SKYFALL: FANS' REACTIONS - GUARANTEED SPOILERS

1868789919299

Comments

  • SandySandy Somewhere in Europe
    Posts: 4,012
    chrisisall wrote:
    Just watched QOS yesterday, wow, it was nice to see Dan with some hair.
    :))

    You should see an eye doctor.
  • RC7RC7
    Posts: 10,512
    I think TLD has the best PTS of the series. It works as a mini Bond movie but it also relates to the rest of the film. The stunt work is great (and it's made more impressive by the fact that Dalton did it himself). TSWLM and TWINE run it close though. I love both of those too.

    Agreed mate. I have to say, over the last year or so TLD is slowly becoming my go to Bond movie. I've always loved it, but I've almost 'rediscovered' it. It's just brilliant.
  • Matt_Helm wrote:
    I say:
    Obviously you are a Fan,albeit not a very qualified one. But keep on trying,at least it keeps you off the streets.

    I wonder how many brian cells it took to conjure up such an excellent, intelligent and thought-provoking response. Your head must be hurting.

    Judging from Most of your previous comments "Brian Cells" is what you use. I am using Brain Cells,which might explain my dissatisfaction with SF's screenplay.
  • chrisisallchrisisall Brosnan Defender Of The Realm
    Posts: 17,823
    Sandy wrote:
    You should see an eye doctor.
    What? He had hair in SF?
    RC7 wrote:
    I think TLD has the best PTS of the series. It works as a mini Bond movie but it also relates to the rest of the film. The stunt work is great (and it's made more impressive by the fact that Dalton did it himself). TSWLM and TWINE run it close though. I love both of those too.

    Agreed mate. I have to say, over the last year or so TLD is slowly becoming my go to Bond movie. I've always loved it, but I've almost 'rediscovered' it. It's just brilliant.
    I rediscovered it last year myself, first viewing it was in my top 5; 2nd viewing it was #1.
  • doubleoegodoubleoego #LightWork
    edited February 2013 Posts: 11,139
    Matt_Helm wrote:
    Doubleoego said:

    Well, you can take almost every film that's ever been made and find that there is very little sense to be found. Hell, take every single Bond movie ever made and an argument can be made that it's all senseless rubbish. That being said, Mendes in the audio commentary talks about how there was a leap in logic or something to that effect within the movie but guess what, it's just a damn movie. Get over it.

    I am constantly baffled how quick and Easy some People are denigrating all of the Former Bond Movies as stupid,Camp and illogical just to defend SF. To you I say - WRONG!!!
    This is foremost an insult of The Great and Late Richard Maibaum who went to Great length to deliver scripts that often strongly improved on Mr. Flemings Books and to iron Out many of the original Plot holes of an actually quite mediocre Thrillerwriter. Also take for example Films like OP,which is Full of ridiculous Moments - it still has an absolute Sound Storyline on the height of its Time!

    He also said:
    Firstly, you cite all 3 Craig movies and fail to mention the utter stupidity that can be argued to be all of Moore's Bond movies, all of Brosnan's and a couple of Connery's. Nice try.


    Would you care to dwell on the stupidity of for example FYEO compared to SF?

    First of all, I said an argument can be made. Such an argument can be made and has been made by others not necessarily myself but off the top of my head as I haven't seen the movie in a while, starting things off, the awful PTS. Imo; questionably avenging Tracy, Bond nonchalantly killing Blofeld, in one of the most ridiculously, tedious, asinine action sequences, resulting in an even more embarrassing death for a character who's been further reduced to...I don't even know what the hell he was reduced to, some kind of, second tier, sub-par, sideshow joke of a character. There's Bibi, Thatcher and don't get me started on the absurdity of Moore scoring goals by knocking the hockey goons into the back of the net...honestly, FYEO is Moore's most restrained entry in the series and overall a good outing but it is by no means a masterpiece and is wholly inferior to SF. If there's anything else I find to be stupid, I'll have to come back after watching it again.
    However, this has nothing to do with putting previous movies down to defend SF. I have defended and simultaneously criticized SF without having to mention previous Bond movies but given the nature of the debates or rather the arguments going on, previous movies are being cited to prove a point and that's something those vigorously lambasting SF have been doing constantly.

