Timothy Dalton or Daniel Craig?

1235748

Comments

  • SandySandy Somewhere in Europe
    Posts: 4,012
    This is a tough choice. The scene in TLD when Bond shoots Kara, until the moment he says "I must have scared the living daylights out of her" (if my memory serves me well) is one of my alltime favourite film-Bond moments. However, if something bothers me in Dalton is how stiff and unconfortable he looks most of the times. What Craig lacks in looks compared to Dalton (height, hair colour) he makes up in coolness and effortless charm. So for me, Craig.
  • DaltonCraig007DaltonCraig007 They say, "Evil prevails when good men fail to act." What they ought to say is, "Evil prevails."
    Posts: 15,718
    Yes @Sandy. I don't know what's the problem with Dalton, but he looks out of place in the Bond films. Craig has much more natural charm, magnetic presence and charisma (even though IMO he can still improve). I watched TLD last night, and it seems Craig may move up to 5th place in my rankings, with Dalton going last. Sorry for the Dalton fans, but Tim is just too stiff. He has some very good scenes, but also some very akward scenes, which seem to cancel each other out and make his take on Bond 'passable'.
  • Posts: 1,778
    Please.... the dialogue in the train scene is horrendous.

    'Rolex ?' 'Omeeeega.'

    If you want horrendous dialogue watch the J.W. Pepper scenes from LALD and TMWTGG. They both really seem like something out of Looney Tunes, not James Bond.
  • Posts: 154
    Please.... the dialogue in the train scene is horrendous.

    'Rolex ?' 'Omeeeega.'

    If you want horrendous dialogue watch the J.W. Pepper scenes from LALD and TMWTGG. They both really seem like something out of Looney Tunes, not James Bond.
    very good DoubleOhhSeven

  • edited April 2012 Posts: 11,189
    Please.... the dialogue in the train scene is horrendous.

    'Rolex ?' 'Omeeeega.'

    If you want horrendous dialogue watch the J.W. Pepper scenes from LALD and TMWTGG. They both really seem like something out of Looney Tunes, not James Bond.

    It's really pointless trying to criticise JW in front of DC @DoubleOhhSeven. He considers JW the best character in the franchise other than Bond.
  • edited April 2012 Posts: 154
    Why? He criticise CR in our faces. I agree its a little bit bad. But he also did it to us... anyway...your right BAIN. DoubleOhhSeven should have not done it
  • edited April 2012 Posts: 1,778
    BAIN123 wrote:
    Please.... the dialogue in the train scene is horrendous.

    'Rolex ?' 'Omeeeega.'

    If you want horrendous dialogue watch the J.W. Pepper scenes from LALD and TMWTGG. They both really seem like something out of Looney Tunes, not James Bond.

    It's really pointless trying to criticise JW in front of DC @DoubleOhhSeven. He considers JW the best character in the franchise other than Bond.

    Your right @Bain. Im wasting energy.

    Moreover Im happy Craig has overtaken Dalton in the polls. I rewatched TLD last night and tried for the life of me to figure out why I always preferred Craig as the "serious Bond". I think I've finally figured it out. Dalton simply isn't that cool. Connery, Moore, and Craig seem to effortlessly glide through their performances as if it's their world and everyone else is just living in it.

    Yes Dalton could be very intense but often intense in the wrong places, whereas Craig was able to seperate the two. Craig could be cool and classy (train scene, casino scenes) and at the same time switch over and become a killer. The only other actor who could do this was Connery. That's why Connery and Craig are IMO the 2 best Bonds.

    And when I say "cool" I don't mean cool in the public's eye. I mean cool as in James Bond's Devil May Care attitude.
  • edited April 2012 Posts: 11,189
    BAIN123 wrote:
    Please.... the dialogue in the train scene is horrendous.

    'Rolex ?' 'Omeeeega.'

    If you want horrendous dialogue watch the J.W. Pepper scenes from LALD and TMWTGG. They both really seem like something out of Looney Tunes, not James Bond.

    It's really pointless trying to criticise JW in front of DC @DoubleOhhSeven. He considers JW the best character in the franchise other than Bond.

    Your right @Bain. Im wasting energy.

