It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
^ Back to Top
The MI6 Community is unofficial and in no way associated or linked with EON Productions, MGM, Sony Pictures, Activision or Ian Fleming Publications. Any views expressed on this website are of the individual members and do not necessarily reflect those of the Community owners. Any video or images displayed in topics on MI6 Community are embedded by users from third party sites and as such MI6 Community and its owners take no responsibility for this material.
James Bond News • James Bond Articles • James Bond Magazine
Comments
1. Direction - 6
2. Screenplay - 4
3. Script - 5
4. Plot - 5
5. Action - 5
6. Main Villain - 6
7. Main Bond Girl - 5
8. Bond - 8
9. Sets - 6
10. Music - 6
11. Cinematography - 6
12. Fleming - 3
13. Supporting Cast - 3
14. Main Titles - 4
15. Plausibility - 3
16. Pace - 3
17. Editing - 3
18. Tilt - 3
84/150 (56%)
/10
1. Direction – 9
2. Screenplay – 8 (Silva's escape and plan is wildly unintelligent)
3. Script – 9
4. Plot – 8 (It's TWINE redux, but I think it's done better)
5. Action - 10
6. Main Villain – 10
7. Main Bond Girl – 6 (way too minimal)
8. Bond – 10
9. Sets – 9
10. Music – 8 (I'm really mixed on this; Breadcrumbs, Tennyson and the Macau casino score as Bond rides in the boat are some of the best pieces of Bond music ever; yet there's so little Bond theme and so much generic meh as well)
11. Cinematography – 10 (Yeah I mean... it's Deakins. This would've been a 10 on his worst day, let alone what is quite possibly his best work ever)
12. Fleming – 10 (They had the balls to confront Bond's past properly, for the first time ever in the films)
/5
13. Supporting Cast – 5
14. Main Titles – 4
15. Plausibility - 3 (Silva's escape is just so bad)
16. Pace - 5
17. Editing –5
18. Tilt – 5
134/150 = 89.33%
/10
1. Direction – 8
2. Screenplay – 7
3. Script – 8
4. Plot – 7
5. Action - 8
6. Main Villain – 8
7. Main Bond Girl - 7
8. Bond – 8
9. Sets – 6
10. Music – 6
11. Cinematography – 10
12. Fleming - 8
/5
13. Supporting Cast – 4
14. Main Titles - 4
15. Plausibility - 3
16. Pace - 4
17. Editing - 4
18. Tilt – 4
114/150
76%
2014 Results - Skyfall – 75.4%, 13th out of 23 films
Well, SF's reputation has survived it seems – just a couple of % points up on it's 2014 results. Which surprised me.
Community Ratings 2016-
Goldfinger – 81.87%
Dr. No – 80.88%
The Living Daylights – 80.73%
GoldenEye – 80.12%
The Spy Who Loved Me – 78.59%
Skyfall – 77.39%
Quantum of Solace – 74%
Thunderball – 73.27%
The Man With The Golden Gun – 69.6%
The World Is Not Enough – 69.03%
Moonraker – 66.81%
Ah, behind Spy. I think that is about right.
