›

The Visually-Differing Gunbarrels Elimination Game

BondBond
edited April 2011 in Bond Movies Posts: 503
This is the second elimination game on the new site, posted with permission from Luds.


1. <FONT COLOR="#FF0000">One vote every 24 hours - Mention the day for which you vote</font> (ex: <b>Monday</b>)
2. <FONT COLOR="#FF0000">Give one category a -1 and one you like a +1 </font>
3. <FONT COLOR="#FF0000">Last entry standing wins! </font>


<FONT COLOR="#0000CC">To suggest future Bond games, please see <b><a href="http://www.mi6community.com/index.php?p=/discussion/209/the-official-bond-game-suggestion-thread">The Official Bond Game Suggestion Thread</a></b>. A queue will be set up with all suggested games, which will be run in order. Games started without permission from the moderators in that thread will be locked instantly. </font>



There was already an elimination game of all 22 gunbarrel sequences back on the old MI6 forum, but for this game we will vote only on 10 that differ visually (i.e. <i>different actor, different take, different graphics</i>). The score is thus not considerable except for OHMSS, DAD, QOS and CR, which are the only individual film gunbarrels listed.</font>

<font size="1">**NOTE — The visual difference between Roger Moore 1 and Roger Moore 2 is that Roger actually filmed a second take starting in TSWLM. The visual difference between Pierce Brosnan 1 and Pierce Brosnan 2 is the CGI bullet added.</font>

Each entry in this original post is linked to a YouTube video of the gunbarrel in question:

<font face="times, serif" size="3">——————</font>

<a href=" Simmons — 5</a>
<a href=" Connery — 5</a>
<a href=" Lazenby — 5</a>
<a href=" Moore (TAKE 1) — 5</a>
<a href=" Moore (TAKE 2) — 5</a>
<a href=" Dalton — 5</a>
<a href=" Brosnan (1995-1999) — 5</a>
<a href=" Brosnan (DAD) — 5</a>
<a href=" Craig (CR) — 5</a>
<a href=" Craig (QOS) — 5</a>

<font face="times, serif" size="3">——————</font>

Here's a video of all of them together:
<a href="http://www.youtube.com/v/osXaHOsDhnE?fs=1">http://www.youtube.com/v/osXaHOsDhnE?fs=1</a>;
«13456789

Comments

  • anotherbondgeekanotherbondgeek
    Posts: 423
    Why don't you just do an elimination game for the 22 different gunbarrels? They all have different music anyway: i.e. GE > DAD.
  • LudsLuds MIA
    Posts: 1,986
    I suppose he cared about the visual aspect rather than the whole, music included.
  • BondBond
    Posts: 503
    Because that one was already done on the other forum, and this one has less entries so will not take as long and will be more head-to-head than a list of 22 entries.
  • BondBond
    edited April 2011 Posts: 503
    But if enough people agree to go with all 22 entries I'm fine with changing it to that if Luds approves the change... I just figured we'd already done that so it would be too repetitive.

    Don't get me wrong, the score is very important to each gunbarrel, but this is really the only way of cutting down the list. Unless we divided by John Barry and David Arnold score, in which case the game would last 5 minutes. :-D
  • LudsLuds MIA
    edited April 2011 Posts: 1,986
    No problem making this a shorter game based on the visual aspect there @Bond, it makes it different to previous games, and we can always run a full gunbarrel game in the future.

    Monday

    Bob Simmons — 5
    Sean Connery — 5
    George Lazenby — 5
    Roger Moore (TAKE 1) — 5
    Roger Moore (TAKE 2) — 5
    Timothy Dalton — 6 +
    Pierce Brosnan (1995-1999) — 5
    Pierce Brosnan (DAD) — 4 - CGI bullet X_X
    Daniel Craig (CR) — 5
    Daniel Craig (QOS) — 5
  • CipherCipher
    Posts: 128
    Monday

