›

Bond movie ranking (Simple list, no details)

1…163164166168169…242

Comments

  • barryt007barryt007
    Posts: 19,339
    MSN'S LATEST RANKINGS (not mine !! ) :

    1. CR
    2. GF
    3. SF
    4. TSWLM
    5. TB
    6. OHMSS
    7. FYEO
    8. DN
    9. YOLT
    10.TLD
    11.FRWL
    12.OP
    13.LTK
    14.GE
    15.LALD
    16.QOS
    17.SP
    18.TWINE
    19.TND
    20.TMWTGG
    21.MR
    22.DAF
    23.AVTAK
    24.DAD


  • JamesBondKenyaJamesBondKenya Danny Boyle laughs to himself
    Posts: 2,730
    barryt007 wrote: »
    MSN'S LATEST RANKINGS (not mine !! ) :

    1. CR
    2. GF
    3. SF
    4. TSWLM
    5. TB
    6. OHMSS
    7. FYEO
    8. DN
    9. YOLT
    10.TLD
    11.FRWL
    12.OP
    13.LTK
    14.GE
    15.LALD
    16.QOS
    17.SP
    18.TWINE
    19.TND
    20.TMWTGG
    21.MR
    22.DAF
    23.AVTAK
    24.DAD


    Tnd/QOS too low
    SF/TB way too high

    But the rest is fine
  • ThunderfingerThunderfinger Das Boot Hill
    Posts: 45,489
    Who or what is MSN?
  • barryt007barryt007
    Posts: 19,339
    Thunderfinger wrote: »
    Who or what is MSN?

    Microsoft News.

    You know,hotmail etc.

  • ThunderfingerThunderfinger Das Boot Hill
    Posts: 45,489
    Microsoft are evil, but smart.
  • StrogStrog
    Posts: 684
    Birdleson wrote: »
    SO we're not far off on that one either.
    You may be one of only two people to rank TLD lower than I do.
    Yes, probably the film I most differ from the consensus on. Sometimes I think my DVD copy of the film must mistakenly be from the bizzaro world. Either that or I am.
  • barryt007barryt007
    Posts: 19,339
    Strog wrote: »
    Birdleson wrote: »
    SO we're not far off on that one either.
    You may be one of only two people to rank TLD lower than I do.
    Yes, probably the film I most differ from the consensus on. Sometimes I think my DVD copy of the film must mistakenly be from the bizzaro world. Either that or I am.

    Believe me @Strog you are not...I have it stuck on #24 in my rankings.
  • StrogStrog
    edited March 2018 Posts: 684
    barryt007 wrote: »
    Strog wrote: »
    Birdleson wrote: »
    SO we're not far off on that one either.
    You may be one of only two people to rank TLD lower than I do.
    Yes, probably the film I most differ from the consensus on. Sometimes I think my DVD copy of the film must mistakenly be from the bizzaro world. Either that or I am.

    Believe me @Strog you are not...I have it stuck on #24 in my rankings.
    Oh I've taken note of your thoughts on the film across various threads, and agree with you on much. Always glad to see you (entertainingly I might add!) fighting the good fight. ;)
  • barryt007barryt007
    edited March 2018 Posts: 19,339
    Strog wrote: »
    barryt007 wrote: »
    Strog wrote: »
    Birdleson wrote: »
    SO we're not far off on that one either.
    You may be one of only two people to rank TLD lower than I do.
    Yes, probably the film I most differ from the consensus on. Sometimes I think my DVD copy of the film must mistakenly be from the bizzaro world. Either that or I am.

    Believe me @Strog you are not...I have it stuck on #24 in my rankings.
    Oh I've taken note of your thoughts on the film across various threads, and agree with you on much. Always glad to see you (entertainingly I might add!) fighting the good fight. ;)

    Thanks very much,It's a tough battle against these Karaphiles but we seem to have a few more members on here lately realising what a plank she is ;)

  • barryt007barryt007
    Posts: 19,339
    Birdleson wrote: »
    @barryt007 You were the other member that I was referring to that would rank lower than me.

    I know he he ;)

  • FoxRoxFoxRox
    Posts: 12,473
    barryt007 wrote: »
    MSN'S LATEST RANKINGS (not mine !! ) :

    1. CR
    2. GF
    3. SF
    4. TSWLM
    5. TB
    6. OHMSS
    7. FYEO
    8. DN
    9. YOLT
    10.TLD
    11.FRWL
    12.OP
    13.LTK
    14.GE
    15.LALD
    16.QOS
    17.SP
    18.TWINE
    19.TND
    20.TMWTGG
    21.MR
    22.DAF
    23.AVTAK
    24.DAD


