Rate The Various Categories – The Musical Scores. Final Scores!

1678911

Comments

  • MayDayDiVicenzoMayDayDiVicenzo Here and there
    Posts: 5,080
    Goldeneye, 1995

    1. Implementation of the Theme Song – 5
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 9
    3. Style – 8
    4. Romance – 6
    5. Excitement – 7
    6. Brass – 4
    7. Suspense – 5
    8. Iconography – 7
    9. Epicness – 6
    10. Timelessness - 3

    60/100

    Tomorrow Never Dies, 1997

    1. Implementation of the Theme Song – 4
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 5
    3. Style – 4
    4. Romance – 5
    5. Excitement – 9
    6. Brass – 8
    7. Suspense – 8
    8. Iconography – 2
    9. Epicness – 7
    10. Timelessness - 7

    58/100

    The World Is Not Enough, 1999

    1. Implementation of the Theme Song – 5
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 6
    3. Style – 4
    4. Romance – 5
    5. Excitement – 8
    6. Brass – 7
    7. Suspense – 5
    8. Iconography – 2
    9. Epicness – 6
    10. Timelessness - 8

    56/100

    Die Another Day, 2002

    1. Implementation of the Theme Song – 6
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 7
    3. Style – 4
    4. Romance – 4
    5. Excitement – 7
    6. Brass – 6
    7. Suspense – 5
    8. Iconography – 2
    9. Epicness – 5
    10. Timelessness - 7

    53/100
  • edited April 2016 Posts: 4,045
    Goldeneye

    1. Implementation of the Theme Song – 8
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 7
    3. Style – 7
    4. Romance – 8
    5. Excitement – 9
    6. Brass – 6
    7. Suspense – 7
    8. Iconography – 6
    9. Epicness – 7
    10. Timelessness – 7

    Final Score: 72%

    Tomorrow Never Dies

    1. Implementation of the Theme Song – 6
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 8
    3. Style – 7
    4. Romance – 7
    5. Excitement – 9
    6. Brass – 7
    7. Suspense – 7
    8. Iconography – 6
    9. Epicness – 6
    10. Timelessness – 7

    Final Score: 70%

    The World Is Not Enough

    1. Implementation of the Theme Song – 7
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 6
    3. Style – 7
    4. Romance – 6
    5. Excitement – 6
    6. Brass – 6
    7. Suspense – 8
    8. Iconography – 7
    9. Epicness – 7
    10. Timelessness – 7

    Final Score: 67%

    Die Another Day

    1. Implementation of the Theme Song – 4
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 6
    3. Style – 6
    4. Romance – 6
    5. Excitement – 8
    6. Brass – 6
    7. Suspense – 6
    8. Iconography – 6
    9. Epicness – 6
    10. Timelessness – 6

    Final Score: 60%

    vzok ratings:

    OHMSS - 93
    Moonraker - 92
    A View To A Kill - 92
    Diamonds - 89
    You Only Live Twice - 84
    The Living Daylights - 82
    Live And Let Die - 81
    Spy Who Loved Me - 79
    From Russia - 76
    CR67 - 75
    Thunderball - 75
    Licence To Kill - 74
    Goldfinger - 73
    Goldeneye - 72
    Tomorrow ND - 70
    Golden Gun - 67
    World Is Not Enough - 67
    FYEO - 64
    Die Another Day - 60
    Dr No - 56
    NSNA - 17
  • Posts: 1,009
    Tomorrow Never Dies:


