It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
^ Back to Top
The MI6 Community is unofficial and in no way associated or linked with EON Productions, MGM, Sony Pictures, Activision or Ian Fleming Publications. Any views expressed on this website are of the individual members and do not necessarily reflect those of the Community owners. Any video or images displayed in topics on MI6 Community are embedded by users from third party sites and as such MI6 Community and its owners take no responsibility for this material.
James Bond News • James Bond Articles • James Bond Magazine
Comments
1. CR
2. SF
3. SP
4. QOS
After I've seen NTTD I will of course update this. I realize the fate of the world rests on this ranking of mine. ;)
2. SF
3. NTTD
4. SP
5. QoS
...having really read up on all the publications and asked just about everyone I know from work colleagues to friends/family then the latter (and for the record not my own) ranking would be more like:
SF
NTTD
CR
SP
QoS
Well, not for everyone. I put CR and QoS' - early Craig - if you like, firmly at the top.
But yes SF benefitted HUGELY from the 2012 Olympic vibes, Adele, and the massive PR machine that drove it forward.
There wasn't a film-critic or newspaper in the UK that dared to give it a mediocre review...
Interesting
Is that because it all leads to the death of M, and therefore can feel like a defeat rather than a victory?
In which case might you not feel the same about NTTD after a while? (as in, death of Bond, very harrowing and moving, but do you want to go through it all again?)
Or was due to the dubious "character development" of M during Skyfall?
I would feel more like watching SF again if M had been portrayed differently, but the lack of a moral compass displayed by M during the movie was such that by the end I found it hard to care about her anymore, or understand why Bond did.
I can see QOS is the closest Craig came to a "normal" Bond movie without any personal relationship baggage.
Spectre also had the stated intention of wanting to be more like an old school Bond movie, but ends up being side-tracked to some extent by the Brofeld angle
But Casino Royale in 4th is hard to fathom?
Honestly, none of that stuff bothers me. The death of M, and how M was handled throughout, I liked. I agree with you about QoS and Spectre. And I agree that CR in 4th is hard to fathom, I think I just liked the ranking because so many Craig rankings are very similar, CR, SF, QOS, SP. NTTD throws a nice wrench into it too as it seems to appear all over the place for people.
My issue with SF is that in my mind it tends to drag a bit, especially the third act. To me it feels longer than SP and NTTD. It's, like, perfectly competently made, but just lacks something intangible that to me makes it *interesting*, I guess. Hard to put my finger on it.
My "Craig Films I Want To Watch" ranking is probably like, CR, SP, QOS, SF. But I know that SF is a better film than SP and QOS, so it's hard for me.
I'm intentionally leaving out NTTD of my rankings until I've sit with it a bit longer, but it's high up.
Oh no. Now I'll have to recruit two more TLD likers to set things right again.
I guess you mean Cary Tagawa; well, he's been too busy setting it up for years, for Sanchez.
2. CR
3. NTTD
4. SP
5. QoS
Overall, I think DC has had a very solid run. Two undisputed classics in his tenure, which is pretty impressive. (Of course, now that I've said that, people will start disputing. LOL)
CR > QOS > SF > NTTD > SP
However, if you asked me which films felt the most (cinematic) Bondian, I'd rank them like this:
SF > SP > CR > QOS > NTTD
But if you asked me which one was the best film (based on story, acting, production, etc), with my personal preferences aside and ignoring how "Bondian" they were, I feel like it should be more like:
NTTD > CR > SF > QOS > SP
Personally I don’t understand that either. SP and NTTD are more traditionally “Bondian” than the first 3 Craig films, though it’s worth noting that does nothing for me in quality one way or another since I’m not a big fan of SP but really like NTTD.
(despite some flaws, the bigger, emotional plot points hit me so hard) 1/NTTD
Followed closely (by centimetres) 2/SF
Followed closely (by a half inch) 3/CR
Followed (by an inch) 4/QOS
Then… by a country mile behind these four…..
SP….
Skyfall
Casino Royale
Quantum of Solace
Spectre
Doh! your right, that's the fella, what was I thinking?
Don't worry, next time I watch TLD my Dalton ranking will probably turn on it's head again...
2. Skyfall
3. No Time to Die
4. Quantum of Solace
5. Spectre
2. CR (#6)
3. SP (#16)
4. QoS (#19)
5. NTTD (#25)
QoS
SF
NTTD
SP
SF
SP
QoS
NTTD
1. CR
2. NTTD
3. SF
4. SP
5. QOS
I think after five films, Daniel Craig knocks this one out of the park. A brilliant final Bond film from a Bond actor. Wonders never cease.
The Same for me. Big gap between the last two.
QOS
SP
2. Skyfall
3. Quantum of Solace
4. Casino Royale
5. No Time to Die
1. CR
2. NTTD
3. SP
4. SF
5. QOS
2. NTTD
3. Skyfall
4. Spectre
5. QoS
This would work for me totally if I could get over the last part of NTTD. Perhaps one day..
1. No Time to Die
2. Casino Royale
3. Skyfall
4. Quantum of Solace
5. SPECTRE