    Not a bad list. The picks for 17-24 are almost perfect, just a little out of order (and I’d move TND out and OP in at #17. TND is 16 on my list). Obviously the right choice for #24.
  • chrisisallchrisisall Brosnan Defender Of The Realm
    Posts: 17,801
    I'm a comics guy, so my new ranking is split between adult graphic novel-style Bond and comic book Bond.... *this is merely a 'favourites' list; no statement on objective quality is intended nor should be inferred*

    TLD
    LTK
    DN
    QOS
    FRWL
    TB
    CR
    GF
    OHMSS
    TWINE
    FYEO
    SF
    _______

    TND
    SP
    YOLT
    GE
    TMWTGG
    OP
    DAF
    TSWLM
    LALD
    DAD
    AVTAK
    MR



  • IGotTheMessageIGotTheMessage United States
    Posts: 194
    I have a fair amount of work to do in order to update my Excel page on this it seems. I should probably get to doing that.
  • IGotTheMessageIGotTheMessage United States
    Posts: 194
    Alright, I updated most of it tonight. I have updated everyone who I already had with their most recent ranking and inserted several more users who I did not have who posted a ranking between the last time that I checked and now. I will finish it up tomorrow.
  • FoxRoxFoxRox
    edited March 2018 Posts: 12,473
    Newest ranking done in tiers (which always seem to change a bit too):

    Tier 1: My Top 2 which never seem to change or be in danger. Perfect, 10/10 Bond films, and two all-time favorite films in general for me.
    1. Casino Royale
    2. On Her Majesty’s Secret Service

    Tier 2: Amazing, classic Bond adventures - all 10 or 9 out of 10 Bond films. These can switch up a little sometimes.
    3. Goldfinger
    4. The Spy Who Loved Me
    5. Skyfall
    6. Dr. No
    7. GoldenEye
    8. From Russia with Love

    Tier 3: Very good Bond films. A little lesser than the above tier, but still majorly successful.
    9. Thunderball
    10. Licence to Kill
    11. For Your Eyes Only
    12. Live and Let Die

    Tier 4: Just a tad lower than Tier 3. Very good/good Bond films. Just not as commonly rewatched.
    13. Quantum of Solace (might be in Tier 3; it’s debatable)
    14. You Only Live Twice
    15. The Living Daylights

    Tier 5: Flawed but mostly fun Bond outings. More problems start to happen here, but not too serious.
    16. Tomorrow Never Dies
    17. Octopussy
    18. A View to a Kill
    19. The World Is Not Enough (any given day this could be Tier 5 or 6, but I’m feeling good about it right now)

    Tier 6: Disappointing Bond films that still have good stuff in them. These are the weaker ones, but no total losses.
    20. Spectre
    21. The Man with the Golden Gun
    22. Diamonds Are Forever
    23. Moonraker

    Tier 7: Why did this happen? (Ok, it’s not 0/10, but it is the clear-cut worst Bond film to me)
    24. Die Another Day
  • barryt007barryt007
    Posts: 19,339
    FoxRox wrote: »
    Newest ranking done in tiers (which always seem to change a bit too):

    Tier 1: My Top 2 which never seem to change or be in danger. Perfect, 10/10 Bond films, and two all-time favorite films in general for me.
    1. Casino Royale
    2. On Her Majesty’s Secret Service

    Tier 2: Amazing, classic Bond adventures - all 10 or 9 out of 10 Bond films. These can switch up a little sometimes.
    3. Goldfinger
    4. The Spy Who Loved Me
    5. Skyfall
    6. Dr. No
    7. GoldenEye
    8. From Russia with Love

    Tier 3: Very good Bond films. A little lesser than the above tier, but still majorly successful.
    9. Thunderball
    10. Licence to Kill
    11. For Your Eyes Only
    12. Live and Let Die

    Tier 4: Just a tad lower than Tier 3. Very good/good Bond films. Just not as commonly rewatched.
    13. Quantum of Solace (might be in Tier 3; it’s debatable)
    14. You Only Live Twice
    15. The Living Daylights

    Tier 5: Flawed but mostly fun Bond outings. More problems start to happen here, but not too serious.
    16. Tomorrow Never Dies
    17. Octopussy
    18. A View to a Kill
    19. The World Is Not Enough (any given day this could be Tier 5 or 6, but I’m feeling good about it right now)

    Tier 6: Disappointing Bond films that still have good stuff in them. These are the weaker ones, but no total losses.
    20. Spectre
    21. The Man with the Golden Gun
    22. Diamonds Are Forever
    23. Moonraker

    Tier 7: Why did this happen? (Ok, it’s not 0/10, but it is the clear-cut worst Bond film to me)
    24. Die Another Day