    Moreover Im happy Craig has overtaken Dalton in the polls. I rewatched TLD last night and tried for the life of me to figure out why I always preferred Craig as the "serious Bond". And when I say "cool" I don't mean cool in the public's eye. I mean cool as in James Bond's Devil May Care attitude.

    I've said this before but I think he just comes off as a bit "stagey". That's the reaction I had when I re-watched a bit of TLD the other week. Also, its how they conduct themselves on camera. Connery, Moore, Craig and yes even Brosnan (in fact especially Brosnan) glide through the scenes - almost cat like.

    I'm going to defend Brosnan here, look how he walks between 04.08 and 04.19. Cool and confident. That's a scene where I can point and say "he's James Bond".



    I'm not sure whether Dalton could have pulled that off but who knows
  • edited April 2012 Posts: 1,778
    BAIN123 wrote:
    BAIN123 wrote:
    Please.... the dialogue in the train scene is horrendous.

    'Rolex ?' 'Omeeeega.'

    If you want horrendous dialogue watch the J.W. Pepper scenes from LALD and TMWTGG. They both really seem like something out of Looney Tunes, not James Bond.

    It's really pointless trying to criticise JW in front of DC @DoubleOhhSeven. He considers JW the best character in the franchise other than Bond.

    Your right @Bain. Im wasting energy.

    Moreover Im happy Craig has overtaken Dalton in the polls. I rewatched TLD last night and tried for the life of me to figure out why I always preferred Craig as the "serious Bond". And when I say "cool" I don't mean cool in the public's eye. I mean cool as in James Bond's Devil May Care attitude.

    I've said this before but I think he just comes off as a bit "stagey". That's the reaction I had when I re-watched a bit of TLD the other week. Also, its how they conduct themselves on camera. Connery, Moore, Craig and yes even Brosnan (in fact especially Brosnan) glide through the scenes - almost cat like.

    I'm going to defend Brosnan here, look how he walks between 04.08 and 04.19. Cool and confident.



    I'm not sure whether Dalton could have pulled that off but who knows

    Respectfully I didn't mention Brosnan because IMO Brosnan like Dalton at times simply tried too hard. If I met Connery, Moore, or Criag I'd think they were the coolest guys on the planet. If I met Brosnan I'd think this clown's putting on an act. There's a whole list of things he does in his films that always annoy me and stike me as playing up to the public's shallow interpretation of what James Bond should be. Maybe that's why casual fans like him so much but hardcore fans for the most part don't care for him.
  • edited April 2012 Posts: 11,189
    BAIN123 wrote:
    BAIN123 wrote:
    Please.... the dialogue in the train scene is horrendous.

    'Rolex ?' 'Omeeeega.'

    If you want horrendous dialogue watch the J.W. Pepper scenes from LALD and TMWTGG. They both really seem like something out of Looney Tunes, not James Bond.

    It's really pointless trying to criticise JW in front of DC @DoubleOhhSeven. He considers JW the best character in the franchise other than Bond.

    Your right @Bain. Im wasting energy.

    Moreover Im happy Craig has overtaken Dalton in the polls. I rewatched TLD last night and tried for the life of me to figure out why I always preferred Craig as the "serious Bond". And when I say "cool" I don't mean cool in the public's eye. I mean cool as in James Bond's Devil May Care attitude.

    I've said this before but I think he just comes off as a bit "stagey". That's the reaction I had when I re-watched a bit of TLD the other week. Also, its how they conduct themselves on camera. Connery, Moore, Craig and yes even Brosnan (in fact especially Brosnan) glide through the scenes - almost cat like.

    I'm going to defend Brosnan here, look how he walks between 04.08 and 04.19. Cool and confident.



    I'm not sure whether Dalton could have pulled that off but who knows

    Respectfully I didn't mention Brosnan because IMO Brosnan like Dalton at times simply tried too hard. If I met Connery, Moore, or Criag I'd think they were the coolest guys on the planet. If I met Brosnan I'd think this clown's putting on an act. There's a whole list of things he does in his films that always annoy me and stike me as playing up to the public's shallow interpretation of James Bond should be.

