›

Bond movie ranking (Simple list, no details)

1…5354565859…242

Comments

  • Crazysoul95Crazysoul95
    edited September 2015 Posts: 3,336
    The top 3 stands far apart i see. 9 out of 10, i am pretty mainstream i quess =)
  • Gustav_GravesGustav_Graves
    edited September 2015 Posts: 11,119
    As I mentioned in my previous post, I did the same thing on IMDB ( http://www.imdb.com/title/tt2379713/board/thread/245015308 and http://www.imdb.com/board/bd0000075/thread/245297664 ). And down below you can see the standings after 61 voters have casted up there. Remember, IMDB-voters, not necessarily the biggest Bond fans:
    Lzk1fu.jpg

    And after that I compared the rankings, and my only conclusion is: A lot of similarities!:
    3ttc2U.jpg

    Like @AntiLocqueBrakes already mentioned, it gets slightly 'wishy-washy' from 13th towards 20th place. There you see a bit more discrepancies. That can be easily explained, because one top vote can do a 'lot of damage'. To filter that out, one needs a lot more voters. Like in real statistics, a pool of 750 to 1000 voters. But that's off course impossible here :-).

    I think the rankings from 1st to 13th place and then from 21st to 25th place are way more accurate. And there you see.....quite a lot of similarities. As a matter of fact, 9 films had the exact ranking in both polls. And besides that in the TOP 13....sometimes only one spot difference, like "Skyfall" and "GoldenEye".

    Interesting though.....there's slightly more love for the Brosnan films outside this community. "Quantum Of Solace" is unanimously 'hated' on IMDB :-P.
  • suavejmfsuavejmf Harrogate, North Yorkshire, England
    Posts: 5,131
    I'm surprised how low DN and TB are. Both brilliant films for me. Good to see that IMDB users rate OHMSS so highly.
  • bondjamesbondjames You were expecting someone else?
    edited September 2015 Posts: 23,883
    Thanks for compiling that @Gustav_Graves.

    I'm happy to see that, apart from OP (which I rated higher than the average voter), and GF (which I rated much lower than the average voter) all my top 10 are in the eventual list.

    Not surprising, because the top 10 is credible as far as I'm concerned. I still think GF is overrated due to its understandable nostalgic impact at the time of release, but that's just me it seems.
  • suavejmfsuavejmf Harrogate, North Yorkshire, England
    Posts: 5,131
    I like GF because of Connery and the faithfulness to Fleming. However, for me it's the weakest of the first 4. Some great one liners mind. The public rate it as it was the beginning of the Bond craze.
  • Gustav_GravesGustav_Graves
    Posts: 11,119
    bondjames wrote: »
    I still think GF is overrated due to its understandable nostalgic impact at the time of release, but that's just me it seems.

    Actually, I completely agree with you. I think GF has this 'cult status'....that will only slightly wear off in several decades from now :-P.
  • BondJasonBond006BondJasonBond006 on fb and ajb
    Posts: 9,020
    Gustav_Graves wrote: »
    bondjames wrote: »
    I still think GF is overrated due to its understandable nostalgic impact at the time of release, but that's just me it seems.

    Actually, I completely agree with you. I think GF has this 'cult status'....that will only slightly wear off in several decades from now :-P.

    Funny you people say this because GF has been my No 7 Bond movie for practically decades (No 6 even before CR).

    Finally I got over the nostalgia and respect for its legacy and ranked it properly which means it is now my No 13 Bond movie.
  • Gustav_GravesGustav_Graves
    Posts: 11,119
    BondJasonBond006 wrote: »
    Gustav_Graves wrote: »
    bondjames wrote: »
    I still think GF is overrated due to its understandable nostalgic impact at the time of release, but that's just me it seems.

    Actually, I completely agree with you. I think GF has this 'cult status'....that will only slightly wear off in several decades from now :-P.

    Funny you people say this because GF has been my No 7 Bond movie for practically decades (No 6 even before CR).

    Finally I got over the nostalgia and respect for its legacy and ranked it properly which means it is now my No 13 Bond movie.

    Oooops, I didn't give GF any point at all :-O!
  • echoecho 007 in New York
    Posts: 6,304
    Let's see:

    1. OHMSS
    2. CR
    3. TLD
    4. TSWLM
    5. GF
    6. FRWL
    7. DN
    8. YOLT
    9. TB
    10. SF
    11. OP
    12. QoS
    13. LALD
    14. FYEO
    15. LTK
    16. GE
    17. TWINE
    18. DAF
    19. MR
    20. AVTAK
    21. TND
    22. TMWTGG
    23. DAD
  • chrisisallchrisisall Brosnan Defender Of The Realm
    Posts: 17,801
    We now move towards an era where GF is underrated & CR is overrated...
  • MansfieldMansfield Where the hell have you been?
    Posts: 1,263
    1. Casino Royale
    4. Goldfinger
    7. The Living Daylights
    14. Octopussy
    22. A View To A Kill

    5/23 match the MI6 community aggregate based on my most recent vote. 8/10 of the top titles also find a similar placement in my rankings. The two that didn't are the following:

    11. The Spy Who Loved Me
    16. Thunderball
  • walter1985walter1985 Rotterdam
    Posts: 91
    very funny to see AVTAK somewhere at the bottom and OHMSS somewhere at the top. can't see what's wrong with AVTAK - okay, a screaming Stacey - and I can't see what's there to enjoy about George L.'s Bond.
  • Gustav_GravesGustav_Graves
    edited September 2015 Posts: 11,119
    In case people forgot to read my previous post on page 60, here are again the ranked results from this topic over the year 2015:
    Like in the polls I created on here, I did a very interesting ranking.

