You Know My Name or Another Way To Die?

13

Comments

  • Posts: 5,634
    Welcome to MI6 pages @cmacy007

    Off to a good start too..
  • Lancaster007Lancaster007 Shrublands Health Clinic, England
    Posts: 1,874
    The more I hear You Know My Name the more I like it, it is fast becoming one of my favourite theme tunes, whereas Another Way to Die is just bloody awful, I was expecting something a lot better from Jack White!
  • Posts: 12,526
    Definately "You know my name"
  • Posts: 12,837
    YKMN is not just a classic Bond theme, but a great rock song too.

    AWTD is just awful. Jack White is talented but he dropped the ball here. Shame because the music is pretty catchy I think, it's just the lyrics n the singing.
  • Samuel001Samuel001 Moderator
    edited July 2012 Posts: 13,356
    EDIT: This is an old thread and I've already chosen and voted - woops!
  • Posts: 1,497
    YKMN is not just a classic Bond theme, but a great rock song too.

    AWTD is just awful. Jack White is talented but he dropped the ball here. Shame because the music is pretty catchy I think, it's just the lyrics n the singing.

    Apparently Jack White had written "Seven Nation Army" during a soundcheck with the thought that he was writing a James Bond theme. This would have been a much better Bond song IMO:

  • Posts: 4,762
    I actually enjoy both somewhat, but the win has to go to You Know My Name. It just simply is better than Another Way to Die in vocals and in the guitar tune, though AWTD does have a nice tune. The drawback is that the vocals from the woman in the background are quite wince-worthy and painful on the ears.
  • Posts: 11,425
    YKMN - much better all round. But AWTD wasn't that bad.
  • Posts: 498
    YKMN, of course. I actually resisted the temptation to listen to the song before Casino Royale came out, and it was an awesome experience hearing the song for the first time during the opening credits.
    I did the same thing for AWTD but it was just kind of... meh. Although, I will say, I do like the instrumental version of AWTD. It could've worked as background music or an end theme.
  • HASEROTHASEROT has returned like the tedious inevitability of an unloved season---
    Posts: 4,399
    "You Know My Name" for sure... IMO, its the best title song since Live And Let Die...

    I don't mind "Another Way To Die", it's certainly not as horrible as Madonna's "Die Another Day", or LuLu's "The Man With The Golden Gun"... but it's not among the best - it's about middle of the road for my tastes... my problem with it, is that White and Keys vocals sound too similar.. would've preferred to have just Alicia Keys sing it.
  • Posts: 5,634
    @haserot I'd go as far to say that Ms Ciccone's Die Another Day is actually better than AWTD, I know which one I would listen to if I was forced, it is the very worst of the 22 Bond releases without question. Lulu's Golden Gun is not so bad, it is quite lively and energetic, in my top five I even feel. If Keys is given another opportunity to attempt a James Bond theme ever again, I'm going offshore..

    It's about time we had another great Bond theme, they have been in short supply the last 30 years I feel, we don't know what Skyfall has in store, I'm a little apprehensive about what we're going to get, but must remain hopeful

    :-S
  • MurdockMurdock The minus world
    edited July 2012 Posts: 16,359
    YKMN But I love AWTD too. There both great Bond themes. I also love the visualizations that go with them in there respective films.
  • Posts: 4,762
    Murdock wrote:
    YKMN But I love AWTD too. There both great Bond themes. I also love the visualizations that go with them in there respective films.

    Oh indeed, the shattering playing cards with the shadowed 007, and then the desert background both make for awesome main title sequences. Certainly two of the easier to watch without getting bored.
  • Posts: 5,634
    I respect your opinion Mr Murdock but I'm having a hard time how anyone can say they love the QOS (theme) intro?, it is torture in it's purest form, it inflicts more pain on me than I thought was humanly possible, I'm being quite serious

    Maybe I'm alone in this, but I stated before, that the lyrics made little sense either, or I just found it too much of a job to listen carefully enough to what was being "sung" :-<

    The respective screen intros aren't too bad though, but with QOS there are some equilibrium issues to be had, a sign of things to come with the actual film itself no less
  • MurdockMurdock The minus world
    Posts: 16,359
    I respect your opinion Mr Murdock but I'm having a hard time how anyone can say they love the QOS (theme) intro?, it is torture in it's purest form, it inflicts more pain on me than I thought was humanly possible, I'm being quite serious

    Maybe I'm alone in this, but I stated before, that the lyrics made little sense either, or I just found it too much of a job to listen carefully enough to what was being "sung" :-<

    The respective screen intros aren't too bad though, but with QOS there are some equilibrium issues to be had, a sign of things to come with the actual film itself no less

    I dunno, It's just catchy to me. :D
  • HASEROTHASEROT has returned like the tedious inevitability of an unloved season---
    edited July 2012 Posts: 4,399
    @haserot I'd go as far to say that Ms Ciccone's Die Another Day is actually better than AWTD, I know which one I would listen to if I was forced, it is the very worst of the 22 Bond releases without question. Lulu's Golden Gun is not so bad, it is quite lively and energetic, in my top five I even feel. If Keys is given another opportunity to attempt a James Bond theme ever again, I'm going offshore..

