Goldeneye vs. Casino Royale

16781012

Comments

  • Posts: 11,189
    I've said this before but I don't really have a problem with David Arnold. True he's no Barry but his music has an energetic, lively feel to it. One of my favourites is the Dr Kaulfman score. Rather understated IMO. It adds to the creepiness of the scene:


  • Posts: 1,492
    DarthDimi wrote:
    [ Arnold's had no less than five opportunities to convince us and his output ranges from rather poor to mediocre at best, IMO. Well I for one think that Bond deserves better than mediocre.

    Umm,,,not sure on that. I think his score for CR is the best since TLD so he that sets him above everyone else for that. I am not joking. One of the pleasures of CR was his lush score as Bond sails into Venice also the Vesper theme which permeates the film and pops up in Quantum. Also he gets marks for the, and I hate to use the word, awesome 'Surrender' by KD Lang in TND.

    As for Serra? Well GE is one of my least watched Bonds but the adjective which pops up is.

    tinny.

    Not great I am afraid.

  • DaltonCraig007DaltonCraig007 They say, "Evil prevails when good men fail to act." What they ought to say is, "Evil prevails."
    edited January 2012 Posts: 15,718
    actonsteve wrote:
    One of the pleasures of CR was his lush score as Bond sails into Venice also the Vesper theme which permeates the film and pops up in Quantum.

    Those cues are extremely simplistic... I'd expect more complexity and epicness for romantic cues like Barry and Serra can compose. The CR score is appalling IMO. It's the most basic and simplistic score in the franchise. It's nowhere near the level of grandness that I am used to from Barry and Barry.
  • Posts: 11,189
    actonsteve wrote:
    DarthDimi wrote:
    [ Arnold's had no less than five opportunities to convince us and his output ranges from rather poor to mediocre at best, IMO. Well I for one think that Bond deserves better than mediocre.

    Umm,,,not sure on that. I think his score for CR is the best since TLD so he that sets him above everyone else for that. I am not joking. One of the pleasures of CR was his lush score as Bond sails into Venice also the Vesper theme which permeates the film and pops up in Quantum. Also he gets marks for the, and I hate to use the word, awesome 'Surrender' by KD Lang in TND.
    As for Serra? Well GE is one of my least watched Bonds but the adjective which pops up is.

    tinny.

    Not great I am afraid.

    I agree that's a good song. The Cheryl Crow one is ok but Surrender is much better. It's a shame its only played at the end.

    Back to GE and CR, in regard to title songs I've never been overly fond of the film version of YKMN. The official version by Chris Connell is much better IMO. It's louder and has a bit more force to it.
  • Posts: 1,492
    Those cues are extremely simplistic... I'd expect more complexity and epicness for romantic cues like Barry and Serra can compose.

    Words to describe his score for CR

    lush
    romantic
    grandiose
    complex
    moody
    multi-layered

    Words to describe Serras score for GE

    kerplunky..

    and

    of course

    tinny.

  • DaltonCraig007DaltonCraig007 They say, "Evil prevails when good men fail to act." What they ought to say is, "Evil prevails."
    edited January 2012 Posts: 15,718
    actonsteve wrote:

    Words to describe his score for CR

    lush
    romantic
    grandiose
    complex
    moody
    multi-layered

    Totally untrue. Any professional musician would tell you the score is extremtly simplistic. How can you say such nonsense ? The score is not 'complex'. It's totally silly to say such things. A simple analysis of the soundtrack will tell you it's just basic, simplistic music.

    I think what you are trying to tell us that is you 'like the soundtrack of CR'. Which is totally fine. But saying it is a 'complex, multi-layered' , etc. is just not true. You're basicly saying Zac Efron is a better actor than Marlon Brando. It's your opinion to prefer Efron to Brando, but saying Efron is a better actor than Efron will rise many laughs from those who will hear you say such things.
  • Posts: 1,492
    actonsteve wrote:

    Words to describe his score for CR

    lush
    romantic
    grandiose
    complex
    moody
    multi-layered

    Totally untrue. Any professional musician would tell you the score is extremtly simplistic. How can you say such nonsense ? The score is not 'complex'. It's totally silly to say such things. A simple analysis of the soundtrack will tell you it's just basic, simplistic music.