On Her Majesty's Secret Service, 1969
/10
1. Direction – 10
2. Screenplay – 9
3. Script – 10
4. Plot – 7 (quite outlandish to be sure)
5. Action – 10
6. Main Villain – 8 (the best of the Blofeld's)
7. Main Bond Girl – 10
8. Bond – 8 (George done well for a non-actor)
9. Sets – 9 (plus points for Piz Gloria)
10. Music – 10
11. Cinematography – 10 (A real highlight of the series)
12. Fleming – 10
/5
13. Supporting Cast – 5
14. Main Titles – 5
15. Plausibility – 4
16. Pace - 4
17. Editing –5
18. Tilt – 5
139/150 = 92.66%
Royale's Ranking -
On Her Majesty's Secret Service - 92.66%
Goldfinger – 91.33%
Dr. No – 88.66%
The Living Daylights – 84%
Skyfall – 83.33%
Thunderball – 82.66%
The Spy Who Loved Me – 82%
Quantum of Solace – 81.33%
GoldenEye – 79.33%
The World Is Not Enough – 74.66%
Moonraker - 72.66%
The Man With The Golden Gun – 67.33%
/10
1. Direction – 10
2. Screenplay – 8
3. Script – 9
4. Plot – 8
5. Action - 9
6. Main Villain – 9
7. Main Bond Girl - 9
8. Bond – 9
9. Sets – 10
10. Music – 10
11. Cinematography – 9
12. Fleming - 10
/5
13. Supporting Cast – 5
14. Main Titles - 5
15. Plausibility - 4
16. Pace - 5
17. Editing - 5
18. Tilt – 5
139/150 =92,66%
DD's Ranking
On Her Majesty's Secret Service, 1969 - 92,66%
GoldenEye, 1995 - 86,00%
Skyfall, 2012 - 84,00%
The Living Daylights, 1987 - 83,33%
Dr. No, 1962 – 82.67%
Thunderball, 1965 - 79,33%
Goldfinger, 1964 - 78,00%
Quantum Of Solace, 2008 - 76,67%
Moonraker, 1979 - 75,33%
The Spy Who Loved Me, 1977 - 71,33%
The World Is Not Enough, 1999 - 60,67%
The Man With The Golden Gun, 1974 - 60,00%
/10
1. Direction – 10
2. Screenplay – 10
3. Script – 10
4. Plot – 10
5. Action - 10
6. Main Villain – 10
7. Main Bond Girl - 10
8. Bond – 8
9. Sets – 10
10. Music – 10
11. Cinematography – 10
12. Fleming - 10
/5
13. Supporting Cast – 5
14. Main Titles - 3
15. Plausibility - 3
16. Pace - 5
17. Editing - 5
18. Tilt – 5
144/150
96%
/10
1. Direction – 9
2. Screenplay – 8
3. Script – 8
4. Plot – 8
5. Action - 9
6. Main Villain – 9
7. Main Bond Girl - 10
8. Bond – 7
9. Sets – 10
10. Music – 10
11. Cinematography – 10
12. Fleming - 10
/5
13. Supporting Cast – 5
14. Main Titles - 2
15. Plausibility - 2
16. Pace - 3
17. Editing - 3
18. Tilt – 4
127/150
84,3333%
/10
1. Direction – 10
2. Screenplay – 10
3. Script – 10
4. Plot – 8
5. Action - 10
6. Main Villain – 10
7. Main Bond Girl -10
8. Bond – 8
9. Sets – 10
10. Music – 10
11. Cinematography – 10
12. Fleming - 10
/5
13. Supporting Cast – 5
14. Main Titles - 4
15. Plausibility - 5
16. Pace - 4
17. Editing - 5
18. Tilt – 5
144/150
96%
/10
1. Direction – 10 (duh.)
2. Screenplay – 9 (tiny little bit of the middle of the film is a bit egregious to me.)
3. Script – 10 (duh.)
4. Plot – 7 (the points off are entirely for Blofeld not recognizing Bond)
5. Action – 10 (duh. Lazenby really is the best fighter of the Bonds.)
6. Main Villain – 10 (God he's just so good.)
7. Main Bond Girl – 10 (DUUUHHHH!!)
8. Bond – 9 (You know what? Yeah. He has his issues in the role and with certain lines in the film. But my favourite scenes in this film are some of my absolute favourites of the series or even cinema for that matter, and George is the reason why. Plus he added a certain vulnerability and a humanity to Bond that Connery never had, and I think that makes him a great precursor to Dalton and Craig.
9. Sets – 10 (Ohhhhhhh yesssssss
10. Music – 10 (Barry On His Bondian Best Service.)
11. Cinematography – 10 (Yeup.)
12. Fleming – 10 (Well naturally, as it's the only totally straight adaptation of one of the novels. This should be an objective 10 for everyone.)