    Bob Simmons — 5
    Sean Connery — 5
    George Lazenby — 6
    Roger Moore (TAKE 1) — 5
    Roger Moore (TAKE 2) — 5
    Timothy Dalton — 6
    Pierce Brosnan (1995-1999) — 5
    Pierce Brosnan (DAD) — 3
    Daniel Craig (CR) — 5
    Daniel Craig (QOS) — 5
  • BondBond
    Posts: 503
    Monday

    Bob Simmons — 5
    Sean Connery — 5
    George Lazenby — 7 (+1)
    Roger Moore (TAKE 1) — 5
    Roger Moore (TAKE 2) — 5
    Timothy Dalton — 6
    Pierce Brosnan (1995-1999) — 5
    Pierce Brosnan (DAD) — 3
    Daniel Craig (CR) — 5
    Daniel Craig (QOS) — 4 (-1)
  • TheWizardOfIceTheWizardOfIce 'One of the Internet's more toxic individuals'
    Posts: 9,117
    Monday

    Bob Simmons — 5
    Sean Connery — 5
    George Lazenby — 6
    Roger Moore (TAKE 1) — 5
    Roger Moore (TAKE 2) — 5
    Timothy Dalton — 7 +1
    Pierce Brosnan (1995-1999) — 5
    Pierce Brosnan (DAD) — 3
    Daniel Craig (CR) — 5
    Daniel Craig (QOS) — 4 -1

    Important to remember its solely on the visuals and not let any particular music track cloud your judgement - in which case QOS should be gone by the end of the day.
  • BondBond
    Posts: 503
    CORRECTED LIST:

    Bob Simmons — 5
    Sean Connery — 5
    George Lazenby — 7
    Roger Moore (TAKE 1) — 5
    Roger Moore (TAKE 2) — 5
    Timothy Dalton — 7
    Pierce Brosnan (1995-1999) — 5
    Pierce Brosnan (DAD) — 3
    Daniel Craig (CR) — 5
    Daniel Craig (QOS) — 3
  • JBFan626JBFan626
    Posts: 1,497
    Bob Simmons — 5
    Sean Connery — 5
    George Lazenby — 8 +1
    Roger Moore (TAKE 1) — 5
    Roger Moore (TAKE 2) — 5
    Timothy Dalton — 7
    Pierce Brosnan (1995-1999) — 5
    Pierce Brosnan (DAD) — 3
    Daniel Craig (CR) — 5
    Daniel Craig (QOS) — 2 -1
  • DarthDimiDarthDimi Behind you!Moderator
    edited April 2011 Posts: 24,254
    Monday

    Bob Simmons — 6 +1
    Sean Connery — 5
    George Lazenby — 8
    Roger Moore (TAKE 1) — 5
    Roger Moore (TAKE 2) — 5
    Timothy Dalton — 7
    Pierce Brosnan (1995-1999) — 5
    Pierce Brosnan (DAD) — 3
    Daniel Craig (CR) — 5
    Daniel Craig (QOS) — 1 -1
  • PrinceKamalKhanPrinceKamalKhan Monsoon Palace, Udaipur
    edited April 2011 Posts: 3,262
    Monday

    Bob Simmons — 6
    Sean Connery — 5
    George Lazenby — 8
    Roger Moore (TAKE 1) — 6 (+1)
    Roger Moore (TAKE 2) — 5
    Timothy Dalton — 7
    Pierce Brosnan (1995-1999) — 5
    Pierce Brosnan (DAD) — 3
    Daniel Craig (CR) — 5
    Daniel Craig (QOS) — 0 (-1) ELIMINATED!