    1. Implementation of the Theme Song – 8 (TND (or better, Until That Day) is beautifully scored and performed by Sheryl Crow, but it ends up being boring and repetitive. Surrender is a better song than TND, K.D. Lang performs it with energy, sounds tremendously Bondian and is used throghout the soundtrack as a good action theme).
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 10 (shocking, truly shocking and rocking: David Arnold and Moby offer us one of the best renditions of the Bond Theme, which was not made for this film but included in it for our listening pleasure. The soundtrack also contains a version of the Theme with cues of Surrender and some Mancini-like arrangements. And an orchestral one for the Bike Chase).
    3. Style – 7 (good and varied, if unoriginal: at times it sounds like Arnold tried too hard to emulate John Barry, even using cues from Barry's soundtracks - FRWL and OHMSS on White Knight, GF and DAF on Surrender. On other parts, Arnold goes Serra and sounds as funky as him: check Backseat Driver to see how well Arnold orchestral work sounds with an electropop beat by the leader of The Propellerheads).
    4. Romance – 10 (oh, Paris and Bond. It's brief -under two minutes - but one of the loveliest themes in all the saga. So romantic and at the same time epic. We hear it again with some re-arrangements, too).
    5. Excitement – 9 (the action themes are tremendous)
    6. Brass –6 (only used if completely necessary, showcasing the jazzy influences of John Barry on David Arnold).
    7. Suspense – 8 (correct. Not chilling nor original but enough to accompany the action nicely).
    8. Iconography – 7 (for today's standards, it sounds average)
    9. Epicness – 9 (while it's not the funniest score ever, this soundtrack has some grandeur in it)
    10. Timelessness - 9 (as I said it sounds average nowadays, but works like this one paved the way to action soundtracks in the 21st Century. Just compare this with a soundtrack from the Metal Gear saga).

    83/100 %: Works both as a movie soundtrack and as a tribute to John Barry.

    Now, for another logo:

    MGM/UA Communications (1987-1990): 7. Sure you have seen this one on old VHS tapes. That one with the foggy letters zooming in. Looks like the composer of the jingle is unknown, but his/her piece is easy to remember: some deep resounding drums and a synth fanfare with some sound effects that sounds like it's been taken from a videogame. Not a very original piece, but sometimes keeping it easy is for the better: a corporate image has to be easy to remember. I mean, remember the Cannon Films logo? It was so simple, yet somewhat catchy and easy to remember. This one is stuff like that,

    And then the logo segued into the MGM lion or...

    United Artists (1987-1993): 7. A blue (sometimes silver), shiny (there are some exceptions wher it's plain blue), modernized UA logo zooms in and a light streak decorates it. All the while, a haunting, somber but somewhat relaxing whooshing sound followed a synthetized choir could be heard. And this is it: without being spectacvular or pure eye candy, it looks well, sounds well and cinema geeks remember it: works perfectly.
  • royale65royale65 Caustic misanthrope reporting for duty.
    Posts: 4,423
    Thanks chaps! And thank you @DarthDimi for "encouraging". You don't want to get on the wrong side of Dimi....
  • edited May 2016 Posts: 1,009
    I'm not posting the next two soundtracks because I have no time to review then. See you on Casino Royale, lads!
  • DarthDimiDarthDimi Behind you!Moderator
    Posts: 24,266
    @royale65

    Sir, this thread means more to me than a coconut to a monkey. So I'm consistently at your service here. *takes a deep bow*
  • pachazopachazo Make Your Choice
    Posts: 7,314
    I'm hoping to have mine finished soon...
  • royale65royale65 Caustic misanthrope reporting for duty.
    Posts: 4,423
    Well, I was just about to do the maths, but I'll find something else do to for the time being.

    @DarthDimi - you flatter me sir.
  • pachazopachazo Make Your Choice
    Posts: 7,314
    Thank you. You're alright in my book, no matter what Dimi says about you!
    So, I kind of rushed through this, but I really wanted to participate so it'll have to do.

