Sam Mendes to direct Bond 24?

1121315171842

Comments

  • doubleoegodoubleoego #LightWork
    edited March 2013 Posts: 11,139
    RC7 wrote:
    Well my vote goes to the master, Mr. Stanley Kubrick. Given some of the suggestions on here, I'd wager that reanimating his corpse is no stumbling block for some users.


    :-D
  • Posts: 194
    doubleoego wrote:
    RC7 wrote:
    Well my vote goes to the master, Mr. Stanley Kubrick. Given some of the suggestions on here, I'd wager that reanimating his corpse is no stumbling block for some users.


    :-D

    :)) Not the worst idea I've heard.
  • Posts: 498
    I think I have seen something which I find many have OVERLOOKED .

    Look at what we know the only the one on the Bond 24 project who is in control right now is - John Logan

    He is the one who takes the shots now, and if he were to choose a director he would want to work with again it would be Scorsese since .
    His most successful films to date , which he got the most awards for were Aviator and Hugo both Scorsese films.
  • edited March 2013 Posts: 11,119
    RC7 wrote:
    Tuulia wrote:
    Tom Hooper and David Fincher are more or less my favourites now. They can do a similar Sam Mendes-like direction. And they have a good chance considering the actors they bring in and considering the ties they have with Craig.

    What ties does Hooper have with Craig?

    Also, why are Hooper and Fincher favourites? Before SF I don't remember anyone considering Mendes as an option. 'Away We Go' had been his previous directorial effort, and if my memory serves me right it got middling reviews and didn't make it's minimal budget back at the BO. I don't think it's a given that some big hitter or current flavour of the month is necessarily top of the list. There are a tonne of directors out there who B+M will be mulling over IMO.

    Uhm....it is truly a pity that http://www.mi6forums.com doesn't exist anymore, but I actually mentioned Sam Mendes before on there :-S. Yes, 'Away We Go' wasn't a big success. It even got quite a bunch of negative reviews. But against that movie one can place his succesful ones, like 'American Beauty', 'Road To Perdition' and 'Revolutionary Road'. I can actually recall a topic in here where 'Skyfall' fits in these bunch of movies, tone-wise, style-wise.

    I had to be a bit clearer regarding Tom Hooper and David Fincher. I think with Tom Hooper you can bring in some other great actors that would like to work with him again, but now on a Bond film (Helena Bonham Carter, Colin Firth).

    David Fincher has worked with Daniel Craig, like Sam Mendes. Considering his influential suggestions towards EION, I don't see why David Fincher will be ignored completely because of his nationality. That's stupidity! Martin Campbell and Lee Tamahori are New Zealand born directors. Roger Spottiswoode is Canadian and Marc Forster is Swiss.

    Moreover, contribute to this topic by naming a few directors @RC7. I love this forum because we can actually speak about our ideas and visions for Bond 24. You are slamming mine down like Hulk Hogan and don't give any other alternative. I find that a bit lame. Sorry to say this.
    So, my list has narrowed down to:
    --> Christopher Nolan
    --> Tom Hooper
    --> Guy Ritchie
    --> David Fincher
    --> Steven Soderbergh, &
    --> Joe Wright

    I agree mostly with this list.

    1. Nolan: He would be great. The opening of TDKR is the best pre-title sequence not in a Bond film. He does seem like the perfect guy to continue this series. But he is the victim of his own success, he can do anything he wants and has grown heavily in prestige in the last few years that he has effectively ruled himself out. Plus Inception is not the masterpiece its made out to be and TDKR showed how Nolan's storytelling crown was clearly falling.
    2. Hooper: I want to hate the idea, but I don't. I actually quite like it. The idea of the director of The King's Speech and Les Mis seems repulsive but looking at his past work on television he's actually a filmmaker with great talent. He's also suitably suave and sophisticated in life, very much like Sam Mendes.
    3.Ritchie: God please no. I don't think the prods would be foolish enough to let Ritchie anywhere near the franchise.
    4: Fincher: I concur. He makes great films with great characters and great twisted macabre storylines. If he wasn't American he would be the number 1 guy in the frame right now. I hope the prods can get over themselves and finally hire a great American filmmaker. Why not start with Finch? After all he made the very European TGWTDT.
    5. Soderbergh: Never going to happen. Next.
    6. Wright: The best name on the list. He's young and has a lot of visual and creative flair. He loves Bond and has said so in many interviews. He can really do character and is proven in the action field. He seems the natural heir to the throne to continue the lofty standards Mendes' introduced in SF.

