It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
^ Back to Top
The MI6 Community is unofficial and in no way associated or linked with EON Productions, MGM, Sony Pictures, Activision or Ian Fleming Publications. Any views expressed on this website are of the individual members and do not necessarily reflect those of the Community owners. Any video or images displayed in topics on MI6 Community are embedded by users from third party sites and as such MI6 Community and its owners take no responsibility for this material.
James Bond News • James Bond Articles • James Bond Magazine
Comments
My cinematic Bond will always be DN up until DAD (I could have easily said LTK though that would have been unfair as PB is the same Bond as those that preceded him).
It won't be any different to those haters on youtube who hate on everything to do with the current Doctor Who but still watch every episode, if only to go on youtube and hate some more.
The past 16 years has been filled with Craig haters....they have their own hate site, they filter in to other forums, they have nothing but scorn and contempt before they see a single frame of the film....I can only say if I don't like the NEW Bond, I'd just make a discrete exit instead of coming here and ruining every one else's appreciation for each film he makes.
I don't get why someone with a different opinion should ruin things for other people.
Scenario 1
- I like Craig.
- So do I.
- Yeah. He's great.
- Yeah.
Scenario 2
- I like Craig.
- You do? I don't.
- Hm. Let's talk.
I prefer scenario 2.
I was always skeptical about his casting, but he's such a great actor, and the films so much meatier than the Brosnan era, that I was quite happy to go along for the ride. But I wish it would have reached its final destination with Skyfall of SPECTRE.
I'm not a "Craig hater." When he was announced as Bond I thought he was perfect, even moreso after watching CR twice in theaters. Back around 2010 or so when people were saying that there might not be any more Bond movies (anyone remember that magazine cover, "Goodbye, Mister Bond?") I was hoping he'd come back for more films. I only started to sour on him a little with SF, then it increased with SP, the five year gap after that, and now the decisions that went into NTTD.
You know the feeling... the temptation... the promise. 😉
Honestly though, my favourite Bond movies have already been made. A few Connery, a couple of Dalton & a few Brosnan.
Well, of course they are... you haven't seen any of the ones that haven't been made yet.
If they only made two Bond films, you'd have a favourite of the two of them, and you'd be able to say the exact same thing. ;)
Are you a time traveler or a philosopher? ;)
It's just a completely redundant statement to say "My favourite Bond movies have already been made."
Although, I wish I could say I was a time traveler, because then I might be able to tell you your favourite Bond film has yet to be made! :)
LOL, yeah, that would be nice, but my favourite movies (Superman 1978, Bond 1987, Batman 1989... etc) are all in the past. I'm a misogynist dinosaur, a relic of the Cold War....
"HE STOLE MY BALLOONS!"
***Distant Screams of Thousands of Angry Nolan Fanboys***
But in all seriousness, I much prefer Returns to 89, but that’s probably a discussion for another thread
I *love* the Nolan Batman films (all of them), but still, 89 is such a classic.
I love the Nolan films too, just thought of it as a funny joke because he does have lots and lots of vocal fans. And I can’t disagree with you on 89, love that film.
lol it's true, I suppose that sort of fan is everywhere, the type that'll get upset if you like/dislike the wrong thing.
I'm no Craig hater either. I loved him in CR. I just wished his films had continued in the same direction, instead of taking a very different path.
I'd go one step further: if the only two Bond films made were the two worst of those we have according to @chrisisall there would still be a favourite one, if only by default. Although of course one could then dismiss the whole franchise entirely.
Same with the aforementioned Batman '89. I used to worship at its altar. Then I discovered the animated films. Then I saw the Nolans. It is still a great movie, but it has been surpassed.
We can stick to our darlings with passion, but sometimes another one comes along that really can make absolutes less absolute. It's funny how that goes sometimes.
This discussion makes me think of Kurt Vonnegut's Slaughterhouse Five. If we could experience time the way we walk back and forth from door to mailbox, we'd already know what the future of Bond brings, and then we'd probably know what our favourite Bond film, ever (yes, more ever than ever so to speak), would be. But, for now, I'm not holding my breath for a film that tops CR or OHMSS for me, though it is possible.
I thought the same at one point. I hated DAD, I admired but didn’t get that much enjoyment out of CR, and then I hated QoS. Over a decade had passed since I’d really, really enjoyed a Bond film, and I was wondering if the series would ever live up to my childhood memories again.
Then SF came out, and I loved it. Then SP came out, and I liked that one even better (despite its flaws). Then NTTD came out, and once I got over the initial shock of how different it was, I loved that one too, and the way it wrapped everything up boosted my opinion of the whole Craig era. I was wondering if we really needed another film with him, but now I couldn’t be happier that he decided to return.
So, keep the faith mate, things can change ;) And you never know, you might warm to the Craig films more in the future. I can get a lot of enjoyment out of DAD now, in a so bad it’s funny sort of way. And I even found stuff to appreciate in QoS, once I’d seen it enough times to actually understand what was going on.
Well, Scenario 2 is in reality more like this:
- I like Craig
- You do? I think he is an abomination! The man that ruined Bond forever just to satisfy his ego. The man that hates Bond (*insert quote from a bad interview taken out of context) and from the start wanted to remove all the elements of the character we love, which he could do because the imbecile that doesn't ubderstand Bond, Barbara Broccoli, bowed to him. Thanks to him I can no longer live my outdated, sexist fantasies through Bond, and it infuriates me. In fact he should be burned at the sticks for his sins. I pretend his films don't exist and conclude that the people who like him are not real Bond fans but rather kids with ADD who have been infected by the Marvel virus. This is common consensus. Just look at how the film hasn't earned money yet! It just proves how fans are alienated.
- I disagree strongly with your opinions and generalizations!
- Hey! Why do you attack me for my opinions, you bully!
I am not sure I like this scenario, but to each his own...
Hahaha, yeah, I recognise the frustration. Not what I had in mind, though. Let's call yours "scenario 3". ;-) All I'm saying is that a forum of nothing but identical opinions would be a boring place, frozen in dead consensus. I prefer a good debate, and while you gave an accurate description of some unpleasant encounters I too have had, most discussions happen in a civilized and respectful manner.
Besides, I'm sure "our side" has been just as guilty of attacking people who just don't like Craig.
The problem isn't that some of us love the Craig years and others don't, it's that some people, regardless of where they stand, still think opinions about films can be objectively correct or false. As usual, it's easier for a lover to get away with absolute love, than it is for a hater to get away with absolute hate, at least on a fan forum. But arguments tend to be pretty weak on either side, and you've given excellent examples of arguments that aren't just weak, but downright moronic. In the end, it's just about taste and opinion. How silly it is to quarrel over that. "NTTD should not have been made." Why? "Because I just don't like the film." That's it. Not "because Fleming so-and-so and Barbara is a [insert ugly word] and my theatre was empty and just because." A simple "I don't like the following elements in the film" should do. Same for why others love the film.
People ought to accept and understand that this isn't an exact science. You can make up all the reasons in the world for why (not) liking the film is not your problem but that of the people who made the film; in the end, there's no "proof" that you are right, only that you are wrong as long as at least one person out there disagrees with you.
https://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/product/B01A9MBQGU?ref=em_1p_7_ti&ref_=pe_22146291_645707901
I'm going to buy it and put it next to my Pierce Brosnan tin box, (did anyone get one of those?).
;)
* I was going for smug, superiour & condescending- did I succeed?
Seems like you have a natural talent for it... *
*Going for young, brash, overconfident and provocative. Did I succeed?