›

Who is your Favorite M Q and Moneypenny

2»

Comments

  • CommanderRossCommanderRoss The bottom of a pitch lake in Eastern Trinidad, place called La Brea
    Posts: 8,331
    It's only at the end of Skyfall we get a cast again that in the next film rival the golden years in which Lee, Maxwell and Llwelyn were cast.

    Allthough I really like Dench's M, I prefer Lee's (also because he's the closest to the M from the books. Indeed, the perfect cast). I think Maxwell had the perfect chemistry with Conners and Moore. It just worked so well. I find all after irritating and/or forgettable up until SF. I also like the back story they've given Eve.

    Desmond was and is Q. Cleese did his best, but was unlucky as the films he played in were too campy. Wishaw indeed is the perfect one for the new age. An increadably good actor (indeed, L4yercake!) and a role adapted to these times.
  • thelivingroyalethelivingroyale
    Posts: 12,837
    CommanderRoss wrote:
    It's only at the end of Skyfall we get a cast again that in the next film rival the golden years in which Lee, Maxwell and Llwelyn were cast.

    Don't get me wrong, I like Ralph Fiennes and Wishaw was a good Q but I thought Harris was really wooden as MP, and I don't think the current cast rival the original three. Not sure anybody ever will.
  • LudovicoLudovico
    edited August 2013 Posts: 15,229
    DarthDimi wrote:
    I will always defend some of the less popular choices. I like Robert Brown and Judy Dench (who often takes a lot of heat for her alleged 'PC' manners), I like Wishaw and yes, YES, I even like Cleese. I also like Bliss and Bond. In fact, the MI6 staff has never disappointed me. Not once.

    But when the question is asked, it's hard for me not to go:

    M - Lee

    Q - Llewellyn

    MP - Maxwell

    It's the boring choice no doubt, but surely it's the only choice, no? ;-)

    It is the obvious choice, however one could divide by time period. Bernard Lee's M, for instance, had some better moments than others. Same with Maxwell's Moneypenny, who was I think at her best in OHMSS. The tears in her eyes when she takes Bond's hat, the sad smile. Absolute classic. She had her moments afterwards, but never like this one. And none ever did.
  • pachazopachazo Make Your Choice
    Posts: 7,314
    CommanderRoss wrote:
    Cleese did his best, but was unlucky as the films he played in were too campy.

    They were but I still felt that he overdid it a little bit. It's like the producers felt that since everyone thought that Desmond was funny they felt it fitting to cast a comedian in the role. Cleese is very deserving of the respect he gets for being a comic legend but the majority of his jokes fell flat in TWINE and DAD.
  • CommanderRossCommanderRoss The bottom of a pitch lake in Eastern Trinidad, place called La Brea
    Posts: 8,331
    thelivingroyale wrote:
    CommanderRoss wrote:
    It's only at the end of Skyfall we get a cast again that in the next film rival the golden years in which Lee, Maxwell and Llwelyn were cast.

    Don't get me wrong, I like Ralph Fiennes and Wishaw was a good Q but I thought Harris was really wooden as MP, and I don't think the current cast rival the original three. Not sure anybody ever will.

    I disagree on Harris. I liked her a lot. I liked the fact that she seemed rather uncomfortable as a field agent. I did like the flirting that was going on between her and Bond. I find it far more believable then the cheezyness between Samantha Bond's MP and Brosnan's Bond.

    Still, we've as yet seen very little of all of them in their new roles, I just hope they'll live up to expectations. It's too early to promote them as yet.
  • thelivingroyalethelivingroyale
    edited August 2013 Posts: 12,837
    Samantha Bond didn't get the best lines sometimes but I thought she had great chemistry with Brosnan and seemed much less wooden than Harris did.

    I think the one that shows most promise is Wishaw. He was much better than I expected and although I didn't like the idea of a younger Q, it means that he can stay on even longer than the others. Hope they tone down the hacking stuff though.
  • RogueAgentRogueAgent
    Posts: 12,526
    TRSTN1 wrote:
    Bernard Lee as M

    Desmond Llewelyn as Q

    Lois Maxwell as Miss Moneypenny

    Without question? I completely agree with the above! ^:)^
  • 4EverBonded4EverBonded the Ballrooms of Mars
    Posts: 12,480
    For me:

    M - Judi Dench (even though I love Lee, Dench is definitely my favorite M)

    Q - Desmond Llewelyn (forever ...) :x But I do like the young Q that is Wishaw

    Moneypenny - Lois (with Naomie second and Samantha 3rd. I think Naomie will shine on, I enjoy her Moneypenny very much!)
  • LudovicoLudovico
    Posts: 15,229
    thelivingroyale wrote:
    Samantha Bond didn't get the best lines sometimes but I thought she had great chemistry with Brosnan and seemed much less wooden than Harris did.