    GoldenEye

    1. Implementation of the Theme Song – 5
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 6
    3. Style – 4
    4. Romance – 6
    5. Excitement – 6
    6. Brass – 4
    7. Suspense – 6
    8. Iconography – 6
    9. Epicness – 7
    10. Timelessness – 4

    Final Score - 54%


    Tomorrow Never Dies


    1. Implementation of the Theme Song – 7
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 7
    3. Style – 5
    4. Romance – 6
    5. Excitement – 7
    6. Brass – 7
    7. Suspense – 7
    8. Iconography – 5
    9. Epicness – 6
    10. Timelessness – 7

    Final Score - 64%


    The World Is Not Enough


    1. Implementation of the Theme Song – 6
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 7
    3. Style – 6
    4. Romance – 6
    5. Excitement – 7
    6. Brass – 5
    7. Suspense – 8
    8. Iconography – 5
    9. Epicness – 6
    10. Timelessness – 5

    Final Score - 61%


    Die Another Day

    1. Implementation of the Theme Song – 5
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 5
    3. Style – 5
    4. Romance – 5
    5. Excitement – 6
    6. Brass – 5
    7. Suspense – 6
    8. Iconography – 5
    9. Epicness – 6
    10. Timelessness – 5

    Final Score - 53%


    pachazo's picks

    1) YOLT - 93%
    2) OHMSS - 92%
    3) AVTAK - 90%
    4) DAF - 87%
    5) TB - 83%
    6) GF - 82%
    7) LALD - 80%
    8) MR -79%
    9) TSWLM - 75%
    10) TLD - 74%
    11) FRWL - 73%
    12) OP - 72%
    13) FYEO - 71%
    14) TMWTGG - 67%
    15) TND - 64%
    16) TWINE - 61%
    17) GE - 54%
    18) DAD - 53%
    19) DN - 52%
    20) LTK - 50%
  • royale65royale65 Caustic misanthrope reporting for duty.
    Posts: 4,423
    Thanks! Now for my roast dinner, then I'll pop the results up.
  • CraigMooreOHMSSCraigMooreOHMSS Dublin, Ireland
    edited May 2016 Posts: 8,236

    GoldenEye

    1. Implementation of the Theme Song – 5
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 6
    3. Style – 6
    4. Romance – 7
    5. Excitement – 7
    6. Brass – 5
    7. Suspense – 7
    8. Iconography – 6
    9. Epicness – 7
    10. Timelessness – 5

    Final Score - 61%


    Tomorrow Never Dies

    1. Implementation of the Theme Song – 8
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 8
    3. Style – 8
    4. Romance – 8
    5. Excitement – 8
    6. Brass – 9
    7. Suspense – 7
    8. Iconography – 7
    9. Epicness – 8
    10. Timelessness – 8

    Final Score - 79%


    The World Is Not Enough

    1. Implementation of the Theme Song – 8
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 8
    3. Style – 8
    4. Romance – 7
    5. Excitement – 8
    6. Brass – 8
    7. Suspense – 8
    8. Iconography – 7
    9. Epicness – 8
    10. Timelessness – 8

    Final Score - 78%


    Die Another Day

    1. Implementation of the Theme Song – 6
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 8
    3. Style – 7
    4. Romance – 8
    5. Excitement – 8
    6. Brass – 7
    7. Suspense – 7
    8. Iconography – 7
    9. Epicness – 8
    10. Timelessness – 7

    Final Score - 73%
  • royale65royale65 Caustic misanthrope reporting for duty.
    Posts: 4,423
    Community Scores -
    On Her Majesty's Secret Service – 95.08%
    A View To A Kill – 89.75%
    You Only Live Twice – 89.72%
    Moonraker - 86.27%
    Goldfinger – 86%
    Diamonds Are Forever – 85.4%
    Thunderball – 85.08%
    The Living Daylights – 83.83%
    Octopussy - 81.09%
    The Spy Who Loved Me – 79.7%
    Live and Let Die - 79.6%
    From Russia With Love – 77.5%
    Tomorrow Never Dies – 74%
    The Man With The Golden Gun – 72.4%
    The World Is Not Enough – 72.18%
    For Your Eyes Only – 71.27%
    Casino Royale '67 – 70.87%
    Licence to Kill – 68.66%
    Die Another Day – 66.81%
    GoldenEye – 63.58%

    Dr. No – 51.45%
    Never Say Never Again – 29.75%


    Actually, considering how divisive a figure that Arnold is on these boards, I'm not too unhappy with these results.

    See you later for the next 'un...

