can read that much from everyone present (that Hinx did not ever work for SPECTRE and was an intruder). If his presence was not wanted Blofeld would have had him executed on the spot. Because at least Blofeld showed neither surprise nor concern when Hinx showed up.
@TheWizardofIce- It's obvious Hinx action was at least sanctioned: he was allowed to carry on. As for the reason why I think we've had here a Kronsteen moment: a member bragging too much and suffering from hubris. In a normal company meeting he would have just gotten his candidacy turned down. But this is not an uber criminal organization we're talking about. And Hinx is not exactly a subtle man.
I wouldn't call the man that Hinx kills arrogant, either. He says he can do the job, but he's not shouting about it with passion or really lathering on his confidence. It's more like he's going to a job interview than anything.
I also don't agree that Blofeld would've had Hinx killed if he was an intruder. He didn't know how things were going to play when Hinx stepped in, but liked the way in which the man took command and made things interesting. He was ruthless, he was capable and proved his villainy when he used those eye scrappers to dispatch his agent. He was a clear choice for eliminating anyone, especially frail old Mr. White. At that point, he was in with SPECTRE, but not before, in my view.
All of this would make for great fodder for a commentary track, wouldn't it? :-\"
Blofeld's not Simon Cowell. I find the notion that SPECTRE hold open auditions where you can just walk in off the street the thinnest hypothesis yet.
It's inconceivable to me that Blofeld is not aware of Hinx's presence before he comes in. It strikes me that Blofeld has already tapped Hinx up to take over and for whatever reason and the gobby bloke deserves to be executed for some breach of protocol so he lets Hinx make his entrance in such a way pour encourager les autres to toe the corporate line.
It's certainly ambiguous. But...
I just re-watched the scene. After Guerra offers his services, Blofeld calls over one of his men and whispers instructions. Then, Moreau is waved over--he looks baffled by this sudden development. Again, Blofeld whispers something (more instructions). At that point, Moreau asks if anyone wants to challenge Guerra for the position. And then, here comes Hinx. Moreau's bafflement suggests to me that this "challenge" was a change in procedure.
This is why I believe Hinx was handpicked by Blofeld and his appearance at the meeting (and subsequent challenge to Guerra) was coordinated. What's unclear is the extent to which Hinx had been employed by Spectre previously. I have assumed he was a low-level hitman, maybe a contracted one, and that Blofeld liked his work.
Well of course, come on now. Obviously it's not a common occurrence. Thinking otherwise is just daft to be frank.
And if I am remembering the scene correctly, Hinx pulls the ring off the dead man's finger and puts it on his own. If he was already affiliated with SPECTRE to such a level that he knew about the Rome meeting and was let inside without issue, why didn't he already have a ring of his own?
I absolutely understand a lot of the negativity surrounding SP, I really do, but if we're now into the territory of nitpicking about one the best scenes in the film (and series for me) I feel like we're approaching peak pedantry. It's perfectly directed and the fact there is no dialogue only enhances its impact. It's not a difficult scene to grasp IMO.
A few things....
1) I love SP and have never been an uber-negative party about it.
2) I'm not nitpicking, I'm trying to engage in an analysis of a scene that genuinely interests me with others.
3) I wasn't reprimanding the choice to make Hinx mute. I think it works for him more than it doesn't. All I was saying is that objectively it makes the scene a bit more puzzling to read. That's not a criticism on the creative decision and execution.
4) I think the scene has many layers, and as I've said, I don't know if we should automatically presume that Hinx was already a SPECTRE agent if he had to take the man's ring to use as his own during the Rome meeting.
If my text came off as the opposite of any of this, it wasn't my intention.
Well, I am not create an entire mythology for Hinx and obviously I am doing a bit of retcon when I said I liked the hypothesis that he killed Dominic Greene. That said, it is obvious to me that at least Blofeld knew of (and approved of) Hinx's presence. Regarding the man he kills in SP, I would need to watch the scene again but I do remember some veiled criticism towards the other members and something akin to bragging (not so much about his skills than about his loyalty and discipline).
And by the way, mythologies are developed exactly like this: by adding elements and extrapolating on a sometimes very thin basis.