It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
^ Back to Top
The MI6 Community is unofficial and in no way associated or linked with EON Productions, MGM, Sony Pictures, Activision or Ian Fleming Publications. Any views expressed on this website are of the individual members and do not necessarily reflect those of the Community owners. Any video or images displayed in topics on MI6 Community are embedded by users from third party sites and as such MI6 Community and its owners take no responsibility for this material.
James Bond News • James Bond Articles • James Bond Magazine
Comments
I'm looking forward to finding out who they choose for the next continuation author. Horowitz produced mixed results for me. Boyd was much more my speed. Hopefully that'll be an announcement that comes this year.
It's still Fleming’s best IMO. Brisk, no-nonsense, finger on the pulse, exciting, and not a word wasted on self-indulgent prose from the writer.
One of my favorite novels, I prefer it than the movie, the movie is still good though.
I think Kim Sherwood is the main writer for now. I’d like to see some more modern day setting for the future of the books. I think that certain villains could use a modern day literary adaptation.
New logo from IFP. Happy anniversary Bond fans!
Sorry to see @Birdleson step down from hosting the thread but it'll be in safe hands with you, @MajorDSmythe. I'm currently rereading Colonel Sun so I should have one to put down at least. :)
I appreciate the compliment, but it comes down to how members take part. If the thread runs out of steam, we'll let it go.
Yes, like all threads it depends on member participation to keep it going but hopefully in this 70th anniversary year for the literary Bond more people will contribute than has been the norm of late.
This has been my first time reading any of the Young Bond books. In my head, I wrongfully wrote them off as probably being too childish. But there were parts of SilverFin that wouldn't be out of place in a normal Bond book; all the bleakness with the Caste, the experimented on pigs and Algar. And Lord Hellbore was such an obnoxious brute, he wouldn't be out of place lined up with some of the villains that Bond will be pitted against in adulthood.
Next up: Blood Fever
Glad you enjoyed OHMSS. The film is very faithful to the novel. The next one, YOLT, certainly won't be like reading the movie and it's all the better for it!
I liked this one too. I should have read these Young Bond books before now.
Next Up: Double Or Die
I don't want to say I told you so but... 😉
Also Double or Die might be my favourite, or at least it was on my last reread, so enjoy!
Yes though I enjoyed more then with a mind to kill
I may be biased but John Gardner is hard to beat. That said, he and Horowitz have a lot in common in terms of writing background. With Horowitz, IFP returned to the tried and tested maxim of "you need a thriller writer to write a thriller" which had stood them in good stead with Gardner previously. My preference is still for the 1968-2002 original line of Bond continuation novels though as those were the ones I grew up with.
I love the benson novels Gardner is hit or miss with me loved amis as well… to be honest apart don’t Deaver I haven’t liked any of the post Benson writers for Bond
Which Gardner Bond novels are your favourites? Like me you probably prefer the contemporary settings in your Bond novels over the period setting approach of most of the post-Benson Bond novels.
Indeed you did.
There may be some dated parts, but overall, it's a great and fun read.
I've only read those Japanese scenes, not the first half which I do find a bit slow.
The Japanese scenes, especially starting from when Bond met Tiger Tanaka is really fun and fast paced, all of what happened after that were really page turner, and quick read.
I laughed many times at the banter between Bond and Tiger, and again, I don't see any of the Film Bonds in here, though kinda weirdly based on some of the dialogues from Bond, I kinda see Sterling Archer :)) lol! But seriously when there's a bit of jokes or sarcasm coming from Bond, it's Sterling Archer whom I really see.
This dialogue from example:
Another example:
Then.....
And.....
Did Bond acted like a bit childish in here 😅
Bond in this book was kinda naive really, he often act as a bit naughty and fool all around.
He's sarcastic, being bumbly based again on his dialogues and the way he talked to Tiger.
It's really funny, I really laughed at the dialogues between Bond and Tiger.
To be honest, I don't see Dalton (or Craig) in the majority of these books, he comes off to me as more like Sterling Archer to me......😅
Though sometimes, I picture Lazenby.
Yes, I do find Bond's actions and dialogues in the books kinda laughable.
To those who were saying that he's dour and serious in the books, that's not true, i'm telling you now guys! He's a bit naive and kinda bit of immature, with a touch of naughtiness in his attitude, he's a bit bully, sarcastic if he didn't liked what's happening on him or around him.