    James Bond will return...
  • royale65royale65 Caustic misanthrope reporting for duty.
    Posts: 4,423
    Well the Brosnan era went surprisingly well – we received the same amount of voters as the “1 film per week” approach. So to round this particular series up, here's the -

    The Craig Era

    Casino Royale, 2006

    1. Theme Song – 10 (bloody brilliant. Set the scene for the entire raw movie)
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 10 (Yes, a ten! This is a Bonds origins story, and that way that the theme is woven sparingly into the score is just superb. Plus that end scene...)
    3. Style – 9
    4. Romance – 9
    5. Excitement – 9
    6. Brass – 8
    7. Suspense – 8
    8. Iconography – 8
    9. Epicness – 9
    10. Timelessness – 9

    89/100


    Quantum of Solace, 2008

    1. Theme Song – 7 (So sue me, I like this song.)
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 7 (this time, this is not an origins story, so there is no reason to skip or the theme)
    3. Style – 8 (an evolving sound from Arnold)
    4. Romance – 8
    5. Excitement – 8
    6. Brass – 8
    7. Suspense – 9
    8. Iconography – 7
    9. Epicness – 7
    10. Timelessness – 8

    77/100


    Skyfall, 2012

    1. Theme Song – 8
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 5 (just the scene with the DB5, and that was Arnold's cover!)
    3. Style – 9
    4. Romance – 8
    5. Excitement – 7 (not the most exciting of scores)
    6. Brass – 7
    7. Suspense – 8
    8. Iconography – 7
    9. Epicness – 7
    10. Timelessness – 8 (can't see it dating, although the use of ambient sounds in say “Shanghai Drive”, let's say, may catch up with)

    74/100


    Spectre, 2015

    1. Theme Song – 6 (works better in conjunction with the main titles)
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 3
    3. Style – 7 (the use of SF's themes grate a bit)
    4. Romance – 9 (just love Dr. Swann's motif)
    5. Excitement – 7
    6. Brass – 7
    7. Suspense – 8
    8. Iconography – 7
    9. Epicness – 8 (I'm thinking of the choir when the cars drive past the Colosseum.)
    10. Timelessness – 8

    70/100


    royale's Rankings -

    On Her Majesty's Secret Service – 98%
    You Only Live Twice – 94%
    Goldfinger – 94%
    The Living Daylights – 90%
    Moonraker – 90%
    Diamonds Are Forever 90%
    Casino Royale – 89%
    Thunderball – 89%
    The Spy Who Loved Me – 85%
    A View To A Kill – 84%
    Octopussy – 83%
    From Russia With Love – 83%
    Live and Let Die – 81%
    For Your Eyes Only – 79%
    Tomorrow Never Dies – 77%
    Licence to Kill – 77%
    Quantum of Solace – 77%
    Skyfall – 74%

    The World Is Not Enough – 74%
    Die Another Day – 73%
    Spectre – 70%
    The Man With The Golden Gun – 69%
    Dr. No – 69%   
    Casino Royale, '67 – 62% 
    GoldenEye – 56%
    Never Say Never Again – 38%

    I do hope that isn't too much bother for you chaps to complete.
    Hmm, just shows how badly we miss Barry.
  • CraigMooreOHMSSCraigMooreOHMSS Dublin, Ireland
    Posts: 8,236
    The Craig Era

    Casino Royale, 2006

    1. Theme Song – 9
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 9
    3. Style – 9
    4. Romance – 9
    5. Excitement – 9
    6. Brass – 9
    7. Suspense – 8
    8. Iconography – 8
    9. Epicness – 9
    10. Timelessness – 9

    88/100


    Quantum of Solace

    1. Theme Song – 6
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 8
    3. Style – 9
    4. Romance – 8
    5. Excitement – 9
    6. Brass – 8
    7. Suspense – 9
    8. Iconography – 7
    9. Epicness – 7
    10. Timelessness – 8

    79/100


    Skyfall

    1. Theme Song – 9
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 7
    3. Style – 8
    4. Romance – 7
    5. Excitement – 7
    6. Brass – 7
    7. Suspense – 8
    8. Iconography – 6
    9. Epicness – 6
    10. Timelessness – 7

