It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
^ Back to Top
The MI6 Community is unofficial and in no way associated or linked with EON Productions, MGM, Sony Pictures, Activision or Ian Fleming Publications. Any views expressed on this website are of the individual members and do not necessarily reflect those of the Community owners. Any video or images displayed in topics on MI6 Community are embedded by users from third party sites and as such MI6 Community and its owners take no responsibility for this material.
James Bond News • James Bond Articles • James Bond Magazine
Comments
CR will remain a top 5 classic for all time, SF not, it'll go down TB's path.
Glad to see TLD get into 6th!
Bring on SF next most likely (although I'd personally prefer if it was GF that we see first).
Couldn't agree more.
Solid finish for TLD, very pleased.
First place should obviously go to FRWL or OHMSS.
I totally agree @bondjames ..we have been on the same thinking on this for most of it...SF is so much better than GF....mind you so is TB,TSWLM,GE etc....
@bondjames
you can say what you want I'll always like you two, ha!
SF is better than GF, hey don't toy with my feelings...
Hence I found it pivotal to compare the totals given by @w2bond in the topic 'Bond movie ranking (simple list, no details)' on page 123........with the results so far in this topic. I guess @w2bond only looked at the most recently actualized rankings, and only those of unique voters. Here's the comparison:
I have to conclude that the rankings are strikingly similar. The change in spots you'll find on the right. It represents the change in this topic as compared to the generic Bond ranking topic. Except for TWINE and TMWTGG, not much changes (Also in the other topic, with TOP 24 ranking, TWINE continues to polarize from page 123 and onwards).
Bond films like LALD and QOS are still considered 'average' at best. And surprisingly, part of the mid table scorings, 10th place until 15th place, are identical. OP is considered Moore's 3rd best Bond film in both rankings.
It also seems that TSWLM and GE will continue to struggle entering the TOP 5 of 'Best Bond Films'. TLD is considered Dalton's best film, without a doubt.
Interesting. I'm curious why you think GF is a better Bond film than SF.....
So there is only one spot "vacant" in the other thread it was TLD in this it'll be SF.
It all depends on who will participate. This thread could have had some changes if the more avid Brosnan fans had voted which they didn't.
But that's besides the points. Both rankings -so far- are strikingly similar.
Yes ,i love TB.....and i will champion it with my trusty harpoon !!!
GF will have a special place in everyone's heart since it is, indeed, one of the most iconic Bond films. Yet, when compared with FRWL and OHMSS I think it slightlyyyy underperforms. But hey, we've arrived in the TOP 5 zone here; the zone of the 'Bond masterpieces' :-).
Just like I thought. Despite the vocal minority on certain films, general sentiment remains the same
FRWL
GF
OHMSS
TLD
GE
it only shows they all are perfect in their own way and it's incredibly difficult to make a ranking of 24 movies when practically half of them should be somewhere on top.
Really ? whenever i have been here in the past 9-10 years it has been a pain in the arse ..but i did have a hiatus about the time you mentioned @Birdleson so i will take your word for it.
SF is the only film that can knock the over-rated GF off 4th spot ..we can but hope.Put it this way,SF got quite high on my score and GF got jack-shit...