    So, we can narrow it down even more hehe: Nolan, Hooper, Fincher & Wright :-). Sounds like a good bunch. What other directors might Barbara Broccoli and Michael Wilson consider right now.....realistically spoken off course? I heard @Skyfail mentioning Martin Scorcese?
  • RENEGADE_GANGRENEGADE_GANG Banned
    Posts: 11
    I personally am very glad Mendes is not returning, although I enjoyed the scenes involving Bond doing pullups and hanging on the elevator while stealthily surveying Patrice in the Shanghai skyscraper, quite frankly though the whole movie was a sloppy mess, starting with the introduction of Silva's island. The movie started off fairly seriously involving the leaked data of mi6 agents , and suddenly the movie turns a full 180 degrees and becomes a cat vs mouse show constantly pitting Silva and Bond against each other in cliched recycled situations almost all predictable . IMO EON did not let Mendes make too any decisions on his own, and what we got was the usual formula shoved down our throats once again resulting in a cheap thrill ride aimed for casual movie goers. Let's hope B24 is similar to CR and maintains a serious tone and drop this kiddy nonsense.
  • The 'Big List of Possible Bond 24 Directors' [update 12/03/2013]:

    --> Joe Wright ('Atonement', 1 Golden Globe nomination):
    Directed the Oscar-heavy character drama movies 'Atonement' and 'Pride And Prejudice', both starring Craig's wife Keira Knightley. Wright also directed the arthouse spy-film 'Hanna' and the recent Oscar-winning costume drama 'Anna Karenina'. Sounds like a good follow-up of Sam Mendes and his schedule isn't that busy.
    My prediction: Likely. Good follow-up in tone and style of Sam Mendes


    ...I think Rachel Weisz might have something to say about the above comment. The last time she looked she was married to Craig and not Keira Knightley.

    Joe Wright is my number 1 choice



  • Posts: 2,081
    from a BBC article about the South Bank Sky Arts Awards where Skyfall won the film award:

    Skyfall producer Barbara Broccoli said it was "an honour" to win the best film award, adding she planned to keep Daniel Craig on as 007 as long as possible.

    "I'm not letting Daniel Craig go anywhere - he's staying right here," she said backstage.

    The producer added she was "devastated" director Sam Mendes had decided to leave the franchise, although she she hoped "we will get him back" in the future.

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-21755232
  • Posts: 498
    @Gustav_Graves

    Why does Mi6forums.com redirect to commanderbond ?
  • Samuel001Samuel001 Moderator
    Posts: 13,356
    Tuulia wrote:
    from a BBC article about the South Bank Sky Arts Awards where Skyfall won the film award:

    Skyfall producer Barbara Broccoli said it was "an honour" to win the best film award, adding she planned to keep Daniel Craig on as 007 as long as possible.

    "I'm not letting Daniel Craig go anywhere - he's staying right here," she said backstage.

    The producer added she was "devastated" director Sam Mendes had decided to leave the franchise, although she she hoped "we will get him back" in the future.

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-21755232

    Good news that she feels like we do about Mendes. Devastated is a strong word. If the Bond 24 director says no to Bond 25 you can bet Mendes will get a call.
  • doubleoegodoubleoego #LightWork
    Posts: 11,139
    RC7 wrote:
    Tuulia wrote:
    Tom Hooper and David Fincher are more or less my favourites now. They can do a similar Sam Mendes-like direction. And they have a good chance considering the actors they bring in and considering the ties they have with Craig.

    What ties does Hooper have with Craig?

    Also, why are Hooper and Fincher favourites? Before SF I don't remember anyone considering Mendes as an option. 'Away We Go' had been his previous directorial effort, and if my memory serves me right it got middling reviews and didn't make it's minimal budget back at the BO. I don't think it's a given that some big hitter or current flavour of the month is necessarily top of the list. There are a tonne of directors out there who B+M will be mulling over IMO.