    Simple but effective music which completes and moves the story along. A wonderful romantic score in places which enhances Vesper and Bonds growing relationship.

    Compare it to the kerpunkly stylophone noise of GE.

  • DaltonCraig007DaltonCraig007 They say, "Evil prevails when good men fail to act." What they ought to say is, "Evil prevails."
    edited January 2012 Posts: 15,718
    <url>

    <url>

    <url>

    <url>
  • edited January 2012 Posts: 1,492
    <url>

    <url>

    <url>

    <url>

    Is that the best you can throw at me?

    Beautiful piece of moody evocative music, the CCTV one is comparable with Barrys safecracking in Berne and is just as tense.

    Not like Serras racket in a steel drum that permeates the film,

  • edited January 2012 Posts: 11,189
    I do like CR's score but I also thought GE ost 4 was a nice, mellow piece of music :(
  • DaltonCraig007DaltonCraig007 They say, "Evil prevails when good men fail to act." What they ought to say is, "Evil prevails."
    edited January 2012 Posts: 15,718
    You can love CR's soundtrack all you want @actonsteve, but don't exaggerate things by saying it's a 'multi-layered' and 'complex' score... any professional musician will tell you otherwise.
  • Posts: 11,189
    You can love CR's soundtrack all you want @actonsteve, but don't exaggerate things by saying it's a 'multi-layered' and 'complex' score... any professional musician will tell you otherwise.

    Are there any professional musicians on Mi6?
  • Posts: 1,492
    You can love GE;s soundtrack all you want @DaltonCraig007, but don't exaggerate things by saying it's "worth a rats arse' ... any professional musician will tell you otherwise.
  • Posts: 11,189
    actonsteve wrote:
    You can love GE;s soundtrack all you want @DaltonCraig007, but don't exaggerate things by saying it's "worth a rats arse' ... any professional musician will tell you otherwise.

    Wow. A bit harsh don't you think? Lol.
  • DaltonCraig007DaltonCraig007 They say, "Evil prevails when good men fail to act." What they ought to say is, "Evil prevails."
    edited January 2012 Posts: 15,718
    actonsteve wrote:
    You can love GE;s soundtrack all you want @DaltonCraig007, but don't exaggerate things by saying it's "worth a rats arse' ... any professional musician will tell you otherwise.

    Actually anyone with some musical knowledge will tell you GE's soundtrack is more complex, multi-layered, etc. than CR. I happen to have studied music and played in an orchestra for several years and I can analyze partitions... it don't need to study rocket science to see that CR's score is very, very poor. I am not saying GE's soundtrack is a masterpiece, but it is better than CR's.

    The bottom line is that CR is a very, very poor soundtrack. But please understand I am not saying people aren't allowed to love this soundtrack... I am just saying some statements around this score are false.
  • Posts: 1,492
    BAIN123 wrote:
    actonsteve wrote:
    You can love GE;s soundtrack all you want @DaltonCraig007, but don't exaggerate things by saying it's "worth a rats arse' ... any professional musician will tell you otherwise.

    Wow. A bit harsh don't you think? Lol.

    Oh I am only having a laugh with/at him. Its quite fun.

  • DaltonCraig007DaltonCraig007 They say, "Evil prevails when good men fail to act." What they ought to say is, "Evil prevails."
    edited January 2012 Posts: 15,718
    actonsteve wrote:
    BAIN123 wrote:
    actonsteve wrote:
    You can love GE;s soundtrack all you want @DaltonCraig007, but don't exaggerate things by saying it's "worth a rats arse' ... any professional musician will tell you otherwise.

