It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
^ Back to Top
The MI6 Community is unofficial and in no way associated or linked with EON Productions, MGM, Sony Pictures, Activision or Ian Fleming Publications. Any views expressed on this website are of the individual members and do not necessarily reflect those of the Community owners. Any video or images displayed in topics on MI6 Community are embedded by users from third party sites and as such MI6 Community and its owners take no responsibility for this material.
James Bond News • James Bond Articles • James Bond Magazine
Comments
I don't think DN is under appreciated. I certainly don't recall seeing anyone rank it at the bottom of their Bond ranking.
MURDOCK'S BONDATHON RANKING
Thunderball
Dr. No
From Russia With Love
Goldfinger
I had never noticed that the character who wants to murder Scaramanga in the PTS is the same character who had appeared in Diamonds are Forever.
Something which made me confused is why is Anders so reticent after the shower scene if it was her who asked for Bond's help in the first place? I understand she's scared, but she doesn't seem so willing to help Bond until he slaps her.
Ranking:
1. OHMSS
2. FRWL
3. DN
4. TMWTGG
5. GF
6. TB
7. LALD
8. CR '54
9. YOLT
10. CR '67
Yes, why is The Man with the Golden Gun regarded as the bottom of the Bond barrel by so many? I mean OK, The kung fu interlude is pointless, as is the Solex macguffin. But it has a lot going for it, too.
Saying that though I still like the film and think Christopher Lee and Maud Adams are superb and I also like Herve Villichez. The scene between Bond and Lazar is brilliant with a great line and I like the meeting between Bond and Scaramanga at the kick boxing when Andrea is killed.
I think there are just too many things that grate on me and they outweigh the positives, it is not my least favourite by far but it does come in 5th from bottom.
LALD was popular?
The Box office was not great for TMWTGG though.
Yes. It was the most successful Bond since TB in global Box office at the time.
I'm a huge fan of TMWTGG. Sure, it has the silly moments, but that doesn't ruin the film for me, because I feel Moore is at the top of his game in this one & it's quite eccentric & atmospheric. I'd have a similar high opinion of DAF (also a film with silly bits) if Connery were just a little lighter with a better toupee. So I don't mind silliness in moderation.
@Birdleson, TWINE is at the absolute bottom of my list. It's the one Bond film that I honestly have a lot of trouble watching without cringing (maybe AVTAK as well, due to it being such a poor sendoff for Moore & the obvious budget cuts/lack of ambition).
What about Moonraker? Can you put up with the campiness and just enjoy the ride or do you find the cheese a bit too strong? I only ask because I recently revisited MR after years of loathing it and found it to be highly enjoyable this time around. It's great when you find yourself embracing the fantasy elements and the slapstick that previously had you rolling your eyes. Even if Moore doesn't give his best performances in TSWLM and MR, they are the two films that I most associate with his style of Bond. Big, Bloated Fantasy Romps. You really feel like anything can happen in this world and that's half the fun. All the elements come together to create a huge cinematic spectacle. Yes, I had a lot of fun with Moonraker on my last viewing...
I do enjoy MR, but far less than I did when younger. It's still a great fantasy Bond as it will always be for me (probably the most outlandish one they ever did) but I just find many of the action sequences annoying only because of the way they end them, eg. (pretitles Jaws laugh, gondola gadget laugh, speedboat falls laugh, python pen attack laugh etc. etc.). If they had just ended those action sequences more seriously, and kept Jaws dangerous, I'd easily have it as a top 10 film.
When they go serious, like the museum Chang fight, simulator, space factory poison death, or Corinne death, it's as good as it gets. Drax is an awesome villain with great lines too & Barry's score is truly sublime. That's why it's such an frustrating film for me, because it's so close to being brilliant but falls short.
I'm 100% in agreement with you about Moore though. No one comes close to doing the bloated fantasy romp as well as he did. He 100% sold the unflappable Bond and that's why he was so successful with those kinds of films (eg. OP, MR & his best imho, TSWLM).
Yes, I think Jaws represents the monster from a horror film and should be played straight, not for laughs. That being said, I think the Comedy moments with jaws in TSWLM are just about acceptable, like dropping the stone on his foot. It's something you aren't expecting and is over in a second, not too degrading to the character as a whole and also quite funny and inventive. The final fight between Bond and Jaws (TSWLM) is quite underwhelming because Jaws is too slow and lumbering, Bond can just jog away from him, but I like the idea of Jaws vs Jaws the shark.
The biggest reason I am excited for SPECTRE is to see a return of the larger than life, epic tone of those middle Moore movies. From what we can see, the globetrotting is certainly making a return and also perhaps some gadgets. I only hope they can get the balance right like with Moonraker. I also hope it won't be too long before we get another army vs army fight. It's been so long since had one of those, It almost feels as though it's one elements of the bond films that's been forgotten about.
I'm not sure if I could do THIS, but I will be organizing something hehe.
Granted, Bond's main goal was Goodnight's love, but it still was a wonderful example that Bond is not a killing machine but a human.
If I had friends who like Bond, I would do it. But, alas, none of my (few) friends do.
MURDOCK'S BONDATHON RANKING.
Thunderball
Dr. No
From Russia With Love
Goldfinger
You Only Live Twice
Any more people who like to organize a bondathon like this?
The World Is Not Enough
The Spy Who Loved Me
Dr No
Octopussy
You Only Live Twice
Casino Royale
Moonraker
The Living Daylights
Die Another Day
From Russia With Love
For Your Eyes Only
Diamonds Are Forever
A View To A Kill
Quantum Of Solace
Thunderball
GoldenEye
The Man With The Golden Gun
Goldfinger
On Her Majesty's Secret Service
Live And Let Die
_______________________________________________________________________
So Roger Moore debuts in this popular entry in the series. Likeable if slightly hollow feeling film. However for the first time ever I think I prefer Golden Gun to this one. Never thought I'd say that!
Next up -Licence To Kill
I hear ya. I honestly think the first 30-40 minutes of DAD are perfectly fine, at least enough to catch my attention and have me intrigued for what might happen next. Then…oh boy...
MURDOCK'S BONDATHON RANKING.
Thunderball
Dr. No
From Russia With Love
Goldfinger
Diamonds are Forever
You Only Live Twice
I wouldn't say DAF is complete nonsense. I think like many of the not so popular to hated Bond films then to have strong first acts but fall apart later on. Diamonds did have an interesting setup but once Blofeld was revealed to be pulling the strings and a doomsday laser was added, that's where the film falls apart. But if YOLT can have a Space ship "eat" other ships then it's not that outrageous after all. :P
MURDOCK'S BONDATHON RANKING.
On Her Majesty's Secret Service.
Thunderball.
Dr. No.
From Russia With Love.
Goldfinger.
Diamonds Are Forever.
You Only Live Twice.
Now onto the Moore era.
MURDOCK'S BONDATHON RANKING.
On Her Majesty's Secret Service.
Thunderball.
Dr. No.
Live and Let Die.
From Russia With Love.
Goldfinger.
Diamonds Are Forever.
You Only Live Twice.
Jokes aside, for me it's hard to place, but because it wasn't as boring as YOLT it gets saved from being put at the very bottom, but that's not saying much.
MURDOCK'S BONDATHON RANKING.
On Her Majesty's Secret Service.
Thunderball.
Dr. No.
Live and Let Die.
From Russia With Love.
Goldfinger.
Diamonds Are Forever.
The Man With The Golden Gun.
You Only Live Twice.
which means...
miniBONDATHON!!
TLD & LTK starting NOW.
TND & another Brosnan tomorrow!
YAHOO!!