    Uhm....it is truly a pity that http://www.mi6forums.com doesn't exist anymore, but I actually mentioned Sam Mendes before on there :-S. Yes, 'Away We Go' wasn't a big success. It even got quite a bunch of negative reviews. But against that movie one can place his succesful ones, like 'American Beauty', 'Road To Perdition' and 'Revolutionary Road'. I can actually recall a topic in here where 'Skyfall' fits in these bunch of movies, tone-wise, style-wise.

    I had to be a bit clearer regarding Tom Hooper and David Fincher. I think with Tom Hooper you can bring in some other great actors that would like to work with him again, but now on a Bond film (Helena Bonham Carter, Colin Firth).

    David Fincher has worked with Daniel Craig, like Sam Mendes. Considering his influential suggestions towards EION, I don't see why David Fincher will be ignored completely because of his nationality. That's stupidity! Martin Campbell and Lee Tamahori are New Zealand born directors. Roger Spottiswoode is Canadian and Marc Forster is Swiss.

    Moreover, contribute to this topic by naming a few directors @RC7. I love this forum because we can actually speak about our ideas and visions for Bond 24. You are slamming mine down like Hulk Hogan and don't give any other alternative. I find that a bit lame. Sorry to say this.
    So, my list has narrowed down to:
    --> Christopher Nolan
    --> Tom Hooper
    --> Guy Ritchie
    --> David Fincher
    --> Steven Soderbergh, &
    --> Joe Wright

    I agree mostly with this list.

    1. Nolan: He would be great. The opening of TDKR is the best pre-title sequence not in a Bond film. He does seem like the perfect guy to continue this series. But he is the victim of his own success, he can do anything he wants and has grown heavily in prestige in the last few years that he has effectively ruled himself out. Plus Inception is not the masterpiece its made out to be and TDKR showed how Nolan's storytelling crown was clearly falling.
    2. Hooper: I want to hate the idea, but I don't. I actually quite like it. The idea of the director of The King's Speech and Les Mis seems repulsive but looking at his past work on television he's actually a filmmaker with great talent. He's also suitably suave and sophisticated in life, very much like Sam Mendes.
    3.Ritchie: God please no. I don't think the prods would be foolish enough to let Ritchie anywhere near the franchise.
    4: Fincher: I concur. He makes great films with great characters and great twisted macabre storylines. If he wasn't American he would be the number 1 guy in the frame right now. I hope the prods can get over themselves and finally hire a great American filmmaker. Why not start with Finch? After all he made the very European TGWTDT.
    5. Soderbergh: Never going to happen. Next.
    6. Wright: The best name on the list. He's young and has a lot of visual and creative flair. He loves Bond and has said so in many interviews. He can really do character and is proven in the action field. He seems the natural heir to the throne to continue the lofty standards Mendes' introduced in SF.

    So, we can narrow it down even more hehe: Nolan, Hooper, Fincher & Wright :-). Sounds like a good bunch. What other directors might Barbara Broccoli and Michael Wilson consider right now.....realistically spoken off course? I heard @Skyfail mentioning Martin Scorcese?

    facepalm1.gif
  • edited March 2013 Posts: 1,021
    Good to hear that SF picked up another award. I can certainly agree with BB and that comment.
  • RC7RC7
    Posts: 10,512
    Moreover, contribute to this topic by naming a few directors @RC7.

    I already did, but the thread keeps being steered back towards Nolan and co. so there's little point discussing it. If you're going to keep bringing up Nolan and entertaining Scorsese, there's little to be discussed because we might as well discuss the end of the world.

    For the record...

    Martin McDonagh (or his brother John)
    Eran Creevy
    Park-Chan Wook
    Gareth Evans
    Nicolas Winding Refn

    I'll let you get back to talking nonsense now.



  • RENEGADE_GANGRENEGADE_GANG Banned
    edited March 2013 Posts: 11
    How is it picking up so many awards? What was so great about skyfall?. Casino Royale was above and beyond skyfall in every aspect.