    1.Go on x stick QOS into tier 3,you know you want to (it’s #4 in my rankings )
    2.Keep TWINE in that tier x bravo !
  • w2bondw2bond is indeed a very rare breed
    Posts: 2,252
    Here is my rough ranking by relative scores, where I take each Bond element (eg Bond performance, Music, Plot), give it a weighting and a number from 1-5 or 1-10 on a relative scale (ie average of scores is 2.5 or 5). It's still in a crude stage, it's hard to refine a system like this...
    1. OHMSS (90.5)
    2. FRWL (83)
    3. GE (80)
    4. GF (74.5)
    5. LALD (74.5)
    6. TLD (70)
    7. CR (67.5)
    8. DN (66.5)
    9. OP (65)
    10. MR (58.5)
    11. TSWLM (57)
    12. FYEO (55)
    13. TND (50)
    14. TMWTGG (46)
    15. SF (46)
    16. DAF (41.5)
    17. TB (40.5)
    18. SP (36.5)
    19. LTK (36.5)
    20. YOLT (36.5)
    21. AVTAK (28)
    22. QOS (23.5)
    23. DAD (13)
    24. TWINE (8)

    My actual ranking:

    1. The Living Daylights
    2. Goldeneye
    3. From Russia With Love
    4. On Her Majesty's Secret Service
    5. Casino Royale
    6. Dr No
    7. Octopussy

    8. Live and Let Die
    9. Goldfinger
    10. For Your Eyes Only
    11. Tomorrow Never Dies
    12. Moonraker
    13. The Spy Who Loved Me
    14. Diamonds Are Forever
    15. Licence to Kill

    16. A View To A Kill
    17. The Man With The Golden Gun

    18. Skyfall
    19. Die Another Day
    20. You Only Live Twice

    21. Spectre
    22. Thunderball
    23. Quantum of Solace
    24. The World is Enough
  • IGotTheMessageIGotTheMessage United States
    edited March 2018 Posts: 194
    Alright, I just finished updating the rankings. It was quite a bit of work as I have so many so statistics and I have to make sure each time that I enter a ranking from a user who I do not have one from yet, that the formulas are also taking their ranking in account. With users who I already have a ranking from, I simply update their ranking with the most recent data which they have entered. I now have one hundred and thirty-seven rankings in the Excel Sheet and a raft of statistics on the data set.

    The cumulative ranking now looks like this:

    1.) Casino Royale (4.6058)
    2.) On Her Majesty's Secret Service (5.0588)
    3.) From Russia With Love (5.5036)
    4.) Goldfinger (7.5182)
    5.) The Living Daylights (8.4161)
    6.) Dr. No (9.2336)
    7.) Skyfall (9.3358)
    8.) The Spy Who Loved Me (9.5839)
    9.) Goldeneye (9.6642)
    10.) Thunderball (10.5620)
    11.) Licence to Kill (11.0657)
    12.) For Your Eyes Only (12.1606)
    13.) Live and Let Die (13.4161)
    14.) Spectre (13.5620)
    15.) Octopussy (14.2847)
    16.) You Only Live Twice (14.3650)
    17.) Quantum Of Solace (15.3869)
    18.) Tomorrow Never Dies (16.5036)
    19.) The Man with the Golden Gun (17.3212)
    20.) Moonraker (17.4161)
    21.) Diamonds Are Forever (17.4162)
    22.) The World Is Not Enough (17.6350)
    23.) A View To A Kill (18.6642)
    24.) Ice Palace (21.2774)
  • IGotTheMessageIGotTheMessage United States
    edited March 2018 Posts: 194
    That data also includes my updated personal ranking. I made a few changes to it. It currently looks like this:

    My rankings:

    1. Dr. No
    2. Casino Royale
    3. From Russia With Love
    4. Licence to Kill
    5. On Her Majesty's Secret Service
    6. Goldeneye
    7. The Living Daylights
    8. Thunderball
    9. Goldfinger
    10. The Spy Who Loved Me
    11. Skyfall
    12. Live and Let Die
    13. Octopussy
    14. For Your Eyes Only
    15. The Man with the Golden Gun
    16. You Only Live Twice
    17. Spectre
    18. Moonraker
    19. Tomorrow Never Dies
    20. Quantum of Solace
    21. The World Is Not Enough
    22. A View to a Kill
    23. Diamonds Are Forever
    24. Ice Palace

  • FoxRoxFoxRox
    Posts: 12,473
    IGotTheMessage wrote: »
    Alright, I just finished updating the rankings. It was quite a bit of work as I have so many so statistics and I have to make sure each time that I enter a ranking from a user who I do not have one from yet, that the formulas are also taking their ranking in account. With users who I already have a ranking from, I simply update their ranking with the most recent data which they have entered. I now have one hundred and thirty-seven rankings in the Excel Sheet and a raft of statistics on the data set.