    ELIMINATED:

    0010. Daniel Craig (QOS)



  • BondBond
    edited April 2011 Posts: 503
    For anyone who wants to know some background info. on this idea, you can see the original thread here:

    http://www.mi6community.com/index.php?p=/discussion/200/rank-the-differing-gunbarrel-sequences-from-best-to-worst/p1
  • Samuel001Samuel001 Moderator
    Posts: 13,356
    Monday:

    Bob Simmons — 7 (+1)
    Sean Connery — 5
    George Lazenby — 8
    Roger Moore (TAKE 1) — 6
    Roger Moore (TAKE 2) — 5
    Timothy Dalton — 7
    Pierce Brosnan (1995-1999) — 5
    Pierce Brosnan (DAD) — 3
    Daniel Craig (CR) — 4 (-1)

    ELIMINATED:

    10. Daniel Craig (QOS)
  • TheWizardOfIceTheWizardOfIce 'One of the Internet's more toxic individuals'
    Posts: 9,117
    Quoting TheWizardOfIce: in which case QOS should be gone by the end of the day
    Just call me mystic Meg
  • RogueThunderballRogueThunderball
    Posts: 306
    Monday:

    Bob Simmons — 7
    Sean Connery — 5
    George Lazenby — 7 -
    Roger Moore (TAKE 1) — 6
    Roger Moore (TAKE 2) — 5
    Timothy Dalton — 7
    Pierce Brosnan (1995-1999) — 6 +
    Pierce Brosnan (DAD) — 3
    Daniel Craig (CR) — 4

    ELIMINATED:

    10. Daniel Craig (QOS)
  • BondBond
    Posts: 503
    Tuesday:

    Bob Simmons — 7
    Sean Connery — 5
    George Lazenby — 8 (+)
    Roger Moore (TAKE 1) — 6
    Roger Moore (TAKE 2) — 5
    Timothy Dalton — 7
    Pierce Brosnan (1995-1999) — 6
    Pierce Brosnan (DAD) — 3
    Daniel Craig (CR) — 3 (-)

    ELIMINATED:

    10. Daniel Craig (QOS)
  • DarthDimiDarthDimi Behind you!Moderator
    Posts: 24,254
    Tuesday:

    Bob Simmons — 8 (+1)
    Sean Connery — 5
    George Lazenby — 8
    Roger Moore (TAKE 1) — 6
    Roger Moore (TAKE 2) — 5
    Timothy Dalton — 7
    Pierce Brosnan (1995-1999) — 6
    Pierce Brosnan (DAD) — 2 (-1)
    Daniel Craig (CR) — 3

    ELIMINATED:

    10. Daniel Craig (QOS)
  • gt007gt007 Station G
    Posts: 1,182
    Tuesday:

    Bob Simmons — 8
    Sean Connery — 5
    George Lazenby — 8
    Roger Moore (TAKE 1) — 6
    Roger Moore (TAKE 2) — 6 (+1)
    Timothy Dalton — 6 (-1)
    Pierce Brosnan (1995-1999) — 6
    Pierce Brosnan (DAD) — 2
    Daniel Craig (CR) — 3

    ELIMINATED:

    10. Daniel Craig (QOS)
  • NicNacNicNac Administrator, Moderator
    Posts: 7,584
    Tuesday:

    Bob Simmons — 8
    Sean Connery — 4 (-1)
    George Lazenby — 8
    Roger Moore (TAKE 1) — 7 (+1)
    Roger Moore (TAKE 2) — 6
    Timothy Dalton — 6
    Pierce Brosnan (1995-1999) — 6
    Pierce Brosnan (DAD) — 2
    Daniel Craig (CR) — 3

    As much as I champion Sean as Bond, his gun barrel really needed a take 2.
  • BondBond
    edited April 2011 Posts: 503
    Hmm, I think I just realized something....

    Is Daniel Craig's tuxedo coat actually CGI in the Casino Royale gunbarrel? I thought it swayed unnaturally when he turned around and shot, and the more I look at it closely, it looks like he was just wearing a white undershirt and the black coat was digitally added so they could manipulate a dramatic swaying effect.

    If so, wow. That's pathetic.
  • LudsLuds MIA
    edited April 2011 Posts: 1,986
    Tuesday

    Bob Simmons — 8
    Sean Connery — 4
    George Lazenby — 8
    Roger Moore (TAKE 1) — 7
    Roger Moore (TAKE 2) — 6
    Timothy Dalton — 7 (+)
    Pierce Brosnan (1995-1999) — 6
    Pierce Brosnan (DAD) — 1 (-)
    Daniel Craig (CR) — 3
  • JamesStockJamesStock
    edited April 2011 Posts: 572
    I can't stand Bob Simmon's version...the immensly slow walk is so predictable as to what's going to happen.