    I'm a realist and I know exactly what the Bond films are. I enjoy them and I know full well it's really all nonsense. Fantasy usually is just that; a bunch of nonsense. However, if you and SOME others are going to launch some Jihad and going to throw around weak arguments and make silly generalizations on those that do like SF and declare the movie as being awful or bizarrely, the worst in the series when, Bond movies that predate SF are far more explicitly guilty of being tremendously more flawed and far more outlandish and nonsensical then be prepared to have other movies within the series delved into and face the same scrutiny you put SF under. After all, it's to serve a purpose and a point for the sake of these so called arguments going on around here.
    The blind disdain for the movie is almost amusing. The desperation to be heard in getting what is just your opinion (you'd do well to be mindful of this fact) bashed over the heads of everyone here reeks. No one is forcing you to like the movie. If you don't like it and are disappointed then fine, it's a shame but don't piss on people's joy and try to kill what should be a celebration of a series and the film's success and unconditional assurance of additional Bond movies. It's just not cool and a huge disrespect to fellow posters.
    I like to think we all love the Bond movies. They are fun and have provided years of glorious entertainment but launching a crusade on the movie and on some of those that do like it is pathetic. It's simple. Many people like it and many people don't. What's the problem? To me, Connery is the best Bond ever to others he's not. Big deal, who cares?
    As for my comment about every single movie, it's true, in every movie one can find an argument to make about somethings not making sense but then again, what movie is unequivocally perfect? You and a minor group of others go around punishing SF for doing what not just every other Bond movies has done but what all movies do. Get a grip, mate. The horse is dead.


    Oh and thanks @Tuulia.
  • RC7 wrote:
    I think TLD has the best PTS of the series. It works as a mini Bond movie but it also relates to the rest of the film. The stunt work is great (and it's made more impressive by the fact that Dalton did it himself). TSWLM and TWINE run it close though. I love both of those too.

    Agreed mate. I have to say, over the last year or so TLD is slowly becoming my go to Bond movie. I've always loved it, but I've almost 'rediscovered' it. It's just brilliant.

    After years of swapping them around between 1st and 2nd place I've decided LTK is my no 1 favourite because I prefer the villian but I do love TLD. It was my first Bond film and I'm glad I had such a brilliant one to introduce me to the series.
  • Posts: 7,653
    SF is just the third movie in which DC is just not given the promise of a really great movie. CR is a bad ending that annoys me everytime (the sinking house!), QoB is a Bourne movie and a half poor in the 007 franchise a poor when compared to the 4 Bourne movies. SF promises a lot but is a long movie that is average on the actionfront and navelgazing when it comes to the character of 007 and he manages to get his chef killed. Which in my book makes him te worst 007 by far.
    I do hope that Craig gets some great adventure movie yet otherwise he'll be rememebered as the 00 that needed serious therapy instead of great movies.
  • I think even though I have issues with it, SF is a great movie that's definetly in my top 10.

    For Bond 24 I'd like a more straight forward Bond movie that focuses more on the plot than Skyfall did. SF seemed entirely focused on the characters and I think the story suffered for it.
  • SandySandy Somewhere in Europe
    edited February 2013 Posts: 4,012
    Well said @doubleoego. FYEO is probably the best of Moore's outings, I personally love it, but it obviously has serious problems! And yes, it starts with the PTS, why the hell would Bond want a delicatessen in stainless steel? One of the top nonsense moments of the series.

    This video is really funny
    http://youtu.be/eV9LGA8L4GI
  • Posts: 7,653
    Sandy wrote:
    Well said @doubleoego. FYEO is probably the best of Moore's outings, I personally love it, but it obviously has serious problems! And yes, it starts with the PTS, why the hell would Bond want a delicatessen in stainless steel? One of the top nonsense moments of the series.

    As I remember the suggestion of a delicatessen in stainless steel deserves the Bald man stroking a pussy in a wheelchair a one way ticket down with love from gravity. SO Rogers 007 agreed with your statement.
    The opening of Roger visiting the grave of his wife was GREAT, what followed next was a bit meeeh.
    But the sinking boat and the race for the Gizmo was a brilliant 007 actioner that showed the toughest 00 in Rogers reign.
    And to my personal taste DC has not yet been offered such a good movie yet. If he were he would probably get depresive about the snow or whatever.

