›

Is Skyfall REALLY Craig's best Bond?

245

Comments

  • TheWizardOfIceTheWizardOfIce 'One of the Internet's more toxic individuals'
    edited April 2013 Posts: 9,117
    samainsy wrote:
    HA HA HA YOUR FUNNY TELL ME ANOTHER JOKE!!

    You're
  • samainsysamainsy Suspended
    Posts: 199
    TheWizardOfIce wrote:
    samainsy wrote:
    HA HA HA YOUR FUNNY TELL ME ANOTHER JOKE!!

    You're

    Are you American?
  • BennyBenny Shaken not stirredAdministrator, Moderator
    Posts: 15,138
    Ha ha, you're funny. Tell me another joke.

    I'd place Skyfall and Casino Royale level, with Quantum easily last.
  • 00130013
    Posts: 1,817
    In my opinion CR is Craig's best Bond movie but SF is Craig's best performance. I'm a big fan of both and there are my 2nd and 4th favorites. But perhaps CR is slighly better because cames frome a Fleming novel (and a very good one).
  • Quantum89Quantum89
    Posts: 28
    I think his best performance was in QoS. He just became Bond.
  • thelivingroyalethelivingroyale
    edited April 2013 Posts: 12,837
    0013 wrote:
    In my opinion CR is Craig's best Bond movie but SF is Craig's best performance.

    My opinion is the complete opposite. I think SF is his best movie but CR was his best performance.

    Actually apart from Lazenby and Dalton (who I think was equally good in both) I'm not sure any of my favourite movies from each actor have their best performance.

    My favourite Connery is YOLT but I think his best performance was probably Goldfinger or Thunderball, my favourite Moore film is Spy but I think his best performance was Octopussy and my favourite Brosnan is Goldeneye but I think his best performance was DAD.
  • SoundofthesinnersSoundofthesinners
    Posts: 3,236
    Somebody around here compared the Casino Royale/Skyfall dichotomy to the From Russia With Love/Goldfinger split.

    I split the difference, putting Goldfinger above From Russia With Love (admittedly, they're #s 1 and 2), but Casino Royale over Skyfall (#s 3 and 6, respectively). All are fine films of course, but Casino Royale's Fleming, less-prone-to-collapse plot, and presence of a Bond girl put it over Skyfall.
  • SirHenryLeeChaChingSirHenryLeeChaChing
    Posts: 3,494
    As much as I enjoyed Skyfall, I walked out thinking CR was better and I still do. So for me it's CR, SF, and then QOS.
  • samainsysamainsy Suspended
    Posts: 199
    Benny wrote:
    Ha ha, you're funny. Tell me another joke.

    I'd place Skyfall and Casino Royale level, with Quantum easily last.

    Yes but maybe Skyfall just 0.001 better I find the poker bit boring though.
  • danielcraig007danielcraig007
    edited April 2013 Posts: 28
    oooooooh its so close between Casino royale and Skyfall for my favourite James Bond film ever. But i give the nod to Skyfall just cause of the last third is just epic with Bond kicking ass. But both films are epic. I think Craig's best Bond performance is in QOS. But lets be honest his performances in all three films have been great.
  • samainsysamainsy Suspended
    Posts: 199
    danielcraig007 wrote:
    oooooooh its so close between Casino royale and Skyfall for my favourite James Bond film ever. But i give the nod to Skyfall just cause of the last third is just epic with Bond kicking ass. But both films are epic. I think Craig's best Bond performance is in QOS. But lets be honest his performances in all three films have been great.
    I agree but not wiv Qos

  • samainsysamainsy Suspended
    Posts: 199
    Just wait till I'm Bond. Every time I walk past a mirror I pretend to do a gunbarrell,If I were Bond I'd do 2 guns.
  • danielcraig007danielcraig007
    Posts: 28
    samainsy wrote:
    danielcraig007 wrote:
    oooooooh its so close between Casino royale and Skyfall for my favourite James Bond film ever. But i give the nod to Skyfall just cause of the last third is just epic with Bond kicking ass. But both films are epic. I think Craig's best Bond performance is in QOS. But lets be honest his performances in all three films have been great.
    I agree but not wiv Qos

    I love QOS (flaws and all) but do think its his performance that holds it together.

  • Quantum89Quantum89
    Posts: 28
    I agree
  • StartStoppingStartStopping
    Posts: 140
    I think Skyfall is better than Casino Royale just because it is more of a Bond film. Casino Royale is a fantastic film but I feel that it doesnt have enough of those classic Bond moments that Skyfall brought back so perfectly. Skyfall wins for this guy.
  • 00130013
    Posts: 1,817
    thelivingroyale wrote:
    0013 wrote:
    In my opinion CR is Craig's best Bond movie but SF is Craig's best performance.

    My opinion is the complete opposite. I think SF is his best movie but CR was his best performance.

    Actually apart from Lazenby and Dalton (who I think was equally good in both) I'm not sure any of my favourite movies from each actor have their best performance.

    My favourite Connery is YOLT but I think his best performance was probably Goldfinger or Thunderball, my favourite Moore film is Spy but I think his best performance was Octopussy and my favourite Brosnan is Goldeneye but I think his best performance was DAD.

    That's interesting. I still have great regard for Craig's performance in CR (and QOS if that matters).
    But we do have some coincidences for both Moore, Dalton and Brosnan.