    Anyways I am a fan of Martin Scorcese and would enjoy seeing him direct a Bond.He would definitely bring a new originality and essence to the franchise. Especially realism.
  • edited March 2013 Posts: 11,119
    The 'Big List of Possible Bond 24 Directors' [update 12/03/2013]:

    --> Joe Wright ('Atonement', 1 Golden Globe nomination):
    Directed the Oscar-heavy character drama movies 'Atonement' and 'Pride And Prejudice', both starring Craig's wife Keira Knightley. Wright also directed the arthouse spy-film 'Hanna' and the recent Oscar-winning costume drama 'Anna Karenina'. Sounds like a good follow-up of Sam Mendes and his schedule isn't that busy.
    My prediction: Likely. Good follow-up in tone and style of Sam Mendes


    ...I think Rachel Weisz might have something to say about the above comment. The last time she looked she was married to Craig and not Keira Knightley.

    Joe Wright is my number 1 choice



    I always get confused between those two actresses :D . Hell, I always get confused between these four actresses: Rachel Weisz ('The Fountain', directed by Darren Aronofsky), Keira Knightley ('Atonement', directed by Joe Wright), Natalie Portman ('Black Swan', directed by Darren Aronofsky) and Anne Hathaway ('The Dark Knight Rises', directed by Christopher Nolan).

    But as Rachel Weisz has worked with Darren Aronofsky on 'The Fountain', perhaps this director can be persuaded to direct Bond 24 O:-). He's almost finished with 'Noah' and has nothing else scheduled. I loved his movies 'Requiem For A Dream' and 'Black Swan'.
    RC7 wrote:
    Moreover, contribute to this topic by naming a few directors @RC7.

    I already did, but the thread keeps being steered back towards Nolan and co. so there's little point discussing it. If you're going to keep bringing up Nolan and entertaining Scorsese, there's little to be discussed because we might as well discuss the end of the world.

    For the record...

    Martin McDonagh (or his brother John)
    Eran Creevy
    Park-Chan Wook
    Gareth Evans
    Nicolas Winding Refn

    I'll let you get back to talking nonsense now.

    Sorry if I have overlooked your suggestions @RC7. Wasn't my intention. I think I have not only mentioned one director but I also came with several other possibilities.

    --> Martin McDonagh: He actually won an Oscar for a short movie that basically kicked off his career with larger movies. I thought 'In Bruges' was fantastic' and 'Seven Psychopaths' is very good. Loved Christopher Walken in there. Would he like to return as a Bond villain ;-)? This choice is on my list too now.
    --> Eran Creevy: Sorry. Not my choice. Not a big resumé and only just starting his director career.
    --> Park-Chan Wook: You really think Babs and Michael would go for a South-Korean director. 'Stoker' is quite a good movie, but it was a boxoffice failure. And Wook is more famous for his shorts.
    --> Gareth Evans: Busy filming now, and his resumé doesn't look very Bond-proof.
    --> Nicolas Winding Refn: Hmmm, interesting choice, allthough 'Valhalla Rising' was quite crap, I loved 'Drive'. His true director debut that made him well-known. Couple more of those and perhaps he can join Bond 24 then?

    My choice from your list would be Martin McDonagh then. Only one that could seriously be considered if you ask me. Very interesting indeed :-).
  • edited March 2013 Posts: 15,229
    doubleoego wrote:
    RC7 wrote:
    Well my vote goes to the master, Mr. Stanley Kubrick. Given some of the suggestions on here, I'd wager that reanimating his corpse is no stumbling block for some users.


    :-D

    If we can bring his spirit back, then Kubrick could be in the list. So no need to go as far as reanimating his corpse. Let's remain realistic.
  • Posts: 2,081
    Gustav... Umm... I'm not so sure if Aronofsky would be a good idea... Maybe there isn't and maybe there wouldn't be any personal issues, but to me it sounds like asking for trouble.
  • RC7RC7
    Posts: 10,512
    Ludovico wrote:
    doubleoego wrote:
    RC7 wrote:
    Well my vote goes to the master, Mr. Stanley Kubrick. Given some of the suggestions on here, I'd wager that reanimating his corpse is no stumbling block for some users.