  • doubleoegodoubleoego #LightWork
    Posts: 11,139
    Thanks @Sandy.
  • Posts: 2,081
    @doubleoego, you're on a roll!

    (you're welcome)
  • I think FYEO is overrated. Good plot but the film itself has it's fair share of flaws and I reckon it's average overall.

    Give me Spy, OP and LALD over FYEO any day.
  • chrisisallchrisisall Brosnan Defender Of The Realm
    Posts: 17,823
    I think FYEO is overrated. Good plot but the film itself has it's fair share of flaws and I reckon it's average overall.

    Give me Spy, OP and LALD over FYEO any day.
    Yes, even LALD, definitely.

  • Posts: 11,425
    Nice to see all the TLD love. The PTS is one of the very best in the series and blows CR's out of the water. It's amazing that a film made on a fraction of today's budgets by a journeyman director stands the test of time and IMO shows the DC films up for just not being as exciting, well written or enjoyable
  • edited February 2013 Posts: 3,494
    Sorry what I meant to say was:
    yeah but we are talking about bond respecting people not vesper respecting people.
    my bad

    Jet set willy
    please dont insult me I have been a bond fan since I was a kid.
    I absolutely LOVE them.
    DAD would be lucky to make my top 20.

    At first you said Skyfall was the worst, now it's AVTAK and TWINE. I'm thinking you haven't thought about this very much.

    I'd take AVTAK and TWINE over DAD and MR, no question. Only DAD exceeds MR as the worst Bond film, and that's mostly because of Sir Roger's sense of humor and style.

    What? when did I mention AVTAK or TWINE?
    My top 23 is in the other thread if you want to take a look.
    Which you obviously need to instead of making up sh*t that I never said!!

    You are right, I got you and the AVTAK/TWINE mixed up with someone else, and I apologize for the error. But then we have this gem directed at Willy, who is as real a Bond fan as any-
    LOL jet set willy
    You couldnt even lace my shoes when it comes to bond.
    Bond ended with Dalton EVERY true fan knows this. No insult meant to Brosnan as I love Goldeneye.
    For interests sake what are your top 5 movies and top 5 books?
    Then I can tell what kinda bond fan you are

    Now that's an arrogant thing to say in a place where we have fans who started watching Bond films when Connery was the one and only Bond. I'm one of them. 44 years a fan. How long have you been a fan?


  • 0BradyM0Bondfanatic70BradyM0Bondfanatic7 Quantum Floral Arrangements: "We Have Petals Everywhere"
    Posts: 28,694
    LOL jet set willy
    You couldnt even lace my shoes when it comes to bond.
    Bond ended with Dalton EVERY true fan knows this. No insult meant to Brosnan as I love Goldeneye.
    For interests sake what are your top 5 movies and top 5 books?
    Then I can tell what kinda bond fan you are

    Now that's an arrogant thing to say in a place where we have fans who started watching Bond films when Connery was the one and only Bond. I'm one of them. 44 years a fan. How long have you been a fan?

    BURN. :-\"
  • hoppimikehoppimike Kent, UK
    Posts: 290
    chrisisall wrote:
    Just watched QOS yesterday, wow, it was nice to see Dan with some hair.
    :))

    heh, yeah he deffo lost a bit over the 4 years! It was thin-ish even in Casino though.
  • I have never seen some one defend AVTAK before, very interesting.

    While I would never call AVTAK a great Bond film, I will defend the villains who are a reason I don't mind an occasional watch. Chris Walken is one of the best of them ever, and Willoughby Gray also great as his "Dr. Frankenstein". Aside from the risk of blindness from Rog's bedroom scene with Grace, she was mostly a good henchwoman until her and Zorin turned on the other.



