BOND POLLS 2016: The Top 10 JAMES BOND-007 Film Ranking Contest (Results: winner!, on page 60)

191012141559

Comments

  • GoldenGunGoldenGun Per ora e per il momento che verrà
    Posts: 7,108
    So when you reach 100, can we have a look at the current rankings?
  • MrBondMrBond Station S
    edited September 2016 Posts: 2,044
    12 POINTS: On Her Majesty's Secret Service
    10 POINTS: Quantum of Solace
    08 POINTS: Casino Royale
    07 POINTS: Thunderball
    06 POINTS: Goldfinger
    05 POINTS: The Spy Who Loved Me
    04 POINTS: Spectre
    03 POINTS: Dr. No
    02 POINTS: The Man With The Golden Gun
    01 POINTS: Octopussy
  • MrBond wrote: »
    12 POINTS: On Her Majesty's Secret Service
    10 POINTS: Quantum of Solace
    08 POINTS: Casino Royale
    07 POINTS: Thunderball
    06 POINTS: Goldfinger
    05 POINTS: The Spy Who Loved Me
    04 POINTS: Spectre
    03 POINTS: Dr. No
    02 POINTS: The Man With The Golden Gun
    01 POINTS: Octopussy

    Hs anyone heard of the SpyCommand Blog from Bill Koenig? :-)
  • ShardlakeShardlake Leeds, West Yorkshire, England
    Posts: 4,043
    12 POINTS: OHMSS
    10 POINTS: Casino Royale
    08 POINTS: Skyfall
    07 POINTS: FRWL
    06 POINTS: TSWLM
    05 POINTS: TB
    04 POINTS: TLD
    03 POINTS: QOS
    02 POINTS: LTK
    01 POINT: DN
  • SuperintendentSuperintendent A separate pool. For sharks, no less.
    Posts: 871
    Benny wrote: »
    Well I guess this is mine...

    12 points Dr.No
    10 points On Her Majesty's Secret Service
    8 points From Russia With Love
    7 points Octopussy
    6 points The Living Daylights
    5 points Casino Royale
    4 points Goldfinger
    3 points The Spy Who Loved Me
    2 points Thunderball
    1 point For Your Eyes Only

    We share the same films in our top ten, @Benny.
  • Birdleson wrote: »
    Sadly, GF has been missing over the past page or more.

    I'll remedy that.

    12 points - Thunderball
    10 points - Goldfinger
    8 points - From Russia With Love
    7 points - GoldenEye
    6 points - Casino Royale
    5 points - Dr. No
    4 points - The Spy Who Loved Me
    3 points - Octopussy
    2 points - The Living Daylights
    1 point - Skyfall

    Lots of relative ties here so I just picked.
  • Score totals after 79 voters. It seems one film is running away now with 1st place......for now:

    TOP 6, the masterpieces:
    #01 placed Bond Film --> 590 POINTS
    #02 placed Bond Film --> 549 POINTS
    #03 placed Bond Film --> 502 POINTS
    #04 placed Bond Film --> 360 POINTS
    #05 placed Bond Film --> 290 POINTS
    #06 placed Bond Film --> 288 POINTS

    Remainder TOP 15, the good ones:
    #07 placed Bond Film --> 238 POINTS
    #08 placed Bond Film --> 225 POINTS
    #09 placed Bond Film --> 193 POINTS
    #10 placed Bond Film --> 184 POINTS
    #11 placed Bond Film --> 182 POINTS
    #12 placed Bond Film --> 154 POINTS
    #13 placed Bond Film --> 143 POINTS
    #14 placed Bond Film --> 142 POINTS
    #15 placed Bond Film --> 109 POINTS

    Remainder TOP 21, the really average ones:
    #16 placed Bond Film --> 091 POINTS
    #17 placed Bond Film --> 067 POINTS
    #18 placed Bond Film --> 055 POINTS
    #19 placed Bond Film --> 054 POINTS
    #20 placed Bond Film --> 049 POINTS
    #21 placed Bond Film --> 039 POINTS

    The ruthless BOTTOM 5:
    #22 placed Bond Film --> 031 POINTS
    #23 placed Bond Film --> 029 POINTS
    #24 placed Bond Film --> 014 POINTS
    #25 placed Bond Film --> 000 POINTS
    #25 placed Bond Film --> 000 POINTS

    Keep voting guys & gals :-).
  • Posts: 4,044
    Really 4-6 are a lot closer to the other good ones that the top 3 masterpieces.
  • vzok wrote: »
    Really 4-6 are a lot closer to the other good ones that the top 3 masterpieces.

    But the gap between #6 and #7 is pretty big. I also look at the number of times a Bond film gets points, as opposed to getting some outlier '12's, 10's and 8's. Having said that, I consider the TOP 6 the 'masterpiece society' when it comes to Bond films. It's the elite club.