    :-D

    If we can bring his spirit back, then Kubrick could be in the list. So no need to go as far as reanimating his corpse. Let's remain realistic.

    True, we could channel his energy through a mannequin.
  • The 'Big List of Possible Bond 24 Directors' [update 12/03/2013]:

    --> Joe Wright ('Atonement', 1 Golden Globe nomination):
    Directed the Oscar-heavy character drama movies 'Atonement' and 'Pride And Prejudice', both starring Craig's wife Keira Knightley. Wright also directed the arthouse spy-film 'Hanna' and the recent Oscar-winning costume drama 'Anna Karenina'. Sounds like a good follow-up of Sam Mendes and his schedule isn't that busy.
    My prediction: Likely. Good follow-up in tone and style of Sam Mendes


    ...I think Rachel Weisz might have something to say about the above comment. The last time she looked she was married to Craig and not Keira Knightley.

    Joe Wright is my number 1 choice



    I always get confused between those two actresses :D . Hell, I always get confused between these four actresses: Rachel Weisz ('The Fountain', directed by Darren Aronofsky), Keira Knightley ('Atonement', directed by Joe Wright), Natalie Portman ('Black Swan', directed by Darren Aronofsky) and Anne Hathaway ('The Dark Knight Rises', directed by Christopher Nolan).

    But as Rachel Weisz has worked with Darren Aronofsky on 'The Fountain', perhaps this director can be persuaded to direct Bond 24 O:-). He's almost finished with 'Noah' and has nothing else scheduled. I loved his movies 'Requiem For A Dream' and 'Black Swan'.

    Aronofsky is one of my favorites. I'd be thrilled but it would be risky.
  • edited March 2013 Posts: 2,081
    ^^ Not sure that risk is worth taking - though I must say I'd be interested in knowing both his and Daniel's honest opinion about it... which on the other hand might be different now than a few months into the movie. Who knows. The tabloids would have fun with them working together, I'm sure.
  • edited March 2013 Posts: 11,119
    New update then, WITH a director from @RC7's list:
    --> Martin McDonagh,
    --> Darren Aronofsky,
    --> Chris Nolan,
    --> Tom Hooper,
    --> David Fincher &
    --> Joe Wright

    Interestingly......all of them are Oscar/Globe nominees, and McDonagh, Nolan & Hooper actually won an Oscar :-).
  • Craig has once said he would like to work with some director on a future Bond, and he has not yet made the lists here :)
    Forster, Craig said he would like to make another one with him (during some QoS press junket). So you should take him into account if you think this is sincere. And if you think it is not sincere but just the usual "everyone is great" stuff, then you should forget many, many quotes from many, many persons :)
  • RC7RC7
    Posts: 10,512
    New update then, WITH a director from @RC7's list:
    --> Martin McDonagh,
    --> Darren Aronofsky,
    --> Chris Nolan,
    --> Tom Hooper,
    --> David Fincher &
    --> Joe Wright

    What's this list?
  • Posts: 11,119
    Craig has once said he would like to work with some director on a future Bond, and he has not yet made the lists here :)
    Forster, Craig said he would like to make another one with him (during some QoS press junket). So you should take him into account if you think this is sincere. And if you think it is not sincere but just the usual "everyone is great" stuff, then you should forget many, many quotes from many, many persons :)

    I do agree man. I think Marc Forster should be considered here as well. Pity the stars weren't in the right position when he directed QOS, but his ideas were quite good. I agree with Craig that QOS' flaws were mainly attributed to rushed screenplay writing, but also some rather unoriginal Bourne-like editing.

    I think he deserves a second chance. Very curious if 'World War Z' will be a good blockbuster....
  • doubleoegodoubleoego #LightWork
    Posts: 11,139
    Marc Forster isn't coming back. That I'm certain of.
  • Considering the problems that WORD WAR Z has had I dont think BB and MGW would go with Marc Forster after SAM MENDES. Fast cutting aside I thought FORSTER brought a lot of interesting touches to QOS and its a film that I think gets unfairly slated. But I would rule him out this time around.
  • Posts: 11,119
    Tuulia wrote:
    Mark Strong presented the South Bank Sky Arts Award to Barbara and Michael
    http://metro.co.uk/2013/03/12/skyfall-wins-best-film-at-2013-south-bank-sky-arts-awards-3538565/

    And from those awards:

    Skyfall producer Barbara Broccoli said it was "an honour" to win the best film award, adding she planned to keep Daniel Craig on as 007 as long as possible.