  • If you can ignore some of the action scenes and the Grace Jones sex scene, AVTAK is a pretty fun watch.
  • RC7RC7
    edited February 2013 Posts: 10,512
    AVTAK is great. It makes watching QoS feel like treading water.
  • LOL jet set willy
    You couldnt even lace my shoes when it comes to bond.
    Bond ended with Dalton EVERY true fan knows this. No insult meant to Brosnan as I love Goldeneye.
    For interests sake what are your top 5 movies and top 5 books?
    Then I can tell what kinda bond fan you are

    Now that's an arrogant thing to say in a place where we have fans who started watching Bond films when Connery was the one and only Bond. I'm one of them. 44 years a fan. How long have you been a fan?

    BURN. :-\"

    You're damn skippy Brady. He's got some cajones coming here as a newbie and throwing his weight around without knowing who he's dealing with, I'll give him that.

    There's a lot of people here, including some intimately associated with the franchise, whose boots he couldn't lace. If he's as smart as he thinks he is, he'll reconsider barking up the tree of people like myself and Willy. It won't otherwise turn out well ;)

  • edited February 2013 Posts: 11,189
    Getafix wrote:
    Nice to see all the TLD love. The PTS is one of the very best in the series and blows CR's out of the water. It's amazing that a film made on a fraction of today's budgets by a journeyman director stands the test of time and IMO shows the DC films up for just not being as exciting, well written or enjoyable

    TLD has an excellent PTS I agree but the last bit just feels a bit silly and cheesy to me now. It's a holdover from
    Moore. At least CR wipes it's slate clean. That's why I prefer it.

    I think the best of all the PTS's is either GF or TSWLM.
  • Posts: 11,425
    BAIN123 wrote:
    Getafix wrote:
    Nice to see all the TLD love. The PTS is one of the very best in the series and blows CR's out of the water. It's amazing that a film made on a fraction of today's budgets by a journeyman director stands the test of time and IMO shows the DC films up for just not being as exciting, well written or enjoyable

    TLD has an excellent PTS I agree but the last bit just feels a bit silly and cheesy to me now. It's a holdover from
    Moore. At least CR wipes it's slate clean. That's why I prefer it.

    I think the best of all the PTS's is either GF or TSWLM.

    I think the end of the TLD PTS is actually the icing on the cake. Without it the PTS would be a bit po faced and over earnest. I don't see it as a hold over from Rog, I just think it's classic Bond.

    Any way I agree with you about GF and Spy. GF is probably my favourite PTS. Spy is gloriously, wonderfully OTT - the Rog era at its height.
  • chrisisallchrisisall Brosnan Defender Of The Realm
    edited February 2013 Posts: 17,823
    Getafix wrote:
    It's amazing that a film made on a fraction of today's budgets by a journeyman director stands the test of time and IMO shows the DC films up for just not being as exciting, well written or enjoyable
    No bigger fan of Dalton here than me, but CR & QOS are pretty darn good movies too IMO.
    But really, nobody does it better than Dalton.
  • edited February 2013 Posts: 174
    Sorry what I meant to say was:
    yeah but we are talking about bond respecting people not vesper respecting people.
    my bad

    Jet set willy
    please dont insult me I have been a bond fan since I was a kid.
    I absolutely LOVE them.
    DAD would be lucky to make my top 20.

    At first you said Skyfall was the worst, now it's AVTAK and TWINE. I'm thinking you haven't thought about this very much.

    I'd take AVTAK and TWINE over DAD and MR, no question. Only DAD exceeds MR as the worst Bond film, and that's mostly because of Sir Roger's sense of humor and style.

    What? when did I mention AVTAK or TWINE?
    My top 23 is in the other thread if you want to take a look.
    Which you obviously need to instead of making up sh*t that I never said!!

    You are right, I got you and the AVTAK/TWINE mixed up with someone else, and I apologize for the error. But then we have this gem directed at Willy, who is as real a Bond fan as any-
    LOL jet set willy
    You couldnt even lace my shoes when it comes to bond.
    Bond ended with Dalton EVERY true fan knows this. No insult meant to Brosnan as I love Goldeneye.
    For interests sake what are your top 5 movies and top 5 books?
    Then I can tell what kinda bond fan you are

    Now that's an arrogant thing to say in a place where we have fans who started watching Bond films when Connery was the one and only Bond. I'm one of them. 44 years a fan. How long have you been a fan?