/5
13. Supporting Cast – 5 (yep.)
14. Main Titles – 4 (The hourglass looks a tad cheap.)
15. Plausibility – 5
16. Pace - 4 (Like I said, that tiny bit in the middle.
17. Editing – 5 (But of course)
18. Tilt – 5 (God I love this movie. So much.)
143/150 = 95.33%
/10
1. Direction – 10
2. Screenplay – 9
3. Script – 10
4. Plot – 8
5. Action - 8
6. Main Villain – 9
7. Main Bond Girl -10
8. Bond – 8
9. Sets – 8
10. Music – 10 (The best Bond score ever)
11. Cinematography – 10 (For that glorious daytime down the mountain ski chase alone)
12. Fleming - 10
/5
13. Supporting Cast – 5
14. Main Titles - 4
15. Plausibility - 3
16. Pace - 4
17. Editing - 5
18. Tilt – 5
136/150 = 90.6%
/10
1. Direction – 8 ( A bit goofy, but pretty great on action scenes and briefing scenes)
2. Screenplay – 10
3. Script – 10
4. Plot – 10
5. Action - 10
6. Main Villain – 6 (Koskov is a pretty great villain, is like kristratos but more friendly, and Whitaker is pretty boring villain w/c is forgettable specially that glass gun that you cant hit him on the foot)
7. Main Bond Girl - 7 ( Kara is a pretty annoying bond girl but independent and very stupid in the same time)
8. Bond – 10 (The Real James Bond Timothy Dalton Really Act the heck out of it)
9. Sets – 10
10. Music – 10
11. Cinematography – 10
12. Fleming - 10 (Timothy Dalton is very Fleming-esque portrayal of the character also that interrogation scene with gen. pushkin)
/5
13. Supporting Cast – 5
14. Main Titles - 5
15. Plausibility - 4 (Some where Unrealistic and unbelivable , but more realistic, good thing that carpet scene never happend)
16. Pace - 3 ( A Bit slow and same time energetic)
17. Editing - 5
18. Tilt – 5
138/150 = 88%
MI60071987892016's Ranking -
Goldfinger - 98%
On Her Majesty's Secret Service - 96%
The Spy Who Loved Me - 93.33%
Thunderball - 92%
Dr. No – 88.66%
Skyfall - 82.66%
Quantum Of Solace - 82%
GoldenEye - 78%
The Man With The Golden Gun – 75.33%
The Living Daylights - 88%
Moonraker - 73.33%
The World Is Not Enough - 71.33%
1. Direction - 8
2. Screenplay - 8
3. Script - 8
4. Plot - 8
5. Action - 8
6. Main Villain - 8
7. Main Bond Girl - 8
8. Bond - 8
9. Sets - 8
10. Music - 8
11. Cinematography - 8
12. Fleming - 8
13. Supporting Cast - 4
14. Main Titles - 3
15. Plausibility - 4
16. Pace -4
17. Editing - 4
18. Tilt - 4
Total: 119/150 (79,33%)
/10
1. Direction – 10
2. Screenplay – 9
3. Script – 8
4. Plot – 8
5. Action — 9
6. Main Villain – 8
7. Main Bond Girl — 9
8. Bond – 9
9. Sets – 9
10. Music – 10
11. Cinematography – 9
12. Fleming — 10
/5
13. Supporting Cast – 4
14. Main Titles — 3
15. Plausibility — 3
16. Pace — 3
17. Editing — 4
18. Tilt – 5
130/150
86,67%
GoldenGun's Rankings
Goldfinger - 88
On Her Majesty's Secret Service - 86,67
The Living Daylights/GoldenEye - 82
The Spy Who Loved Me - 75,33
Dr. No - 74