    Wow. A bit harsh don't you think? Lol.

    Oh I am only having a laugh with/at him. Its quite fun.

    I am the one laughing here, judging by your OTT statements on music.

    I understand you love Arnold's CR soundtrack. But please admit it's far from being the masterpiece you're saying it is. If you can find the partitions on a few tracks of the score, please go see a musician/music teacher to analyze it for you... they'll tell you it's a poor soundtrack. Good sounding music maybe, and I admit a few cues sound great... but musically speaking it's a very poor soundtrack.

  • Posts: 11,189
    Children!! Calm down ;)

  • Posts: 1,492
    . I am not saying GE's soundtrack is a masterpiece, .

    Well, at least you admit its rubbish.
    The bottom line is that CR is a very, very poor soundtrack.

    I hear that the Royal Philamonic are throwing out Purcell and Britten this year and chosing the score for GE. Of course they will have to get scratchy eighties stylophones in to play it or book the screeching cats.


    .


  • edited January 2012 Posts: 11,189
    actonsteve wrote:
    . I am not saying GE's soundtrack is a masterpiece, .

    Well, at least you admit its rubbish.
    The bottom line is that CR is a very, very poor soundtrack.

    I hear that the Royal Philamonic are throwing out Purcell and Britten this year and chosing the score for GE. Of course they will have to get scratchy eighties stylophones in to play it or book the screeching cats.


    .


    Then they should consider Alicia Keys and Jack White ;)
  • Posts: 1,492
    I understand you love Serras GE soundtrack. But please admit it's far from being the masterpiece you're saying it is. If you can find the partitions on a few tracks of the score, please go see a musician/music teacher to analyze it for you... they'll tell you it's a godawful soundtrackand I admit a few cues sound bearable... but musically speaking it's a very painful soundtrack.
  • DaltonCraig007DaltonCraig007 They say, "Evil prevails when good men fail to act." What they ought to say is, "Evil prevails."
    edited January 2012 Posts: 15,718
    actonsteve wrote:
    I understand you love Serras GE soundtrack. But please admit it's far from being the masterpiece you're saying it is. If you can find the partitions on a few tracks of the score, please go see a musician/music teacher to analyze it for you... they'll tell you it's a godawful soundtrackand I admit a few cues sound bearable... but musically speaking it's a very painful soundtrack.

    Again you say some nonsense. GE's score contain very interesting cues. The music itself is better than CR's soundtrack. Many would rather play interesting music like Serra's GE than poor, simplistic music like Arnold's CR, which would bore musicians very quickly.

    The fact is GE is a quite good soundtrack, and CR a very poor soundtrack. Whether you like one score or the other is up to personal opinion and taste. But the fact is GE is the better soundtrack, musically speaking, by a fair margin.
  • Posts: 11,189
    actonsteve wrote:
    I understand you love Serras GE soundtrack. But please admit it's far from being the masterpiece you're saying it is. If you can find the partitions on a few tracks of the score, please go see a musician/music teacher to analyze it for you... they'll tell you it's a godawful soundtrackand I admit a few cues sound bearable... but musically speaking it's a very painful soundtrack.

    Again you say some nonsense. GE's score contain very interesting cues. The music itself is better than CR's soundtrack. Many would rather play interesting music like Serra's GE than poor, simplistic music like Arnold's CR, which would bore musicians very quickly.

    The fact is GE is a quite good soundtrack, and CR a very poor soundtrack. Whether you like one score or the other is up to personal opinion and taste. But the fact is GE is the better soundtrack, musically speaking, by a fair margin.

    That's not a fact. That's an opinion.
  • DaltonCraig007DaltonCraig007 They say, "Evil prevails when good men fail to act." What they ought to say is, "Evil prevails."
    edited January 2012 Posts: 15,718
    BAIN123 wrote:
    That's not a fact. That's an opinion.