    If I met Brosnan I'd go weak at the knees like I did when I was about to shake hands with Roger Moore but anyway back on topic ;)
  • Posts: 1,778
    BAIN123 wrote:
    BAIN123 wrote:
    BAIN123 wrote:
    Please.... the dialogue in the train scene is horrendous.

    'Rolex ?' 'Omeeeega.'

    If you want horrendous dialogue watch the J.W. Pepper scenes from LALD and TMWTGG. They both really seem like something out of Looney Tunes, not James Bond.

    It's really pointless trying to criticise JW in front of DC @DoubleOhhSeven. He considers JW the best character in the franchise other than Bond.

    Your right @Bain. Im wasting energy.

    Moreover Im happy Craig has overtaken Dalton in the polls. I rewatched TLD last night and tried for the life of me to figure out why I always preferred Craig as the "serious Bond". And when I say "cool" I don't mean cool in the public's eye. I mean cool as in James Bond's Devil May Care attitude.

    I've said this before but I think he just comes off as a bit "stagey". That's the reaction I had when I re-watched a bit of TLD the other week. Also, its how they conduct themselves on camera. Connery, Moore, Craig and yes even Brosnan (in fact especially Brosnan) glide through the scenes - almost cat like.

    I'm going to defend Brosnan here, look how he walks between 04.08 and 04.19. Cool and confident.



    I'm not sure whether Dalton could have pulled that off but who knows

    Respectfully I didn't mention Brosnan because IMO Brosnan like Dalton at times simply tried too hard. If I met Connery, Moore, or Criag I'd think they were the coolest guys on the planet. If I met Brosnan I'd think this clown's putting on an act. There's a whole list of things he does in his films that always annoy me and stike me as playing up to the public's shallow interpretation of James Bond should be.

    If I met Brosnan I'd go weak at the knees but anyway back on topic.

    Lol you're right. Wrong thread for that. Back to the subject, I think Dalton's messy appearance in LTK did him no favors either. And this coming from someone who loved LTK. Both LTK and QOS are very similar in that they have Bond on his own (atleast for alittle while in QOS) and having a personal stake in the mission. But atleast Craig still looks dashing in QOS. I think thet might have taken the whole broody theme with LTK a bit too far in that Bond could be angry but that doesn't mean his style should suffer.
  • SandySandy Somewhere in Europe
    Posts: 4,012
    I'm not Brosnan's biggest fan but he could act cool sometimes. Most of them behind the wheel. But in terms of coolness who can compete with Connery and Craig, and Moore also, yes.
  • edited April 2012 Posts: 12,837
    Craig has overtaken Dalton in the polls...

    noooooo.gif

    Why.... WHHYYYYY?????
  • Posts: 1,778
    Craig has overtaken Dalton in the polls...

    noooooo.gif

    Why.... WHHYYYYY?????

    Don't feel too bad @Thelivingroyale. It's been a close race all the way through.
  • doubleoegodoubleoego #LightWork
    Posts: 11,139
    Craig is better than Dalton imo for a variety of reasons but I think it also comes down to Craig being a more engaging actor or at the very least gives a far more engaging performance. I think Dalton did a great job but I do feel he took the role a tad too seriously and didnt allow himself to just get on with it and go with the natural flow that is required to successfully pull it off.
  • 4EverBonded4EverBonded the Ballrooms of Mars
    Posts: 12,480
    Craig has stamina. ;)
  • X3MSonicXX3MSonicX https://www.behance.net/gallery/86760163/Fa-Posteres-de-007-No-Time-To-Die
    Posts: 2,635
    lol, Well, James Bond is a secret agent, he actually IS supposed to have a lot of stamina, there's no agent that runs only for 10 seconds.
    Agents actually need to run fast for at least 15 or 30 minutes. (based on MY perception, lol. Maybe even more than 15, if i'm wrong.)
  • Posts: 1,082
    X3MSonicX wrote:
    lol, Well, James Bond is a secret agent, he actually IS supposed to have a lot of stamina, there's no agent that runs only for 10 seconds.
    Agents actually need to run fast for at least 15 or 30 minutes. (based on MY perception, lol. Maybe even more than 15, if i'm wrong.)

    An agent doesn´t have to be able to run. Infact, an agent can be 60 years old. All he (or she) needs it the equipment Q-branch supplies to their agents. To quote Moore again, "Why walk when you can ride". They can use their Little Nellies, Q-Cars, Q-boats or Q-bikes (with a jet motor).