The Man with the Golden Gun - 73,33
Thunderball/Skyfall - 70
The World Is Not Enough - 68,67
Quantum of Solace - 68
Moonraker - 57,33
/10
1. Direction – 8
2. Screenplay – 8
3. Script – 7
4. Plot – 8
5. Action - 8
6. Main Villain – 7
7. Main Bond Girl - 8
8. Bond – 4
9. Sets – 7
10. Music – 9
11. Cinematography – 8
12. Fleming - 9
/5
13. Supporting Cast – 5
14. Main Titles - 4
15. Plausibility - 3
16. Pace - 4
17. Editing - 4
18. Tilt – 5
116/150
77.33 %
Tanaka's Rankings
On Her Majesty's Secret Service - 77.33%
Skyfall - 76.67%
Dr. No - 75.33%
The Living Daylights - 74.67% / GoldenEye - 74.67
Quantum of Solace - 69.33% / Thunderball - 69.33%
The Man with the Golden Gun - 68.67%
Moonraker - 68% / The Spy Who Loved Me - 68%
The World is Not Enough - 60.67%
1. Direction – 10
2. Screenplay – 10
3. Script – 10
4. Plot – 8
5. Action - 10
6. Main Villain – 8
7. Main Bond Girl - 10
8. Bond – 8
9. Sets – 10
10. Music – 10
11. Cinematography – 10
12. Fleming - 10
13. Supporting Cast – 4
14. Main Titles - 4
15. Plausibility - 3
16. Pace - 4
17. Editing - 4
18. Tilt – 5
Total - 138/150 = 92%
vzok's ranking:
On Her Majesty's Secret Service - 92
The Living Daylights - 80
GoldenEye - 74
Skyfall - 74
Dr No - 69.33
Quantum Of Solace - 68
Goldfinger - 68
Thunderball - 67.33
Moonraker - 66
The Spy Who Loved Me - 64.66
The World Is Not Enough - 60
The Man With The Golden Gun - 58
On Her Majesty's Secret Service – 89.66%
Goldfinger – 81.87%
Dr. No – 80.88%
The Living Daylights – 80.73%
GoldenEye – 80.12%
The Spy Who Loved Me – 78.59%
Skyfall – 77.39%
Quantum of Solace – 74%
Thunderball – 73.27%
The Man With The Golden Gun – 69.6%
The World Is Not Enough – 69.03%
Moonraker – 66.81%
Clear of Goldfinger. I think that will take some beating. Let's see how it compares to the 2014 results – 88.50% which placed it 2nd.
James Bond will return...
Octopussy, 1983
/10
1. Direction – 9
2. Screenplay – 9
3. Script – 9
4. Plot – 10
5. Action – 8
6. Main Villain – 8 (“Octopussy, Octopussy”)
7. Main Bond Girl – 9 (I like Bond and Octopussy's chemistry)
8. Bond – 9 (Moore's advancing years are offset wonderfully by his laconic humour)
9. Sets – 8 (plus points for Octopussy's bed)
10. Music – 8
11. Cinematography – 8
12. Fleming – 8 (A fair bit of Fleming here, plus the Cold War bumpf)
/5
13. Supporting Cast – 4
14. Main Titles – 3
15. Plausibility – 4
16. Pace - 4
17. Editing –4
18. Tilt – 5
127/150 = 84.66%
Royale's Ranking -
On Her Majesty's Secret Service - 92.66%
Goldfinger – 91.33%
Dr. No – 88.66%
Octopussy – 84.66%
The Living Daylights – 84%
Skyfall – 83.33%
Thunderball – 82.66%
The Spy Who Loved Me – 82%
Quantum of Solace – 81.33%
GoldenEye – 79.33%
The World Is Not Enough – 74.66%
Moonraker - 72.66%
The Man With The Golden Gun – 67.33%
Wow, better than TLD and TB. Congrats OP!