    72/100


    Spectre

    1. Theme Song – 5
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 7
    3. Style – 7
    4. Romance – 9
    5. Excitement – 7
    6. Brass – 7
    7. Suspense – 7
    8. Iconography – 7
    9. Epicness – 8
    10. Timelessness – 7

    71/100

    We're pretty close with our rankings here, @royale65!
  • GBFGBF
    Posts: 3,198
    The Craig Era

    Casino Royale, 2006

    1. Theme Song – 10
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 7
    3. Style – 7
    4. Romance – 6
    5. Excitement – 8
    6. Brass – 7
    7. Suspense – 6
    8. Iconography – 7
    9. Epicness – 7
    10. Timelessness – 8

    73/100


    Quantum of Solace

    1. Theme Song – 5
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 7
    3. Style – 7
    4. Romance – 7
    5. Excitement – 6
    6. Brass – 7
    7. Suspense – 8
    8. Iconography – 6
    9. Epicness – 5
    10. Timelessness – 7

    65/100


    Skyfall

    1. Theme Song – 10
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 6
    3. Style – 8
    4. Romance – 6
    5. Excitement – 8
    6. Brass – 8
    7. Suspense – 9
    8. Iconography – 7
    9. Epicness – 7
    10. Timelessness – 8

    77/100


    Spectre

    1. Theme Song – 4
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 6
    3. Style – 8
    4. Romance – 6
    5. Excitement – 7
    6. Brass – 6
    7. Suspense – 6
    8. Iconography – 7
    9. Epicness – 7
    10. Timelessness – 7

    64/100
  • GoldenGunGoldenGun Per ora e per il momento che verrà
    edited May 2016 Posts: 7,222
    Casino Royale

    1. Theme Song – 7
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 7
    3. Style – 7
    4. Romance – 9
    5. Excitement - 7
    6. Brass – 6
    7. Suspense – 7
    8. Iconography – 7
    9. Epicness – 6
    10. Timelessness – 7

    Overall: 70%

    Quantum of Solace

    1. Theme Song – 6
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 7
    3. Style – 9
    4. Romance – 8
    5. Excitement - 7
    6. Brass – 7
    7. Suspense – 9
    8. Iconography – 9
    9. Epicness – 7
    10. Timelessness – 7

    Overall: 76%


    Skyfall

    1. Theme Song – 8
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 7
    3. Style – 8
    4. Romance – 7
    5. Excitement - 8
    6. Brass – 6
    7. Suspense – 8
    8. Iconography – 7
    9. Epicness – 7
    10. Timelessness – 7

    Overall: 73%

    Spectre

    1. Theme Song – 3
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 6
    3. Style – 5
    4. Romance – 5
    5. Excitement - 6
    6. Brass – 4
    7. Suspense – 4
    8. Iconography – 4
    9. Epicness – 5
    10. Timelessness – 5

    Overall: 47%

    On Her Majesty's Secret Service: 97%
    The Living Daylights: 94%
    You Only Live Twice: 93%
    A View to a Kill: 88%
    Thunderball: 85%
    The Spy Who Loved Me: 82%
    Moonraker: 81%
    Licence to Kill: 80%
    GoldenEye: 78%
    Diamonds Are Forever: 78%
    From Russia with Love: 78%
    Goldfinger: 77%
    Tomorrow Never Dies: 77%
    Octopussy: 77%
    The Man with the Golden Gun: 77%
    Quantum of Solace: 76%
    The World Is Not Enough 76%
    Live and Let Die: 75%
    Skyfall: 73%
    Casino Royale: 70%
    For Your Eyes Only: 68%
    Die Another Day: 64%
    Dr. No: 49%
    Spectre: 47%

    QOS is definitely my favourite Craig score, I'd say it's probably Arnold's best Bond work but the title song just drags it under TND and on par with TWINE.

    CR and SF are ok music scores, with some fine cues and some lesser ones in there.