    If you read the whole conversation between me and jet set willy you will see he insulted me first and second if I recall.
    I wouldnt call it arrogant to defend myself I would call it having self respect.
    I even tried to to offer the olive branch with some humour but got no reply, but hey it hasnt bothered me half as much as it seems to have bothered you.

    I have been a bond fan since christmas 1982, when I was 6, when moonraker was on, still get a great feeling whenever I watch it. I know how corny some parts are but I still have a special place for it.
  • Posts: 11,425
    Sorry what I meant to say was:
    yeah but we are talking about bond respecting people not vesper respecting people.
    my bad

    Jet set willy
    please dont insult me I have been a bond fan since I was a kid.
    I absolutely LOVE them.
    DAD would be lucky to make my top 20.

    At first you said Skyfall was the worst, now it's AVTAK and TWINE. I'm thinking you haven't thought about this very much.

    I'd take AVTAK and TWINE over DAD and MR, no question. Only DAD exceeds MR as the worst Bond film, and that's mostly because of Sir Roger's sense of humor and style.

    What? when did I mention AVTAK or TWINE?
    My top 23 is in the other thread if you want to take a look.
    Which you obviously need to instead of making up sh*t that I never said!!

    You are right, I got you and the AVTAK/TWINE mixed up with someone else, and I apologize for the error. But then we have this gem directed at Willy, who is as real a Bond fan as any-
    LOL jet set willy
    You couldnt even lace my shoes when it comes to bond.
    Bond ended with Dalton EVERY true fan knows this. No insult meant to Brosnan as I love Goldeneye.
    For interests sake what are your top 5 movies and top 5 books?
    Then I can tell what kinda bond fan you are

    Now that's an arrogant thing to say in a place where we have fans who started watching Bond films when Connery was the one and only Bond. I'm one of them. 44 years a fan. How long have you been a fan?


    If you read the whole conversation between me and jet set willy you will see he insulted me first and second if I recall.
    I wouldnt call it arrogant to defend myself I would call it having self respect.
    I even tried to to offer the olive branch with some humour but got no reply, but hey it hasnt bothered me half as much as it seems to have bothered you.

    I have been a bond fan since christmas 1982, when I was 6, when moonraker was on, still get a great feeling whenever I watch it. I know how corny some parts are but I still have a special place for it.

    Ho ho ho - you sure know how to wind up SirHenry. He luuuurves MR!

    Keep up the good work though. There's a bit of a bully/vigilante vibe afoot at the moment and more than a touch of pomposity in addressing new members. I don't buy this nonsense that you have to watch GE and CR back to back for a month before you have the right to comment.
  • @Getafix
    Whats his problem with MR?
    lol
  • Posts: 11,425
    chrisisall wrote:
    Getafix wrote:
    It's amazing that a film made on a fraction of today's budgets by a journeyman director stands the test of time and IMO shows the DC films up for just not being as exciting, well written or enjoyable
    No bigger fan of Dalton here than me, but CR & QOS are pretty darn good movies too IMO.
    But really, nobody does it better than Dalton.

    CR is a solid film. It's not a personal favourite but I can see its merits. Vesper, Mathis and Le Chiffre add real class and weight to the film, as does DC's performance. IMO QoS is just a more enjoyable film. However, I'd still sit down to watch a lot of the oldies first before choosing to watch those two.
  • edited February 2013 Posts: 12,837
    Getafix wrote:
    I think the end of the TLD PTS is actually the icing on the cake. Without it the PTS would be a bit po faced and over earnest. I don't see it as a hold over from Rog, I just think it's classic Bond.

    Exactly. It has all the classic Bond ingredients in what, 10 minutes? Probably less. You have the brilliant stunt, the nasty enemy agent, the nice location, the fit girl in the bikini, etc. It's like a mini Bond movie and it's fantastic. Dalton nails it from the second he turns to face the camera.

    It also sets up the rest of the film nicely with the smert shpionam message.
    Getafix wrote:
    Spy is gloriously, wonderfully OTT - the Rog era at its height.

    @Getafix Check out the TSWLM appreciation thread. We need more love for Spy on this site.
Sign In or Register to comment.