    An agent should have knowledge about the equipment, and of course knowledge in deparments like fishes, wines, food etc.

  • Posts: 7,653
    Euh, neither.

    But I like DC's oevre far better.
  • X3MSonicXX3MSonicX https://www.behance.net/gallery/86760163/Fa-Posteres-de-007-No-Time-To-Die
    Posts: 2,635
    An agent doesn´t have to be able to run. Infact, an agent can be 60 years old. All he (or she) needs it the equipment Q-branch supplies to their agents. To quote Moore again, "Why walk when you can ride". They can use their Little Nellies, Q-Cars, Q-boats or Q-bikes (with a jet motor).

    An agent should have knowledge about the equipment, and of course knowledge in deparments like fishes, wines, food etc.

    No one knows when an agent will need to run after the bandit, right? ;)
  • Posts: 1,082
    X3MSonicX wrote:
    An agent doesn´t have to be able to run. Infact, an agent can be 60 years old. All he (or she) needs it the equipment Q-branch supplies to their agents. To quote Moore again, "Why walk when you can ride". They can use their Little Nellies, Q-Cars, Q-boats or Q-bikes (with a jet motor).

    An agent should have knowledge about the equipment, and of course knowledge in deparments like fishes, wines, food etc.

    No one knows when an agent will need to run after the bandit, right? ;)

    Take Little Nellie and follow the bandit. Craig is torturing himself by running after Mitchell instead of calling Q and telling him to bring Little Nellie, or use the Q-car instead. Or steal a cab, like Moore did in AVTAK. Moore is the god of Bond.
  • 4EverBonded4EverBonded the Ballrooms of Mars
    Posts: 12,480
    Craig has stamina. ;)
  • Posts: 1,052
    I would go for Dalton, Craig may overtake in the future but I don't really think Craig is doing anything witht the part that Dalton didn't already try and to me Timbo just feels more "Bond".
  • Posts: 12,837
    I would go for Dalton, Craig may overtake in the future but I don't really think Craig is doing anything witht the part that Dalton didn't already try and to me Timbo just feels more "Bond".

    This. Except I don't think craig, or anyone else, will ever overtake Dalton in my ranking. He always has been and always will be my favourite bond.
  • Posts: 1,052
    This. Except I don't think craig, or anyone else, will ever overtake Dalton in my ranking. He always has been and always will be my favourite bond.

    Just out of curiosity "thelivingroyale", which Dalton film do you consider the definitive one? I've always thought LTK was the really pure Dalton film.
  • edited April 2012 Posts: 12,837

    Just out of curiosity "thelivingroyale", which Dalton film do you consider the definitive one? I've always thought LTK was the really pure Dalton film.

    LTK for me also, my favourite film of all time. I love TLD too but LTK is just amazing. Dalton is really badass and I like the idea of bond going rogue and looking for revenge. Plus, there are gadgets, one liners, Q, moneypenny, all the bond elements, but it is also dark and realistic.
  • Posts: 1,052
    Good choice, always really like Carey Lowell to but she doesn't seem to be a fave amongst Bond girls.
  • peterpeter Toronto
    Posts: 9,509
    Craig by a long mile. He's the bastard son of Connery. He's got enought charisma in his "little finger" to last a life time.

    Dalton was uncomfortable in the role.

    I've read comparisons to the two actors-- that both play(ed) 007 as the regretful serviceman to Her Majesty's Secret Service.

    I did feel this in Dalton.

    But I feel Craig's Bond is always ready to prove himself; that if he comes off as surly, it's because he's pissed he couldn't do it his way. He hates to see he's fallible and his pig-headness comes from refusing to acknowledge this fallibility.

    Long Live Craig as Bond...!
  • At first I would have said I'd decide by flipping a coin, but after watching a fan-made u-tube video done up to look like a film trailer for Property of a lady: I've gotta say Dalton, he's still got it.
  • Thunderball 57

    Gotta go with Craig over Dalton.
    I would go:
    Craig, Connery, Brosnan ,Dalton, Moore, Lazenby ,
Sign In or Register to comment.