/10
1. Direction – 9
2. Screenplay – 9
3. Script – 9
4. Plot – 10
5. Action - 10
6. Main Villain – 9
7. Main Bond Girl - 9
8. Bond – 10
9. Sets – 8
10. Music – 9
11. Cinematography – 9
12. Fleming - 8
/5
13. Supporting Cast – 5
14. Main Titles - 4
15. Plausibility - 5
16. Pace - 5
17. Editing - 4
18. Tilt – 5
137/150
91.33%
/10
1. Direction – 7
2. Screenplay – 4
3. Script – 7
4. Plot – 6
5. Action — 8
6. Main Villain – 7
7. Main Bond Girl — 7
8. Bond – 7
9. Sets – 8
10. Music – 7
11. Cinematography – 7
12. Fleming — 5
/5
13. Supporting Cast – 3
14. Main Titles — 2
15. Plausibility — 3
16. Pace — 2
17. Editing — 3
18. Tilt – 2
99/150
66 %
GoldenGun's Rankings
Goldfinger - 88
On Her Majesty's Secret Service - 86,67
The Living Daylights/GoldenEye - 82
The Spy Who Loved Me - 75,33
Dr. No - 74
The Man with the Golden Gun - 73,33
Thunderball/Skyfall - 70
The World Is Not Enough - 68,67
Quantum of Solace - 68
Octopussy - 66
Moonraker - 57,33
/10
1. Direction – 7
2. Screenplay – 7
3. Script – 8
4. Plot – 8
5. Action - 6
6. Main Villain – 6
7. Main Bond Girl - 9
8. Bond – 9
9. Sets – 9
10. Music – 8
11. Cinematography – 7
12. Fleming - 8
/5
13. Supporting Cast – 4
14. Main Titles - 3
15. Plausibility - 5
16. Pace - 5
17. Editing - 5
18. Tilt – 4
118/150 =78,66%
DD's Ranking
On Her Majesty's Secret Service, 1969 - 92,66%
GoldenEye, 1995 - 86,00%
Skyfall, 2012 - 84,00%
The Living Daylights, 1987 - 83,33%
Dr. No, 1962 – 82.67%
Thunderball, 1965 - 79,33%
Octopussy, 1983 - 78,66%
Goldfinger, 1964 - 78,00%
Quantum Of Solace, 2008 - 76,67%
Moonraker, 1979 - 75,33%
The Spy Who Loved Me, 1977 - 71,33%
The World Is Not Enough, 1999 - 60,67%
The Man With The Golden Gun, 1974 - 60,00%
/10
1. Direction – 7
2. Screenplay – 7
3. Script – 7
4. Plot – 7
5. Action - 8
6. Main Villain – 7
7. Main Bond Girl - 7
8. Bond – 7
9. Sets – 8
10. Music – 7
11. Cinematography – 7
12. Fleming - 8
/5
13. Supporting Cast – 3
14. Main Titles - 3
15. Plausibility - 5
16. Pace - 4
17. Editing - 4
18. Tilt – 3
109/150
72,66%
Octopussy, 1983
/10
1. Direction – 9
2. Screenplay – 7
3. Script – 8
4. Plot – 8
5. Action - 8
6. Main Villain – 8
7. Main Bond Girl - 9
8. Bond – 8
9. Sets – 8
10. Music – 9
11. Cinematography – 8
12. Fleming - 8
/5
13. Supporting Cast – 5
14. Main Titles - 3
15. Plausibility - 3
16. Pace - 4
17. Editing - 4
18. Tilt – 3
120/150
80,00%
1. Direction – 8
2. Screenplay – 8
3. Script – 9
4. Plot – 9
5. Action - 10
6. Main Villain – 8
7. Main Bond Girl - 8
8. Bond – 8
9. Sets – 8
10. Music – 8
11. Cinematography – 8
12. Fleming - 8
13. Supporting Cast – 3
14. Main Titles - 2
15. Plausibility - 4
16. Pace - 5
17. Editing - 4
18. Tilt – 5
Total - 123/150 = 82%
vzok's ranking:
On Her Majesty's Secret Service - 92
Octopussy - 82
The Living Daylights - 80
GoldenEye - 74
Skyfall - 74
Dr No - 69.33
Quantum Of Solace - 68
Goldfinger - 68
Thunderball - 67.33
Moonraker - 66
The Spy Who Loved Me - 64.66
The World Is Not Enough - 60
The Man With The Golden Gun - 58