And the Klebbie goes to...Worst execution of a good idea page 147

16667697172148

Comments

  • LocqueLocque Escaped from a Namur prison
    Posts: 262
    I like the easygoing chemistry between Bond and Q in GE (all the more impressive since it was Brosnan's first).

    After all these years, they've become old friends having a laugh at work.
  • Posts: 5,993
    GF, no doubt about that. And it's funny how that movie is the most quotable of all. My second place would be the scene from TWINE. Brings a tear in my eye when I watch it, knowing it was the last time we saw Desmond on screen.
  • Posts: 1,917
    I can't think of a Q-Bond scene I don't like. It was always something to look forward to back in the days of the classics, heck up until TWINE even.

    My write-in nominee would be TB with Q in tropical climate clothes, introducing a number of gadgets and perfect comedy timing between Connery and Llewelyn. OP would be my second nominee in Q's India workshop as he and Moore have are at a peak there.

    GF is fast becoming the favorite here, but I can't go for that as the playfulness is mostly on Connery's side and Llewelyn is just a tad stiff and too deadpan. It was introduced here and perfected in following films.

    In GE, the chemistry's good between Brosnan and Llewelyn, but the jokes are poor. I'm very tempted to vote for SF as I really like seeing Craig doing the witty banter with Whishaw. But I can't do that to the original Q.

    I never thought I'd ever pick TWINE to have a superlative for anything, but of these nominees, I can't forget that final Bond-Q meeting that has a great blend of humor and sentimentality with that haunting final exit, made even more poignant in that he'd pass away just a few weeks later. I pick TWINE.
  • mtmmtm United Kingdom
    Posts: 16,363
    Locque wrote: »
    I like the easygoing chemistry between Bond and Q in GE (all the more impressive since it was Brosnan's first).

    I do quite like that, but I think Llewelyn is, to be honest, pretty bad in that scene. He's even clearly reading it off cards! Pierce is in full smug mode too.

    I think I'd give honourable mentions to the Living Daylights one (I think Llewelyn is good in that one, I rather like the gags, and it doesn't outstay its welcome); and to be honest although it's amongst the silliest, the Octopussy one is quite enjoyable because Roger is at his most like a little schoolboy and Q at maximum schoolteacherish: it's sort of like the most extreme version they've ever done with the most groan-worthy gags (and one even stolen from Casino Royale!), but if you're in the right frame of mind it's rather charming. Apart from the leering at a girl's tits of course!

    Of the noms though, I will give honourable mention to the Skyfall one as it's fresh and sparky and gives new life to Q. The TWINE one... I dunno, I think it's one of the worst. He taught him to "never let them see you bleed"? When?! :D

    But yeah, I'll go with Goldfinger too. Connery is lovely and subtle in it, and there's lots to enjoy.
  • Posts: 7,415
    mtm wrote: »
    Locque wrote: »
    I like the easygoing chemistry between Bond and Q in GE (all the more impressive since it was Brosnan's first).

    I do quite like that, but I think Llewelyn is, to be honest, pretty bad in that scene. He's even clearly reading it off cards! Pierce is in full smug mode too.

    I think I'd give honourable mentions to the Living Daylights one (I think Llewelyn is good in that one, I rather like the gags, and it doesn't outstay its welcome); and to be honest although it's amongst the silliest, the Octopussy one is quite enjoyable because Roger is at his most like a little schoolboy and Q at maximum schoolteacherish: it's sort of like the most extreme version they've ever done with the most groan-worthy gags (and one even stolen from Casino Royale!), but if you're in the right frame of mind it's rather charming. Apart from the leering at a girl's tits of course!

    Of the noms though, I will give honourable mention to the Skyfall one as it's fresh and sparky and gives new life to Q. The TWINE one... I dunno, I think it's one of the worst. He taught him to "never let them see you bleed"? When?! :D

    But yeah, I'll go with Goldfinger too. Connery is lovely and subtle in it, and there's lots to enjoy.

    Agreed on both counts, re GE poor old Des is clearly reading his lines and Brossa is very smugly annoying (hate thst moment he is messing with the laptop!)
    Also agree on TLD, i would second that, well written scene ("you dont find many normal people in this business Q!")
  • mtmmtm United Kingdom
    Posts: 16,363
    Mathis1 wrote: »
    mtm wrote: »
    Locque wrote: »
    I like the easygoing chemistry between Bond and Q in GE (all the more impressive since it was Brosnan's first).

    I do quite like that, but I think Llewelyn is, to be honest, pretty bad in that scene. He's even clearly reading it off cards! Pierce is in full smug mode too.

    I think I'd give honourable mentions to the Living Daylights one (I think Llewelyn is good in that one, I rather like the gags, and it doesn't outstay its welcome); and to be honest although it's amongst the silliest, the Octopussy one is quite enjoyable because Roger is at his most like a little schoolboy and Q at maximum schoolteacherish: it's sort of like the most extreme version they've ever done with the most groan-worthy gags (and one even stolen from Casino Royale!), but if you're in the right frame of mind it's rather charming. Apart from the leering at a girl's tits of course!