    Tuesday

    Bob Simmons — 7 (-)
    Sean Connery — 4
    George Lazenby — 8
    Roger Moore (TAKE 1) — 7
    Roger Moore (TAKE 2) — 6
    Timothy Dalton — 8 (+)
    Pierce Brosnan (1995-1999) — 6
    Pierce Brosnan (DAD) — 1
    Daniel Craig (CR) — 3

    How did Daniel Craig's QOS version get killed first? Ack! Yes it's a bit fast, but clean, quick, and natural. @Bond is right, the CR coat looks really fake/unnatural. DAD should have gone first...grrr.
  • LudsLuds MIA
    Posts: 1,986
    Quoting JamesStock: DAD should have gone first...grrr.
    Yes! But you're still not voting it off! ;)
  • BondBond
    edited April 2011 Posts: 503
    Quoting JamesStock: How did Daniel Craig's QOS version get killed first? Ack! Yes it's a bit fast, but clean, quick, and natural.
    Nah, QOS is by far the worst gunbarrel. Way too rushed, ruins the whole tense and built-up atmosphere the gunbarrel sequence is supposed to create. And Craig's walk/shoot is just awful, looks like he couldn't wait to get it over with.
  • PrinceKamalKhanPrinceKamalKhan Monsoon Palace, Udaipur
    edited April 2011 Posts: 3,262
    Tuesday

    Bob Simmons — 7
    Sean Connery — 4
    George Lazenby — 8
    Roger Moore (TAKE 1) — 8 (+1)
    Roger Moore (TAKE 2) — 6
    Timothy Dalton — 8
    Pierce Brosnan (1995-1999) — 5 (-1)
    Pierce Brosnan (DAD) — 1
    Daniel Craig (CR) — 3

  • BondBond
    edited April 2011 Posts: 503
    So Prince, you prefer the CGI bullet in DAD over the three previous otherwise identical incarnations?
  • anotherbondgeekanotherbondgeek
    Posts: 423
    Tuesday

    Bob Simmons — 8 (+1)
    Sean Connery — 4
    George Lazenby — 8
    Roger Moore (TAKE 1) — 8
    Roger Moore (TAKE 2) — 6
    Timothy Dalton — 8
    Pierce Brosnan (1995-1999) — 5
    Pierce Brosnan (DAD) — 0 (-1) ELIMINATED
    Daniel Craig (CR) — 3

    ELIMINATED:

    9. Pierce Brosnan (DAD)
    10. Daniel Craig (QOS)
  • JBFan626JBFan626
    Posts: 1,497
    Quoting JamesStock: I can't stand Bob Simmon's version...the immensly slow walk is so predictable as
    to what's going to happen.
    I kind of see what you mean, but on the contrary I think the slow walk adds more menace; and the whole sequence is supposed to be an exaggeration to some degree. What stands out in Bob Simmons is his posture and stance. He has more physicality than the other actors.

    Bob Simmons — 8
    Sean Connery — 4
    George Lazenby — 9 +1
    Roger Moore (TAKE 1) — 8
    Roger Moore (TAKE 2) — 6
    Timothy Dalton — 8
    Pierce Brosnan (1995-1999) — 4 -1
    Daniel Craig (CR) — 3
  • Samuel001Samuel001 Moderator
    Posts: 13,356
    Bob Simmons — 9 (+1)
    Sean Connery — 4
    George Lazenby — 9
    Roger Moore (TAKE 1) — 8
    Roger Moore (TAKE 2) — 6
    Timothy Dalton — 8
    Pierce Brosnan (1995-1999) — 4
    Daniel Craig (CR) — 2 (-1)
Sign In or Register to comment.