    Summary:
    - Connery
    M: FRWL
    P: FRWL
    - Moore
    M: TSWLM
    P: TSWLM & OP
    Dalton:
    M: TLD
    P: TLD & LTK
    Brosnan
    M: GE
    P: GE & DAD
    Craig
    M: CR
    P: SF

    where M stands for favorite movie and P for best performance.
  • Judi2013fan_MeetBondJudi2013fan_MeetBond Banned
    Posts: 57
    W_PPK u must be joking???? Skyfall is my all time favourite Bond film and I stand by that. BTW I like your avatar can we see more in the pics threaD? I am blind so it is hrd to see that that small??
  • Baltimore_007Baltimore_007
    Posts: 5,634
    If someone thought Skyfall was a poor release and warranted a bottom five place, that's good enough. It's their decision. Not everyone has it as a favorite release. That can be appreciated, although I have it on the verge of a top five position, but it's hardly the best Bond release the franchise has ever seen

    You'll forgive me if I leave. Goodnight
  • Judi2013fan_MeetBondJudi2013fan_MeetBond Banned
    Posts: 57
    Excuse me but Skyfall is highest grossing Bond film of all time I THINK that says enough???
  • echoecho 007 in New York
    Posts: 6,306
    CR is better in my book. It's a more personal story for Bond and therefore more satisfying than SF.
  • 0BradyM0Bondfanatic70BradyM0Bondfanatic7 Quantum Floral Arrangements: "We Have Petals Everywhere"
    edited April 2013 Posts: 28,694
    Judi2013fan_MeetBond wrote:
    Excuse me but Skyfall is highest grossing Bond film of all time I THINK that says enough???

    Money is no indicator of quality. If that was the case the Michael Bay Transformer films would be held akin to classic films. 8-|
  • w2bondw2bond is indeed a very rare breed
    Posts: 2,252
    0BradyM0Bondfanatic7 wrote:
    Judi2013fan_MeetBond wrote:
    Excuse me but Skyfall is highest grossing Bond film of all time I THINK that says enough???

    Money is no indicator of quality. If that was the case the Michael Bay Transformer films would be held akin to classic films. 8-|

    And all the Twilight movies are masterpieces compared with all but Skyfall :-))
  • Judi2013fan_MeetBondJudi2013fan_MeetBond Banned
    Posts: 57
    Skyfall's great in my book. The best one yet!
  • danielcraig007danielcraig007
    Posts: 28
    0BradyM0Bondfanatic7 wrote:
    Judi2013fan_MeetBond wrote:
    Excuse me but Skyfall is highest grossing Bond film of all time I THINK that says enough???

    Money is no indicator of quality. If that was the case the Michael Bay Transformer films would be held akin to classic films. 8-|

    But the film has got massive critical acclaim and awards. I mean Skyfall not transformers :D

  • Judi2013fan_MeetBondJudi2013fan_MeetBond Banned
    Posts: 57
    It seems popular opinion is on my side on thise one Brady.
  • royale65royale65 Caustic misanthrope reporting for duty.
    Posts: 4,423
    Judi2013fan_MeetBond wrote:
    It seems popular opinion is on my side on thise one Brady.

    I think @0BradyM0Bondfanatic7 was commenting that box office clout has no indication on the quality of the movie. ;-). Hence Transformers
  • HappiestinthesaddleHappiestinthesaddle Banned
    edited April 2013 Posts: 101
    "Box office is no guarantee of quality"
    "And youth is no guarantee of innovation" =))

    Skyfall is superior.
    Casino Royale looks like it was filmed in a Czech tax haven to save pennies.
    And guess what?
    It was.
    A shameful blight on the series that gave is sumptuous vistas.
    Piz Gloria, Blofeld's volcano, Palmyra.
    All beautiful.
    What does Royale give us?
    A poor man's vision of an airport, filmed in Czech republic.
    It's meant to be Miami.
    But you can see the people are all downtrodden eastern Europeans.

    EON finally got it right with Skyfall =D>

    Mod Edit - Removed potentially offensive material.
    You are on thin ice my friend.
  • RC7RC7
    Posts: 10,512
    Happiestinthesaddle wrote:
    "Box office is no guarantee of quality"
    "And youth is no guarantee of innovation" =))

    Skyfall is superior.
    Casino Royale looks like it was filmed in a Czech tax haven to save pennies.
    And guess what?
    It was.
    A shameful blight on the series that gave is sumptuous vistas.
    Piz Gloria, Blofeld's volcano, Palmyra.
    All beautiful.
    What does Royale give us?
    A poor man's vision of an airport, filmed in Czech republic.
    It's meant to be Miami.
    But you can see the people are all downtrodden eastern Europeans.

    EON finally got it right with Skyfall =D>

    Mod Edit - Removed potentially offensive material.
    You are on thin ice my friend.

    Funny that of the two, CR actually uses locations, SF is primarily shot at Pinewood. The most exotic location being Turkey.
  • HappiestinthesaddleHappiestinthesaddle Banned
    Posts: 101
    And which one looks and feels shoddier?
    That's right.
    Casino Royale.
  • BennyBenny Shaken not stirredAdministrator, Moderator
    Posts: 15,138
    do-not-feed-the-troll.jpg
Sign In or Register to comment.