It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
^ Back to Top
The MI6 Community is unofficial and in no way associated or linked with EON Productions, MGM, Sony Pictures, Activision or Ian Fleming Publications. Any views expressed on this website are of the individual members and do not necessarily reflect those of the Community owners. Any video or images displayed in topics on MI6 Community are embedded by users from third party sites and as such MI6 Community and its owners take no responsibility for this material.
James Bond News • James Bond Articles • James Bond Magazine
Comments
I hope you're right. Very odd writing. No one actually speaks like that, at least not in the movies!
And Harris looks so self conscious
It's really odd direction. It's Bond and MP, presumably very well acquainted colleagues by now, yet the direction and delivery of the dialogue is unnecessarily flowery. It could've probably done with someone like Fiennes delivering it very 'matter of fact', rather than the overt 'oooooooh he's got a secret' tone of the trailer. I say this firmly in the knowledge it's likely out of context and could work perfectly in the moment. I still find it very 'theatrical', as I did some of SF. The Severine-Bond scene is perfect tonally, with the overt theatricality of it, but Bond to MP in his house, I'm not so sure.
I really don't like Naomi Harris as Moneypenny, which is a shame because I was really excited to see her. I think she's stunning and a good actress, I fully expected her to be the better Bond girl in SF (since Berenice hadn't done much acting before at all) and while I didn't like the field agent background I was still happy with her being MP once I found out that's who the character was. Then I watched SF and I was really disappointed, I thought she was wooden and her chemistry with Craig was non existent. Meanwhile Berenice did a great job, stealing every scene she was in, and if she had a bit more screentime Severine would probably be my favourite Bond girl.
Honestly I preferred Samantha Bond as Moneypenny. Yeah Naomi is a lot fitter but MP doesn't necessarily need to be fit imo (Maxwell and Bliss weren't hot either so I don't get why fans complain about Bond not being attractive enough for the role), what's important is her chemistry with Bond, without that the whole character doesn't work. I think with Craig and Harris it just seems forced, and while I think Naomi was wooden in SF I don't think this is the fault of either of the actors, chemistry is something you either have or you don't. They don't have it imo which is why I don't think Harris as MP works. But Brosnan and Bond had loads of chemistry, it always felt natural even with the dodgy lines they were sometimes given, which is why I think Samantha Bond was a much better Moneypenny than Naomi Harris so far.
Severine had the potential to be one of the great Bond girls.
I think Lois Maxwell and Samantha Bond were both pretty attractive women in their prime. They're not 'hot' like some of the main Bond girls but perhaps more attrarctive in some respects.
Damn right. I thought they were superb together, particularly in GE and TND.
i enjoyedbPierce's Bond as much as Sean's.
That's not controversial, just silly.
My controversial view is that Mathieu Amelric is actually really rather good as Dominic Greene. I like his understated take on the traditional Bond psychopath. The more you watch QoS the more you realise it's quite a traditional Bond movie in many respects. And it has a really good cast. I still find it very odd how much criticism it gets. Given the production problems, it's really very good and the villain is one of the best parts.
Imagine what QOS would have been like if Forster & Craig hadn't had to burn so much energy writing the damn thing...
@-)
Maybe but thats my opinion. Never said it was a fact
I guess its the right way.
Thanks
I fully agree, the showdown is great and the way Bond disposes of Greene at the end is brutal and satisfying.
I agree about Amalric and QOS cast.
My controversial opinion: however inept, Elvis has his use as a character.
He also seems a bit inconsequential in relation to the wider organisation of Quantum.
Almaric is good with the stuff they have him, but I would have rather seen a bit more of Mr White and perhaps have him as a wiesely number 2 alongside.
I like QoS but there are many ways in which it could have been improved.
It's a great looking movie as well. I personally find it visually more satisfying than SF.