    Of the noms though, I will give honourable mention to the Skyfall one as it's fresh and sparky and gives new life to Q. The TWINE one... I dunno, I think it's one of the worst. He taught him to "never let them see you bleed"? When?! :D

    But yeah, I'll go with Goldfinger too. Connery is lovely and subtle in it, and there's lots to enjoy.

    Agreed on both counts, re GE poor old Des is clearly reading his lines and Brossa is very smugly annoying (hate thst moment he is messing with the laptop!)

    Ooh there's a good potential category for a future Klebbie: Most Distracting Bit of Product Placement! :D They literally just stop the scene dead so they can advertise the new IBM laptop- there's not even a joke there!
  • Posts: 928
    I'll vote for the TWINE farewell scene.
  • goldenswissroyalegoldenswissroyale Switzerland
    Posts: 4,483
    GE.
    TWINE is the weakest with a nomination. Good and emotional ending but the rest is a bit disappointing.
    GF is very good, no doubt. My favourite Q scene with Connery is the one from TB, great fun!
    My two favourites are GE and SF. I'm not even sure for which one I voted in my poll but I usually go with the one from GE. Loved it as a teenager and still works perfect for me now. Not annoying at all for me.
  • mtmmtm United Kingdom
    edited July 2020 Posts: 16,363
    GE.
    TWINE is the weakest with a nomination. Good and emotional ending but the rest is a bit disappointing.

    I even find the ending a bit weird. I remember my friend seeing it and describing it as 'a scared-looking old man being lowered into a pit' :D
    GF is very good, no doubt. My favourite Q scene with Connery is the one from TB, great fun!

    Heh! I do love his reaction to Q when he walks in: it's obvious that the Q scene in Goldfinger was felt to have an impact straight away as this was only a year later.
  • RichardTheBruceRichardTheBruce I'm motivated by my Duty.
    Posts: 13,779
    GF.

    This deserves an eventual future round of five ONLY Desmond Llewelyn Q choices.

  • thedovethedove hiding in the Greek underworld
    Posts: 5,418
    GF.

    This deserves an eventual future round of five ONLY Desmond Llewelyn Q choices.

    Excellent idea @RichardTheBruce I shall queue it up in our line-up. Recently watching TB and I had forgotten how loud Q's tropical shirt is. I also liked his socks and shoes in YOLT. He looks rightly peeved to come out to Japan and takes great offence to Tiger calling it a toy! Good stuff there.
  • j_w_pepperj_w_pepper Born on the bayou, but I now hear a new dog barkin'
    Posts: 9,026
    I'm all for the GF scene. Everything else is just a copy.
  • echoecho 007 in New York
    edited July 2020 Posts: 6,287
    Can't deny GF, although I have a soft spot for "007 never did have respect for government property."

    All of the M/Moneypenny/Q scenes in OHMSS are simply...perfect.

    "What would I do without you, Miss Moneypenny? Thank you."

    "Miss Moneypenny, what would you do without me?"
  • Posts: 5,993
    Agreed, the best Bond/Moneypenny scene is the one from OHMSS. The worst : DAD.
  • FatherValentineFatherValentine England
    Posts: 737
    If we're going beyond Desmond Llewelyn, then I like the scene in NSNA. Or should that be in the Controversial Opinions thread?
  • GoldenGunGoldenGun Per ora e per il momento che verrà
    edited July 2020 Posts: 7,110
    Out of the nominees, I'd go for TWINE because it's a great mix of funny interplay and a touching goodbye to one of the series' most beloved characters.

    On the other hand, if write-ins are allowed I'd say uncle Q's visit in LTK is a highlight. One of the things I love about LTK is how much Q we get. Love that first scene: If it hadn't been for Q Branch you'd been dead long ago.

    And this priceless one:

    Bond to Pam: Pam, meet Q, my uncle.
    Bond to Q: Q, meet Pam, my cousin.
    Q: Aaah, we must be related.
  • M_BaljeM_Balje Amsterdam, Netherlands
    Posts: 4,515
    Twine: Always have escape plan. When the world say goodbye to Desmond.
    I watched Twine 24 days after his death.

    But let i for another one: Q in Moonraker on the side of the road. The stroyman.
  • mtmmtm United Kingdom
    Posts: 16,363
    GoldenGun wrote: »
    Out of the nominees, I'd go for TWINE because it's a great mix of funny interplay and a touching goodbye to one of the series' most beloved characters.

    On the other hand, if write-ins are allowed I'd say uncle Q's visit in LTK is a highlight. One of the things I love about LTK is how much Q we get. Love that first scene: If it hadn't been for Q Branch you'd been dead long ago.

    And this priceless one:

    Bond to Pam: Pam, meet Q, my uncle.
    Bond to Q: Q, meet Pam, my cousin.
    Q: Aaah, we must be related.