    It's about time we had another great Bond theme, they have been in short supply the last 30 years I feel, we don't know what Skyfall has in store, I'm a little apprehensive about what we're going to get, but must remain hopeful

    :-S

    have you ever listened to Alicia Keys outside of Another Way To Die? She has an excellent voice.. the problem i believe was all on Jack White's end - as he wrote, sang, and produced the song... had the song just been Alicia Keys and a piano, it would've been miles better than what 'flash in the pan' White came up with... i'll go a step further and say, had David Arnold been allowed to work on the song with Ms. Keys, and the lyricist Don Black, we could've gotten another song as good as You Know My Name... note that every time Arnold and Black collaborated on a song in recent years, it turned out to be good - every time the artist did it all themselves, it blew.

    Which brings me to that awful piece of musical garbage called Die Another Day.... had the producers just bought the rights to use the other Madonna song Frozen, they would've been better off... the theme for DAD is uninspired pop/dance/club trash... the only thing it does right is hit hard on the subwoofers in my car, thats it..
  • Posts: 278
    YKMN by far. Best version is the one in the movie too.
  • doubleoegodoubleoego #LightWork
    Posts: 11,139
    HASEROT wrote:

    have you ever listened to Alicia Keys outside of Another Way To Die? She has an excellent voice.. the problem i believe was all on Jack White's end - as he wrote, sang, and produced the song... had the song just been Alicia Keys and a piano, it would've been miles better than what 'flash in the pan' White came up with... i'll go a step further and say, had David Arnold been allowed to work on the song with Ms. Keys, and the lyricist Don Black, we could've gotten another song as good as You Know My Name... note that every time Arnold and Black collaborated on a song in recent years, it turned out to be good - every time the artist did it all themselves, it blew.

    Finally, someone who knows what they're talking about.

  • Posts: 1,143
    You Know My Name. By far the better song.
  • Posts: 1,548
    You Know My Name is far far superior. Brilliant theme. As much as I admire Jack Black and Alicia Keys they just didn't gel properly as a Bond duet
  • DarthDimiDarthDimi Behind you!Moderator
    Posts: 24,256
    I'm going to go out on a limb here and say that AWTD might have fit the final half of the end titles. I think it has a few - repeat: A FEW - catchy cues going for it...

    [no, no bullets, I'm still alive]

    ... and as such I'm okay with hearing it in an obscure position in the film.

    As for the opening titles, it did what vampires do with blood. Plus, it didn't benefit, like DAD back in the day, from great opening titles. If anything, those terrible whirls and endless sand dunes make me focus on the song more and that isn't a good thing.

    Bottom line, I will not stigmatize the song itself, even if it isn't a great song altogether IMO, but it was part of something even worse which, unfortunately, was put in the very wrong place in the Bond film. It was put in a sacred place. And that was a mistake. A disaster I dare say.
  • Posts: 58
    You Know My Name, easily. Another Way to Die sounds like a bunch of cats being tortured. =P
  • CraigMooreOHMSSCraigMooreOHMSS Dublin, Ireland
    Posts: 8,231
    You Know My Name, easily. AWTD is garbage, easily the worst Bond song.
  • Posts: 267
    YKMN is one of my all time favorite title songs. I like the music of AWTD, but the singing by both Keys and White is dreadful.
  • Posts: 1,052
    They are both awful in the extreme!
  • edited July 2012 Posts: 299
    Another Way to Die is hands down the worst song of the series. It is atrocious. Starts out promising and then goes to hell, and stays there. Whereas You Know My Name is actually a great song, and even though it's a little radical for Bond, it nonetheless works.
  • Posts: 266
    You Know My Name. By far the better song.

    A few years ago i went to see Aerosmith in hyde park and Chris Cornell supported them and he played You know my name and David Arnold come on stage with him and played keyboards for the performance so that was cool. IMO It is the best Bond Theme since AVTAK but i liked GE too.
  • You Know My Name by Chris Cornell hands down.I thought the music for Another Way to Die was good, but Alicia Keys ruins the song when she starts singing the chorus.
  • Posts: 414
    I'm going Another Way to Die. Because it's actually my favorite Bond theme, and it's apparent from this thread and others that it needs all the love it can get.

    For Jack White fans, it's Jack White song that happens to have Alicia Keyes doing back-up vocals. For Alicia Keyes fans, it's an Alicia Keyes song that happens to have Jack Whie doing back-up vocals. A dark, mysterious tune and lyrics that perfectly reflect Craig's Bond and the central theme of the movie: knowing who to trust. (Another man who stands right behind you looking in the mirror . . . Someone who you think that you can trust is just/Another way to die.)
  • Major_BoothroydMajor_Boothroyd Republic of Isthmus
    Posts: 2,722
    Another Way To Die is awful. Among my least favourite Bond title songs ever.
Sign In or Register to comment.