    SP on the other hand appears to be my least favourite of the bunch with only 47%. Unsurprisingly the atrocious whining of Sam Smith doesn't help either.
  • Posts: 4,045
    I think you mean Oscar winning atrocious whining....
  • GoldenGunGoldenGun Per ora e per il momento che verrà
    Posts: 7,222
    vzok wrote: »
    I think you mean Oscar winning atrocious whining....

    Well, I've seen lots of poor stuff win Oscars. I won't lose my sleep over it.
  • Posts: 4,045
    GoldenGun wrote: »
    vzok wrote: »
    I think you mean Oscar winning atrocious whining....


    Well, I've seen lots of poor stuff win Oscars. I won't lose my sleep over it.

    You will if you listen to it.
  • Posts: 4,325
    Casino Royale, 2006

    1. Theme Song – 8
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 7
    3. Style – 8
    4. Romance – 8
    5. Excitement - 8
    6. Brass – 6
    7. Suspense – 8
    8. Iconography – 8
    9. Epicness – 8
    10. Timelessness – 8

    77%

    Quantum of Solace, 2008

    1. Theme Song – 6
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 5
    3. Style – 8
    4. Romance – 6
    5. Excitement - 8
    6. Brass – 6
    7. Suspense – 8
    8. Iconography – 7
    9. Epicness – 8
    10. Timelessness – 8

    70%

    Skyfall, 2012

    1. Theme Song – 10
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 3
    3. Style – 7
    4. Romance – 5
    5. Excitement - 8
    6. Brass – 4
    7. Suspense – 8
    8. Iconography – 7
    9. Epicness – 8
    10. Timelessness – 6

    66%

    Spectre, 2015

    1. Theme Song – 7
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 2
    3. Style – 7
    4. Romance – 6
    5. Excitement - 7
    6. Brass – 5
    7. Suspense – 6
    8. Iconography – 5
    9. Epicness – 7
    10. Timelessness – 4

    56%

    Tanaka123 Rankings

    You Only Live Twice - 89%
    Goldfinger - 86%/ On Her Majesty's Secret Service - 86%
    Thunderball - 81%/ Moonraker - 81% / The Living Daylights - 81%
    Diamonds Are Forever - 79%
    Octopussy - 77% / Casino Royale - 77%
    Live and Let Die - 75% / A View to a Kill - 75%
    From Russia with Love - 74% / For Your Eyes Only - 74%
    The Spy Who Loved Me - 73%
    Tomorrow Never Dies - 71%
    Quantum of Solace - 70%
    The World is Not Enough - 68%
    The Man with the Golden Gun - 66% / GoldenEye - 66% / Skyfall - 66%
    Die Another Day - 63%
    Licence to Kill - 62%
    Spectre - 56%
    Dr. No - 52%
  • royale65royale65 Caustic misanthrope reporting for duty.
    Posts: 4,423
    @CraigMooreOHMSS - great minds etc ;-)

    Thanks for the votes chaps!
  • DarthDimiDarthDimi Behind you!Moderator
    Posts: 24,266
    Casino Royale, 2006

    1. Theme Song – 7
    2. Use of Bond Theme - 7 (I actually appreciate those slight hints...)
    3. Style – 8 (Arnold delivers this time.)
    4. Romance – 8
    5. Excitement - 8 (Miami Airport... That track brings a lot of excitement, amongst others.)
    6. Brass – 6
    7. Suspense - 9
    8. Iconography – 8
    9. Epicness – 7
    10. Timelessness – 7

    75%

    Quantum Of Solace, 2008

    1. Theme Song – 4
    2. Use of Bond Theme - 7
    3. Style – 7
    4. Romance – 8
    5. Excitement - 7
    6. Brass – 6
    7. Suspense - 6
    8. Iconography – 7
    9. Epicness – 8
    10. Timelessness – 7

    67%

    SkyFall, 2012

    1. Theme Song – 10
    2. Use of Bond Theme - 7
    3. Style – 6
    4. Romance – 7
    5. Excitement - 5
    6. Brass – 5
    7. Suspense - 6
    8. Iconography – 4
    9. Epicness – 4
    10. Timelessness – 5