    By the way, I am stunned about the intense dislike of non-EON film NSNA. If you like it or not, it's a Bond film, in which Connery plays Bond a 7th time. And looking at the acting performances of Klaus-Maria Brandauer and Barbara Carrera the film doesn't deserve a treatment like this.



  • Birdleson wrote: »
    @Gustav_Graves , you may want to go back and count again. Out of curiosity to see how my favorite was doing, GF, I went back to the beginning and started to total it's score. After the fourth page my number didn't coincide with any of the totals you showed in your tallies. By the end it was way off. I've done it twice. Maybe there were doubles entries that you caught and I didn't, or some other such thing, but I'm just making you aware.

    There were like four instances of people who wanted to vote and couldn't get access in here to post it. I have them included as well. There was one instance of a forummember who posted the results from some of his/her friends for instance. Also, my parents want to vote as well, but they are not able to log in, due to some problems (I have informed @Samuel001 about that already).

    I suggest you let me do the counting, and don't dig in too deep in the total tallies just yet. I have my Excel grid in front of me. I am mildly autistic, so that means perfectionism from my side times 100 :-). For the sake of other people who are thinking of voting, let's not try to strategically influence the voting by hoping your favorite gets more votes. And even if that's not the case, people do read your message and could be influenced.

    Lastly, after 79 voters, it becomes more and more impossible in the TOP 10 to rise a few spots, if there's a huge points gap of let's say 40 to 300 points. It's what it is :-).

    Be patient for the end results ;-). In any case, thank you for being so into the details. It keeps me sharp as well.
  • edited September 2016 Posts: 4,044
    Perhaps if you are including other people's scores you can type them in here for them so we can all see their top 10s.

    Can we all include family/friend's scores? I know at least one Bond fan who would like to vote here.
  • BennyBenny Shaken not stirredAdministrator, Moderator
    Posts: 15,128

    We share the same films in our top ten, @Benny.


    <:-P

    Well, here's to us. We are the best!
    ;)
  • ThunderfingerThunderfinger Das Boot Hill
    Posts: 45,489
    vzok wrote: »
    Perhaps if you are including other people's scores you can type them in here for them so we can all see their top 10s.

    Can we all include family/friend's scores? I know at least one Bond fan who would like to vote here.

    Yes, it has been done. It s a way for you to make lists up.
  • w2bondw2bond is indeed a very rare breed
    Posts: 2,252
    Even of that's the case I doubt it will affect the final results that much
  • edited September 2016 Posts: 6,432
    It makes sense to just include the votes of forum members in the poll?

    Spectre-James-Bond-Easter-Egg-Dead-Agent-Names.jpg

    We don't want a situation where these people are casting votes ;))
  • TheWizardOfIceTheWizardOfIce 'One of the Internet's more toxic individuals'
    edited September 2016 Posts: 9,117
    By the way, I am stunned about the intense dislike of non-EON film NSNA. If you like it or not, it's a Bond film, in which Connery plays Bond a 7th time. And looking at the acting performances of Klaus-Maria Brandauer and Barbara Carrera the film doesn't deserve a treatment like this.

    Stunned? Why?

    By specifying we choose a top 10 you are pretty much condemning NSNA to get a tiny amount of votes. This does not prove intense dislike on the part of majority of Bond fans. It just proves that NSNA isn't top 10 material, which I could have told you before the vote started.

    I agree with you that Sean, KMB and Barbara Carrera all make NSNA a decent enough watch, although it is substandard to 99% of EON's output in every other department. Has a few good one liners though. I certainly don't hate but it's never getting near the top 10. Or indeed the top 20.
    It makes sense to just include the votes of forum members in the poll?

    Spectre-James-Bond-Easter-Egg-Dead-Agent-Names.jpg

    We don't want a situation where these people are casting votes ;))

    Quite. Why not just open it out to the general public and then GF will win?
  • Including votes beyond the forum makes the poll null and void, in a public vote Goldfinger would win for sure with Skyfail a close second.
  • edited September 2016 Posts: 11,119
    Including votes beyond the forum makes the poll null and void, in a public vote Goldfinger would win for sure with Skyfail a close second.

    I run a similar poll last year, October 2015, with similar voting procedures on IMDB last year. And I can assure you.....Goldfinger did not manage to win top spot. Far from it:

    Final_Results_IMDB_TOP_10_CONTEST_Best_Bond.jpg
    Final_Results_IMDB_TOP_10_CONTEST_Best_Bond.jpg

    So please guys? Can we please stop the presumptions? Voting is going well, the topic is popular, and the poll is therefore NOT 'null' or 'void'.
  • edited September 2016 Posts: 6,432
    I was referring more to the nation wide voting in England, Goldfinger over the decades often finishes top.
  • I was referring more to the nation wide voting in England, Goldfinger over the decades often finishes top.