    I think the one that shows most promise is Wishaw. He was much better than I expected and although I didn't like the idea of a younger Q, it means that he can stay on even longer than the others. Hope they tone down the hacking stuff though.

    I MUCH prefer Harris to Bond (Samantha, I mean) and I think the chemistry is better too, almost too good in fact: I wouldn't have remained platonic had I been Bond (James).

    I too did not like the idea of a younger Q, but ended up enjoying Wishaw quite a lot. I see now it was maybe the only way to go: make the character different than Llewellyn's, to avoid comparisons.
  • 00130013
    edited August 2013 Posts: 1,817
    I've seen that the answers don't differ too much from each other.,, What about ranking the dyads so we can counter the interaction between the characters?

    M
    Connery-Lee
    Lazenby-Lee
    Moore-Lee
    Moore-Brown
    Dalton-Brown
    Brosnan-Dench
    Craig-Dench
    (Craig-Fiennes could be optional if someone dares based on so short scene)

    Q
    Connery-Llewelyn
    Lazenby-Llewelyn
    Moore-Llewelyn
    Dalton-Llewelyn
    Brosnan-Llewelyn
    Brosnan-Cleese
    Craig-Whishaw

    Monneypenny
    Connery-Maxwell
    Lazenby-Maxwell
    Moore-Maxwell
    Dalton-Bliss
    Brosnan-Bond
    Craig-Harris

    ***
    Mine will be:
    1. Connery-Lee
    2. Brosnan-Dench
    3. Dalton-Brown
    4. Craig-Dench
    5. Moore-Brown
    6. Lazenby-Lee
    7. Moore-Lee

    1. Connery-Llewelyn
    2. Brosnan-Llewelyn
    3. Moore-Llewelyn
    4. Dalton-Llewelyn
    5. Craig-Whishaw
    6. Brosnan-Cleese
    7. Lazenby-Llewelyn

    1. Connery-Maxwell
    2. Lazenby-Maxwell
    3. Moore-Maxwell
    4. Craig-Harris
    5. Brosnan-Bond
    6. Dalton-Bliss
  • Baltimore_007Baltimore_007
    Posts: 5,634
    Greatest M was, and will always be, Bernard Lee

    Greatest Q was, and will always be, Desmond Llewelyn

    Greatest Moneypenny was, and will always be, Lois Maxwell

    whatever came after them, and what we have now, and for in the future, I don't think anyone will be able to replace those names featured
  • MayDayDiVicenzoMayDayDiVicenzo Here and there
    Posts: 5,080
    Maxwell, Llewelyn and Lee for me too.
  • StirredNotShakenStirredNotShaken Toronto
    Posts: 2,402
    Lee, Llewelyn, and Maxwell. You're an idiot to choose otherwise.

    HOWEVER. If he remains on for long enough, I MIGHT just possibly tolerate someone saying Whishaw's the best Q.
  • JrW_008JrW_008 The North
    edited August 2013 Posts: 112
    I am finding this more difficult than I should. I have equal liking for Bernard Lee, Robert Brown and Judi Dench. Unlike with the Bond of my childhood, Brosnan, I like the casting of M, Judi Dench. However I will say Robert Brown today, but it could be any of the three tomorrow.
    As for Q, without the slightest doubt in my mind it is Desmond Llewelyn. Some day though Ben Whishaw may have some credibility as a good Q, I liked his appearance in Skyfall.
    Same goes for Moneypenny, definitely Lois Maxwell.

    I'll point out for clarification that Brosnan was the Bond of my early childhood, I'm 16 so in the years I consider myself a Bond fan it is Craig.
  • Dr_YesDr_Yes
    Posts: 169
    JrW_008 wrote:
    I'll point out for clarification that Brosnan was the Bond of my early childhood, I'm 16 so in the years I consider myself a Bond fan it is Craig.

    Ah, sonny, for me it was Roger Moore! I was 9 when LALD came out & my brother and I actually saw it in a cinema. For what it's worth, I can now only get my wife to watch Craig's Bond films.
  • PerdoggPerdogg
    Posts: 686
    Favorite M:

    1. Bernard Lee
    2. Robert Brown

    Favorite Monepenny

    1. Lois Maxwell
    2. Caroline Bliss
    3. Barbara Bouchet

    Favorite Q:

    1. Desmond Llewelyn
  • DragonpolDragonpol https://thebondologistblog.blogspot.com
    Posts: 18,344
    Favourite M - Bernard Lee

    Favourite Miss Moneypenny - Lois Maxwell

    Favourite Q - Desmond Llewelyn
Sign In or Register to comment.