    59%

    Spectre, 2015

    1. Theme Song – 7
    2. Use of Bond Theme - 8
    3. Style – 7
    4. Romance – 9
    5. Excitement - 8
    6. Brass – 8
    7. Suspense - 7
    8. Iconography – 6
    9. Epicness – 5
    10. Timelessness – 5

    70%

    DD's Rankings

    Never Say Never Again - 17%
    Dr. No – 57%
    Skyfall - 59%
    For Your Eyes Only - 60%
    Live And Let Die - 61%
    GoldenEye - 65%
    The World Is Not Enough - 66%
    Casino Royale '67 - 66%
    Quantum Of Solace - 67%
    Die Another Day - 68%
    The Spy Who Loved Me - 70%
    Spectre - 70%
    TomorrowNeverDies - 74%
    The Man With The Golden Gun - 75%
    Octopussy - 75%
    Casino Royale - 75%
    Licence To Kill - 76%
    From Russia With Love - 77%
    Moonraker - 81%
    Goldfinger - 82%
    Thunderball - 83%
    You Only Live Twice - 85%
    A View To A Kill - 87%
    On Her Majesty's Secret Service - 89%
    Diamonds Are Forever - 93%
    The Living Daylights - 94%

  • Posts: 4,045
    Casino Royale

    1. Implementation of the Theme Song – 9
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 7
    3. Style – 7
    4. Romance – 7
    5. Excitement – 8
    6. Brass – 6
    7. Suspense – 8
    8. Iconography – 6
    9. Epicness – 7
    10. Timelessness – 7

    Final Score: 72%

    Quantum Of Solace

    1. Implementation of the Theme Song – 4
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 6
    3. Style – 7
    4. Romance – 7
    5. Excitement – 8
    6. Brass – 6
    7. Suspense – 7
    8. Iconography – 6
    9. Epicness – 7
    10. Timelessness – 7

    Final Score: 65%

    Skyfall

    1. Implementation of the Theme Song – 9
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 6
    3. Style – 7
    4. Romance – 7
    5. Excitement – 7
    6. Brass – 6
    7. Suspense – 7
    8. Iconography – 7
    9. Epicness – 7
    10. Timelessness – 7

    Final Score: 70%

    Spectre

    1. Implementation of the Theme Song – 2
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 5
    3. Style – 7
    4. Romance – 7
    5. Excitement – 8
    6. Brass – 6
    7. Suspense – 7
    8. Iconography – 6
    9. Epicness – 8
    10. Timelessness – 7

    Final Score: 63%

    vzok ratings:

    OHMSS - 93
    Moonraker - 92
    A View To A Kill - 92
    Diamonds - 89
    You Only Live Twice - 84
    The Living Daylights - 82
    Live And Let Die - 81
    Spy Who Loved Me - 79
    From Russia - 76
    CR67 - 75
    Thunderball - 75
    Licence To Kill - 74
    Goldfinger - 73
    Goldeneye - 72
    Casino Royale - 72
    Tomorrow ND - 70
    Skyfall - 70
    Golden Gun - 67
    World Is Not Enough - 67
    Quantum Of Solace - 65
    FYEO - 64
    Spectre - 63
    Die Another Day - 60
    Dr No - 56
    NSNA - 17
  • royale65royale65 Caustic misanthrope reporting for duty.
    Posts: 4,423
    Last chance to vote. I'll be rounding this 'un up either Sunday, or Monday. Perhaps Tuesday.
  • MayDayDiVicenzoMayDayDiVicenzo Here and there
    Posts: 5,080
    Casino Royale

    1. Implementation of the Theme Song – 7
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 6
    3. Style – 5
    4. Romance – 8
    5. Excitement – 7
    6. Brass – 4
    7. Suspense – 5
    8. Iconography – 4
    9. Epicness – 6
    10. Timelessness – 9