    Although I did see someone point out recently that Q was giving Government equipment to a civilian in that, and basically being an accomplice to murder! :) Quite how he kept his job I don't know...
  • Tokoloshe2Tokoloshe2 Northern Ireland
    Posts: 1,175
    I have to vote for GE, I've always loved the light-heartedness of it and all the background jokes. It's a great way to introduce Brosnan/Q in the era, and the final "that's my lunch!" gag makes me laugh every time.
  • R1s1ngs0nR1s1ngs0n France
    Posts: 2,148
    GF and it’s not even close.
    I also very much like their scene in TB.
    You clearly see that Bond enjoys testing Q’s patience in that one and both actors’ play off each other beautifully.
  • BennyBenny Shaken not stirredAdministrator, Moderator
    Posts: 15,133
    Of those nominated, I'll go with GF. However I do enjoy the Q scene in GE, although dear old Desmond is clearly reading from cue cards, it's still a nice sequence. I always enjoy the end joke. 'Don't touch that! That's my lunch.'
  • goldenswissroyalegoldenswissroyale Switzerland
    Posts: 4,483
    It's interesting how often GF wins in such games. It seems that the cast and first half of the film are absolutely iconic and almost unbeatable. (?)
  • thedovethedove hiding in the Greek underworld
    Posts: 5,418
    I agree @goldenswissroyale GF just has some many iconic and memorable scenes. What this has caused me to see is that the first three films DN, FRWL, and GF all so well done and in such a short time. 1962, 63, and 64. I would add in TB but some don't love it as much. It was an incredible run of films. In fact I think it's the strongest trio in the series. You see with Craig's era that with the time of 3-4 years between films and yet it's produces an uneven result. Shows you what legends were involved in those early films. Adam, Barry, Maibaum, Saltzman Broccoli, Connery and then all the others. Just incredible work unlikely to be duplicated.
  • Posts: 1,917
    thedove wrote: »
    I agree @goldenswissroyale GF just has some many iconic and memorable scenes. What this has caused me to see is that the first three films DN, FRWL, and GF all so well done and in such a short time. 1962, 63, and 64. I would add in TB but some don't love it as much. It was an incredible run of films. In fact I think it's the strongest trio in the series. You see with Craig's era that with the time of 3-4 years between films and yet it's produces an uneven result. Shows you what legends were involved in those early films. Adam, Barry, Maibaum, Saltzman Broccoli, Connery and then all the others. Just incredible work unlikely to be duplicated.

    Yes, great points. It seemed like the momentum was strong, to keep going, they were hungry.

    I'll expand on that when you consider many of the musicians of the time such as the Beatles, who seemed to be cranking out great music in short periods of time constantly. I guess this kind of lends itself to the saying they don't make 'em like they used to.
  • LeonardPineLeonardPine The Bar on the Beach
    Posts: 3,996
    GF by a mile. Iconic, beautifully played by both actors, and that car....👍
  • MooseWithFleasMooseWithFleas Philadelphia
    Posts: 3,369
    GoldenEye please!
  • PrinceKamalKhanPrinceKamalKhan Monsoon Palace, Udaipur
    edited July 2020 Posts: 3,262
    GoldenGun wrote: »
    Out of the nominees, I'd go for TWINE because it's a great mix of funny interplay and a touching goodbye to one of the series' most beloved characters.

    On the other hand, if write-ins are allowed I'd say uncle Q's visit in LTK is a highlight. One of the things I love about LTK is how much Q we get. Love that first scene: If it hadn't been for Q Branch you'd been dead long ago.

    And this priceless one:

    Bond to Pam: Pam, meet Q, my uncle.
    Bond to Q: Q, meet Pam, my cousin.
    Q: Aaah, we must be related.

    There's something about all of Q's scenes with his extended role in LTK in the sense we've seen how far their friendship has grown since that classic scene in GF which will probably win and for good reason.

    I'm casting my vote for a write in:

    OP-where Bond and Q ride in the hot air balloon with the Union Jack and Q saves Magda and company with the hot air balloon and receives a welcome embrace from her "Later, perhaps."

  • mattjoesmattjoes Julie T. and the M.G.'s
    Posts: 7,021
    I vote for GoldenEye, as there is such an immediately affectionate and warm chemistry between Pierce Brosnan and Desmond Llewelyn. It's also a very funny scene.

    I'll also express an appreciation for that poignant moment in TWINE. "You're not retiring anytime soon... are you?" There is an emotional connection between the viewer and the character of Q that has had years to build up, and in that scene, it is gratifyingly and gracefully allowed to come to the surface for just the right amount of time. It also creates a perfect transition into the next scene, with Bond studying Elektra King's sad backstory.
  • marcmarc Universal Exports
    Posts: 2,610
    I like how Bond and Q laugh together in GE when 'the writing is on the wall', and the sandwich is a perfect ending for this scene.
  • Posts: 1,009
    GE. I have a special spot for that one.
Sign In or Register to comment.