    The cumulative ranking now looks like this:

    1.) Casino Royale (4.6058)
    2.) On Her Majesty's Secret Service (5.0588)
    3.) From Russia With Love (5.5036)
    4.) Goldfinger (7.5182)
    5.) The Living Daylights (8.4161)
    6.) Dr. No (9.2336)
    7.) Skyfall (9.3358)
    8.) The Spy Who Loved Me (9.5839)
    9.) Goldeneye (9.6642)
    10.) Thunderball (10.5620)
    11.) Licence to Kill (11.0657)
    12.) For Your Eyes Only (12.1606)
    13.) Live and Let Die (13.4161)
    14.) Spectre (13.5620)
    15.) Octopussy (14.2847)
    16.) You Only Live Twice (14.3650)
    17.) Quantum Of Solace (15.3869)
    18.) Tomorrow Never Dies (16.5036)
    19.) The Man with the Golden Gun (17.3212)
    20.) Moonraker (17.4161)
    21.) Diamonds Are Forever (17.4162)
    22.) The World Is Not Enough (17.6350)
    23.) A View To A Kill (18.6642)
    24.) Ice Palace (21.2774)

    Not bad. The top 2 are perfect!
  • Mathis1Mathis1
    Posts: 7,434
    I'm just concerned that I've never seen 'Ice Palace!!!!
  • FoxRoxFoxRox
    Posts: 12,473
    Birdleson wrote: »
    I am surprised that even after all this time SP fared so well.

    @Birdleson same. I expected 18 or so for it on average.
  • Mathis1Mathis1
    Posts: 7,434
    It did seem to be hated by everyone. But I think it was just a few very strong vocal posters. Bottom line is that no matter whats said about SP, it isn't viewed as worse than DAD, the very nadir of the series!
  • GoldenGunGoldenGun Per ora e per il momento che verrà
    Posts: 7,136
    Birdleson wrote: »
    Except by me and a few others.
    I’m on your side on that one.
  • Mendes4LyfeMendes4Lyfe The long road ahead
    edited March 2018 Posts: 8,400
    Yeah, got your back bro, no worries.
  • IGotTheMessageIGotTheMessage United States
    Posts: 194
    @Birdleson,
    Of course.
    As for Spectre, it has been on a fairly steady downward slide since I first began accumulating the rankings last Summer. It was in twelfth one I last posted the cumulative rankings over the Summer and has since fallen off to fourteenth. In the current rankings, it has placed in the top five 18 times, or in 13% of all rankings, which is holding it up somewhat (for comparisons sake, LALD has only been in the top-5 11 times), but it has nonetheless definitely weakening as time passes. If more of the rankings posted shortly after it was released were updated, many of which have not been in a long while, it would probably lose a number of those high placements and would slip further as a consequence.

    With that said though, it is not really at the top of the list of films being ranked in the bottom five. It has been ranked in the bottom five a total of 29 times, which is 21% of the total. I will put up those statistics in order to demonstrate this point.

    Number of times ranked in the bottom five Percentage of time in the bottom five
    7 5% -DN
    2 1% -FRWL
    2 1% -GF
    15 11% -TB
    23 17% -YOLT
    2 1% -OHMSS
    52 38% -DAF
    16 12% -LALD
    51 37% -TMWTGG
    6 4% -TSWLM
    59 43% -MR
    8 6% -FYEO
    24 18% -OP
    76 55% -AVTAK
    6 4% -TLD
    23 17% -LTK
    10 7% -GE
    45 33% -TND
    59 43% -TWINE
    110 80% -DAD
    2 1% -CR
    45 33% -QOS
    14 10% -SF
    29 21% -SP

    So, while it's current position is probably a bit misleading, it also doesn't seem as if those who aren't ranking it highly universally regard it as one of the worst films in the series. It will probably drop further from here, but the vibe that I am getting is that it probably will not end up dropping into the bottom five or six anytime soon.
  • ThunderfingerThunderfinger Das Boot Hill
    Posts: 45,489
    Very interesting statistics. Thanks for doing it.
  • IGotTheMessageIGotTheMessage United States
    Posts: 194
    Thunderfinger wrote: »
    Very interesting statistics. Thanks for doing it.

    No problem.
  • bondjamesbondjames You were expecting someone else?
    edited March 2018 Posts: 23,883
    Thanks for the effort in pulling those stats together @IGotTheMessage. For me, what's interesting is how unsurprising those results actually are. The top 10 is precisely what I expected from a survey of the fanatical faithful.

    As I had noted on another thread, it's interesting to me how FYEO/LALD almost inevitably end up together just below the top 10, which I've seen in a couple of member rankings. The bottom 8 are exactly what I expected. I'm reasonably certain SP will join them, in time.

    I differ most from the forum on TLD and GF, both which I rank far lower than the average.
  • IGotTheMessageIGotTheMessage United States
    Posts: 194
    @bondjames,
    If you are interested, your ranking currently has a correlation of .806956522 to the cumulative ranking.
Sign In or Register to comment.