I also liked how Blofeld treated women quite properly compared to how Bond treated them, but again, Blofeld was the villain :))
Blofeld treated Irma Bunt like his equal really, like telling her "What do you think it, my dear?", I'd say it, Blofeld was more of a good partner than Bond in terms of treatment of women :))
Like, OMG! Fleming why?! Blofeld was a psycho, but he treated women better than Bond did!
Some brief thoughts on each of the stories:
1. From a View to a Kill
“What does a James Bond short story even look like?” is a question I had on my mind before reading this, and FAVTAK is a solid opener to answer this question: for the most part, it looks exactly as one would hope, a mini-Bond adventure that is like one of novels in Bonsai form, expertly trimmed to keep the satisfying structure in short form. I had hoped for a little more depth to the plot here, as having Bond try to sus out a mole in the military base could have added some nice espionage thrills but what we get is short and sweet. Probably my second least favorite of the collection, which is high praise since I enjoyed this.
2. For Your Eyes Only
Now we get to the main course (well, actually this collection offers two of them). Absolutely loved this one. Like the previous story it’s a fully condensed Bond adventure centered around a sniping mission to get revenge on behalf of M. Amazing opening scene hooks you right away, there’s some interesting wrinkles with the morality of the mission, and then the bulk of the story is the delightfully atmospheric trek through Canada and Northern America that builds suspense along the way. The resolution comes a little easy, but for the most part this is Fleming in top form.
3. Quantum of Solace
This is the clear odd man out as Bond or even any Bond like hallmarks hardly figure into this tale of domestic strife. It’s my least favorite of the collection on its own terms and as a Bond story, but I think it’s well placed in the middle of the book as a sort of intermission that also sets-up some themes the later stories tackle in more interesting ways.
4. Risico
Like For Your Eyes Only this is practically another fully formed Bond adventure in miniature, maybe even more so since this covers a lot more ground. Love the focus on honest to goodness espionage here, and the villain/ally dynamics recalled From Russia With Love in the best of ways, and the action is well written and exciting. Top marks, this one fully satisfied my craving for more Bond antics.
5. The Hildebrand Rarity
This one is another oddity in a way, because like Quantum of Solace this is almost entirely a tale of domestic strife and there is no spy work at all. That being said, it still satisfies as a Bond story since he’s front and center in the action, and it still contains a memorable villain, death, and exotic locations. I found it much more successful at its aims than QoS, but it was also strengthened by having that earlier story in mind as a read it. This one also gives Fleming a great opportunity to write about undersea life again, which is always a delight because his passion and knowledge burst through with captivating and vivid descriptions. While not as good as the titular story or Risico this was a very good tale as well and again I found perfectly sequenced in the collection as it offers itself as a strange, macabre, denouement instead of a more typical resolution.
On the whole this collection is stronger than the sum of its parts (and many of those parts are very good!) due to the sequencing of the stories and their cumulative stacking of themes, making it feel nearly as cohesive as the novels that surround it in the series. Had all the stories been as good as FYEO or Risico this would be among the best of the novels, but even if it doesn’t quite reach those heights it marks a very good entry into the series and is a jolt of fresh air particularly where it’s placed in the 14 books.
Well I haven’t read all of them but of the ones I have read
I loved Seafire and enjoyed death is forever
Icebreaker is ok
Liscence to kill is also ok
Liscence renewed I didn’t like I didn’t hate it either
Again I put Gardner third but secretly I put benson first because that is who I grew up with I know I am supposed to put Fleming first because he created bond but for me benson is who I grew up with
I'm reading FYEO next, after reading all the full-length novels again (started in March 2020). I also last read TMWTGG and found it wanting. I haven't read the rest of your post but I'll look forward to reading it all after I've re-read the fyeo book.
Looks like we're on the same page (so to speak).
Still, I haven't really got back to reading a book continuously. But regarding Bond, I've been browsing through the Fleming novels I've had on and off, in order to find locations for the Geoguesser game and the Trivia game. One of these days, I'm going to re-read them all in their entirety.
I do find the novel really fun, I don't get what many people saying that this is a dark novel, sure because of the Blofeld climax thing, but in tone, it's actually fun, especially those scenes with Bond and Tiger Tanaka practicing Japanese culture, I really laughed at their dialogues.
What I do find weird was I keep seeing Sterling Archer everytime I read Bond's dialogues in those scenes.
I’m getting that same thing with Bond in general, lol. With Blofeld in YOLT, I can see both Dr. Evil facial expressions and his voice talking with his speeches. Probably because of Donald Pleasence. I still think IFP should give Blofeld a chance to headline his own novel. At least once. With Irma Bunt at his side.