    "I'm not letting Daniel Craig go anywhere - he's staying right here," she said backstage.

    The producer added she was "devastated" director Sam Mendes had decided to leave the franchise, although she she hoped "we will get him back" in the future.

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-21755232


    Thanks @Tuulia. I can understand that Barbara Broccoli was devastated in Sam Mendes' final choice not to return. Though, I think he must come back for a 25th or 26th Bond film.
  • 0BradyM0Bondfanatic70BradyM0Bondfanatic7 Quantum Floral Arrangements: "We Have Petals Everywhere"
    edited March 2013 Posts: 28,694
    doubleoego wrote:
    Marc Forster isn't coming back. That I'm certain of.

    My thoughts as well. No matter who is to blame, I don't think EON want to risk it again. Forster sometimes let his art-house directing get in the way, and at times I feel like he needed to be pinched and told he was directing a Bond film, and not one of his passion projects. These films are bigger than ever now, and require directors to treat them as such, even if it means changing their styles.

    And @Gustav_Graves, I can think of no better person to send off Dan as Bond than Mendes, when that sad time comes. I am sure that we will see Mendes and EON team up again, as both sides are more than willing if schedules and stars align.
  • Posts: 11,119
    doubleoego wrote:
    Marc Forster isn't coming back. That I'm certain of.

    My thoughts as well. No matter who is to blame, I don't think EON want to risk it again. Forster sometimes let his art-house directing get in the way, and at times I feel like he needed to be pinched and told he was directing a Bond film, and not one of his passion projects. These films are bigger than ever now, and require directors to treat them as such, even if it means changing their styles.

    And @Gustav_Graves, I can think of no better person to send off Dan as Bond than Mendes, when that sad time comes.

    So, which list can we make of possible directors that we can or should not rule out right now then?
  • 0BradyM0Bondfanatic70BradyM0Bondfanatic7 Quantum Floral Arrangements: "We Have Petals Everywhere"
    Posts: 28,694
    doubleoego wrote:
    Marc Forster isn't coming back. That I'm certain of.

    My thoughts as well. No matter who is to blame, I don't think EON want to risk it again. Forster sometimes let his art-house directing get in the way, and at times I feel like he needed to be pinched and told he was directing a Bond film, and not one of his passion projects. These films are bigger than ever now, and require directors to treat them as such, even if it means changing their styles.

    And @Gustav_Graves, I can think of no better person to send off Dan as Bond than Mendes, when that sad time comes.

    So, which list can we make of possible directors that we can or should not rule out right now then?

    For Bond 24 or the future in general? Right now I am not even going to trying to determine who will be next up to direct, as there are too many factors to consider. I will just wait for EON to confirm, as I am not a betting man in any sense of the word.
  • Posts: 11,119
    doubleoego wrote:
    Marc Forster isn't coming back. That I'm certain of.

    My thoughts as well. No matter who is to blame, I don't think EON want to risk it again. Forster sometimes let his art-house directing get in the way, and at times I feel like he needed to be pinched and told he was directing a Bond film, and not one of his passion projects. These films are bigger than ever now, and require directors to treat them as such, even if it means changing their styles.

    And @Gustav_Graves, I can think of no better person to send off Dan as Bond than Mendes, when that sad time comes.

    So, which list can we make of possible directors that we can or should not rule out right now then?

    For Bond 24 or the future in general? Right now I am not even going to trying to determine who will be next up to direct, as there are too many factors to consider. I will just wait for EON to confirm, as I am not a betting man in any sense of the word.

    Betting makes life fun. Look at Bond :-). But....it can make or break your reputation too. Look at me, mostly breaking mine hahahaha :-P.
Sign In or Register to comment.