    Musically speaking it's a fact. Just go read partitions of GE and CR, and compare the two... you'll see that CR is a poor soundtrack. That's not an opinion, that's what every single musician and music teacher would tell you after reading a few partitions of CR's soundtrack.

    I am not saying CR's score doesn't sound nice, or that you can't love it... but it just is a poor soundtrack.

    It's like saying a cooking recipe book is better litterature than a book from Hugo or Verne...

    Yes, some cues from CR sound nice... but the bottom line is that CR is, musically, one of the poorest soundtrack of the franchise. But that doesn't stop you from liking it... Heck, I can love some bad music myself, but I don't go telling everybody it's the best album ever.
  • Agent007391Agent007391 Up, Up, Down, Down, Left, Right, Left, Right, B, A, Start
    Posts: 7,854
    Amazing how this has gone from "Which movie do you prefer" to "which composer do you prefer".
  • SharkShark Banned
    edited January 2012 Posts: 348
    actonsteve wrote:
    I think his score for CR is the best since TLD so he that sets him above everyone else for that. I am not joking. One of the pleasures of CR was his lush score as Bond sails into Venice also the Vesper theme which permeates the film and pops up in Quantum.

    I'd agree with Arnold's CR being the best since TLD if the score was more like that. Deliberate and stirring. Instead, it's filled to the brim with forgettable and at times plain obnoxious action and suspense cues. Looking for decent music in that score is like searching for a needle in a haystack.
    actonsteve wrote:
    Words to describe his score for CR

    lush
    romantic
    grandiose
    complex
    moody
    multi-layered

    Nah. For the most part, it's more like

    Bland
    Generic
    Pastiche
    Soulless
    Chaotic
    Wallpaper
    Toilet water
    Ugly
    Brosnan 2.0
    actonsteve wrote:
    Beautiful piece of moody evocative music, the CCTV one is comparable with Barrys safecracking in Berne and is just as tense.

    The CCTV cue is almost a note-for-note rip-off of Don Davis's cue for when Neo is being operated on in THE MATRIX.

    It does its job in the film, I don't deny that, but it's nowhere near as evocative as anything Barry's penned, let alone the iconic underscore for Gumbold's safe.
    BAIN123 wrote:
    I've said this before but I don't really have a problem with David Arnold. True he's no Barry but his music has an energetic, lively feel to it. One of my favourites is the Dr Kaulfman score. Rather understated IMO. It adds to the creepiness of the scene:


    Meh. It's Arnold's stock atonal stuff. Compared to real avant-garde pros like Elliot Goldenthal, Jerry Goldsmith or Don Davis, it doesn't add up to much I'm afraid.

  • SharkShark Banned
    edited January 2012 Posts: 348
    actonsteve wrote:
    I hear that the Royal Philamonic are throwing out Purcell and Britten this year and chosing the score for GE. Of course they will have to get scratchy eighties stylophones in to play it or book the screeching cats.

    Eh? You're aware there's a good amount of lush orchestral music in GOLDENEYE for the Monte Carlo casino, and Bond's scenes with Natalya? It's not all dark industrial.
  • DaltonCraig007DaltonCraig007 They say, "Evil prevails when good men fail to act." What they ought to say is, "Evil prevails."
    Posts: 15,718
    actonsteve wrote:
    the CCTV one is comparable with Barrys safecracking in Berne and is just as tense.

    =))
  • Samuel001Samuel001 Moderator
    edited January 2012 Posts: 13,355
    @Shark, have you ever tried replacing Arnold's tracks in a Bond film with their nearest equivalent?

    By the sounds of it, you'd be able to create the exact same score, but better, than Arnold has done, as he just does a rip-off of what other, better, composers do.
  • edited January 2012 Posts: 1,778
    Guys lets try to relax here. No need for unpleasantries. Arnold's music might be generic but all I have to do is point out the softcore porn track Serra used for the Bond/Xenia race. Someone please try to justify that.
Sign In or Register to comment.