    Final Score: 61%

    Quantum Of Solace

    1. Implementation of the Theme Song – 4
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 2
    3. Style – 8
    4. Romance – 4
    5. Excitement – 8
    6. Brass – 6
    7. Suspense – 7
    8. Iconography – 7
    9. Epicness – 7
    10. Timelessness – 9

    Final Score: 62%

    Skyfall

    1. Implementation of the Theme Song – 2
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 5
    3. Style – 5
    4. Romance – 4
    5. Excitement – 9
    6. Brass – 5
    7. Suspense – 8
    8. Iconography – 5
    9. Epicness – 8
    10. Timelessness – 8

    Final Score: 59%

    Spectre

    1. Implementation of the Theme Song – 2
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 5
    3. Style – 3
    4. Romance – 5
    5. Excitement – 5
    6. Brass – 4
    7. Suspense – 6
    8. Iconography – 3
    9. Epicness – 5
    10. Timelessness – 7

    Final Score: 45%

    MayDay's final score ranking-
    1. OHMSS- 98%
    2. MR- 96%
    3. AVTAK- 95%
    4. YOLT- 92%
    6/5. GF/TLD- 91%
    7. FYEO- 90%
    8. OP- 89%
    9. TSWLM- 87%
    10. LALD- 82%
    11. DAF- 79%
    13/12. FRWL, TB- 78%
    14. TMWTGG- 74%
    15. LTK- 63%
    17/16. CR'67, QOS- 62%
    18. CR- 61%
    19. GE- 60%
    20. SF- 59%
    21. TND- 58%
    22. TWINE- 56%
    23. DAD- 53%
    24. SP- 45%
    25. DN- 42%
    26. NSNA- 22%

  • edited May 2016 Posts: 1,009
    I decided to let it pass by. I'm so eager to see the finished ranking!
  • Posts: 3,336
    Casino Royale

    1. Implementation of the Theme Song – 9
    2. Use of Bond Theme – 9
    3. Style – 8
    4. Romance – 9
    5. Excitement – 8
    6. Brass – 8
    7. Suspense – 7
    8. Iconography – 7
    9. Epicness – 8
    10. Timelessness – 9

    82/100
    82%
  • royale65royale65 Caustic misanthrope reporting for duty.
    Posts: 4,423
    Smeg on a cracker, it's the final round up!

    Community Scores -
    On Her Majesty's Secret Service – 95.08%
    A View To A Kill – 89.75%
    You Only Live Twice – 89.72%
    Moonraker - 86.27%
    Goldfinger – 86%
    Diamonds Are Forever – 85.4%
    Thunderball – 85.08%
    The Living Daylights – 83.83%
    Octopussy - 81.09%
    The Spy Who Loved Me – 79.7%
    Live and Let Die - 79.6%
    From Russia With Love – 77.5%
    Casino Royale - 76.33%
    Tomorrow Never Dies – 74%
    The Man With The Golden Gun – 72.4%
    The World Is Not Enough – 72.18%
    For Your Eyes Only – 71.27%
    Casino Royale '67 – 70.87%
    Quantum of Solace – 70.01%
    Skyfall - 68.75%
    Licence to Kill – 68.66%
    Die Another Day – 66.81%
    GoldenEye – 63.58%
    Spectre - 60.75%
    Dr. No – 51.45%
    Never Say Never Again – 29.75%

    Despite the lackluster performance on CR, the rest of the Craig era is as expected. And SP, only ahead on DN and NSNA. Ouch.

    I didn't expect AVTAK to be so high, but OHMSS I kinda did. A most worthy experiment and results, methinks.

    What do you think?

    Thanks to everyone who contributed to this thread. I salute you!
  • DarthDimiDarthDimi Behind you!Moderator
    Posts: 24,266
    Interesting results, @royale65!
    Thank you for hosting this show :)
  • royale65royale65 Caustic misanthrope reporting for duty.
    edited May 2016 Posts: 4,423
    Cheers old boy. Tell me @DarthDimi, were there any surprises for you?
Sign In or Register to comment.