    Okay, but that does tell you something no? 'Nation wide' poll? As opposed to frantic movie nerds (IMDB) and Bond nerds (in here)? I know which people have slightly more knowledge about movies. Perhaps, in the nation wide poll there was a bit of 'Brexit' slipping into the vote :-P.
  • Including votes beyond the forum makes the poll null and void, in a public vote Goldfinger would win for sure with Skyfail a close second.

    I run a similar poll last year, October 2015, with similar voting procedures on IMDB last year. And I can assure you.....Goldfinger did not manage to win top spot. Far from it:

    Final_Results_IMDB_TOP_10_CONTEST_Best_Bond.jpg
    Final_Results_IMDB_TOP_10_CONTEST_Best_Bond.jpg

    So please guys? Can we please stop the presumptions? Voting is going well, the topic is popular, and the poll is therefore NOT 'null' or 'void'.
    I disagree it defeats the purpose of having a forum poll if external votes are included, the poll will no longer accurately reflect the members opinions.

  • Including votes beyond the forum makes the poll null and void, in a public vote Goldfinger would win for sure with Skyfail a close second.

    I run a similar poll last year, October 2015, with similar voting procedures on IMDB last year. And I can assure you.....Goldfinger did not manage to win top spot. Far from it:

    Final_Results_IMDB_TOP_10_CONTEST_Best_Bond.jpg
    Final_Results_IMDB_TOP_10_CONTEST_Best_Bond.jpg

    So please guys? Can we please stop the presumptions? Voting is going well, the topic is popular, and the poll is therefore NOT 'null' or 'void'.
    I disagree it defeats the purpose of having a forum poll if external votes are included, the poll will no longer accurately reflect the members opinions.

    Nonsense. Those four people who are not forum members, are looking heavily within this topic. I can assure you that. Moreover, it's still a game and perhaps you take it too seriously, all for the sake of your beloved "Goldfinger". The fact that you make a distinction between the expertise of external voters -only about four!- and forummembers is quite ridiculous.

    I know that I brought up "NSNA", but I'm was not trying to use to question people's voting preferences or knowledge. I was just surprised with the absence of any points for it so far.

    Dear @fire_and_ice? Please stop your suspicions now, or it will sooner or later derail the topic and then I'm off here.
  • ThunderfingerThunderfinger Das Boot Hill
    Posts: 45,489
    I don t doubt that. But there are people on this forum who would do just that, and who is to say who can be trusted and who can t? It s no big deal, by all means.
  • TheWizardOfIceTheWizardOfIce 'One of the Internet's more toxic individuals'
    Posts: 9,117
    So if I meet some bloke on the bus later and ask him for his top 10 Bond films I can post that up here as a valid list?
  • So if I meet some bloke on the bus later and ask him for his top 10 Bond films I can post that up here as a valid list?

    This is a fun forum man, not the US elections or Hillary's foundation. Stop the innuendo.
  • So if I meet some bloke on the bus later and ask him for his top 10 Bond films I can post that up here as a valid list?

    Aye. I've got a passel of "cousins" who are just aching for me to post their Top 10s.

  • So if I meet some bloke on the bus later and ask him for his top 10 Bond films I can post that up here as a valid list?

    Aye. I've got a passel of "cousins" who are just aching for me to post their Top 10s.

    Ask them to become a member of the forum :-).
  • SzonanaSzonana Mexico
    Posts: 1,130
    Since I don't see my votes on the list you've made till now im posting them again :

    12 POINTS: The World is not enough
    10 POINTS: Goldeneye
    08 POINTS: Die Another Day
    07 POINTS: Tomorrow never dies
    06 POINTS: Dr No
    05 POINTS: Thunderball
    04 POINTS: From Russia with Love
    03 POINTS: Casino Royale
    02 POINTS:Skyfall
    01 POINTS: Spectre
  • Szonana wrote: »
    Since I don't see my votes on the list you've made till now im posting them again :

    12 POINTS: The World is not enough
    10 POINTS: Goldeneye
    08 POINTS: Die Another Day
    07 POINTS: Tomorrow never dies
    06 POINTS: Dr No
    05 POINTS: Thunderball
    04 POINTS: From Russia with Love
    03 POINTS: Casino Royale
    02 POINTS:Skyfall
    01 POINTS: Spectre

    Hey @Szonana. That list I made was from I similar Inexecuted last year on IMDB ;-). Your votes are already included. No worries.
  • Birdleson wrote: »
    Decided to be kind.

    It's ok @Birdleson ;-). I think it's positive that other people outside this sometimes scary ring of Bond nerds is taking the first steps to visit this forum. That's the good thing of a positive-spirited topic ;-).

    We're not in the Skulls&Bones fraternity, are we ;-).
Sign In or Register to comment.