    1. I took all people's latest/newest updated TOP 10 rankings (Many people give their updated rankings several times).

    2. I only looked at the posts from this year (1st of January till now. Sorry, because of all the work I didn't see you @walter1985)

    3. Then I added Eurovision style points to each and individual TOP 10 ranking:
    no# 1 - 12 points
    no# 2 - 10 points
    no# 3 - 08 points
    no# 4 - 07 points
    no# 5 - 06 points
    no# 6 - 05 points
    no# 7 - 04 points
    no# 8 - 03 points
    no# 9 - 02 points
    no#10- 01 point

    4. With this system I could add the TOP 10's of 54 forummembers. I added them up all together. And this is the TOP 25 ranking so far:

    IMiA06.png

    The funny thing is....the results are almost exactly the same as a similar poll I am conducting on two topics on the IMDB-forum: "SPECTRE"-topic and the "James Bond"=topic. Those results I will post later, so you can compare.


    So....as I mentioned above, I did the same thing on IMDB ( http://www.imdb.com/title/tt2379713/board/thread/245015308 and http://www.imdb.com/board/bd0000075/thread/245297664 ). And down below you can see the standings after 61 voters have casted up there. Remember, IMDB-voters, not necessarily the biggest Bond fans:
    Lzk1fu.jpg

    And after that I compared the rankings, and my only conclusion is: A lot of similarities!:
    3ttc2U.jpg

    Like @AntiLocqueBrakes already mentioned, it gets slightly 'wishy-washy' from 13th towards 20th place. There you see a bit more discrepancies. That can be easily explained, because one top vote can do a 'lot of damage'. To filter that out, one needs a lot more voters. Like in real statistics, a pool of 750 to 1000 voters. But that's off course impossible here :-).

    I think the rankings from 1st to 13th place and then from 21st to 25th place are way more accurate. And there you see.....quite a lot of similarities. As a matter of fact, 9 films had the exact ranking in both polls. And besides that in the TOP 13....sometimes only one spot difference, like "Skyfall" and "GoldenEye".

    Interesting though.....there's slightly more love for the Brosnan films outside this community. "Quantum Of Solace" is unanimously 'hated' on IMDB :-P.
  • Crazysoul95Crazysoul95
    Posts: 3,336
    Nice to see GF at 4th, because of all the bashing it gets on here i would imagined it being much lower. And it only finished in 10th place in the Bond Film Elimination Game.
  • tigers99tigers99
    Posts: 582
    Changes all the time but here we go:

    1. Casino Royale
    2. From Russia with Love
    3. On Her Majesty's Secret Service
    4. Dr. No
    5. Licence to Kill
    6. Skyfall
    7. Goldfinger
    8. The Living Daylights
    9. Thunderball
    10. GoldenEye
    11. For Your Eyes Only
    12. Octopussy
    13. The Spy Who Loved Me
    14. You Only Live Twice
    15. The World is Not Enough
    16. Tomorrow Never Dies
    17. Live and Let Die
    18. Quantum of Solace
    19. The Man with the Golden Gun
    20. A View to a Kill
    21. Diamonds Are Forever
    22. Moonraker
    23. Die Another Day (close one with Moonraker and Diamonds, but this was the most disappointing first viewing)
  • jobojobo
    edited September 2015 Posts: 7,507
    Okay, here's my updated one as well for you to register @Gustav_Graves.

    1. From Russia With Love
    2. Casino Royale
    3. Dr No
    4. The Living Daylights
    5. On Her Majesty's Secret Service
    6. Skyfall
    7. Licence To Kill
    8. For Your Eyes Only
    9. Thunderball
    10. Goldfinger
    11. The Spy Who Loved Me
    12. Octopussy
    13. Quantum of Solace
    14. Goldeneye
    15. Live And Let Die
    16. Moonraker
    17. You Only Live Twice
    18. A View to a Kill
    19. The Man With the Golden Gun
    20. Tomorrow Never Dies
    21. Diamonds Are Forever
    22. The World is Not Enough
    23. Die Another Day
  • ThighsOfXeniaThighsOfXenia
    Posts: 1,596
    BondJasonBond006 wrote: »
    Well, I don't think my ranking is that odd. I do have all 6 actors in the top 6, which shows that I don't let favouritism get in the way in my ranking.

    Not sure if "odd" was the right word. What I meant was "atypical."
  • WaltherPPKWaltherPPK
    Posts: 50
    After my latest marathon, just in time for SPECTRE I might add, my list now looks like this.

    1. Living Daylights
    2. Licence to Kill
    3. Casino Royale
    4. From Russia With Love
    5. Thunderball
    6. On Her Majesty's Secret Service
    7. SkyFall
    8. Live and Let Die
    9. Octopussy
    10. For Your Eyes Only
    11. Diamonds are Forever
    12. Goldfinger
    13. The Spy Who Loved Me
    14. Dr No.
    15. Quantum Of Solace
    16. You Only Live Twice
    17. Goldeneye
    18. The World is Enough
    19. Moonraker
    20. A View to A Kill
    21. The Man with the Golden Gun
    22. Tomorrow Never Dies
    23. Die Another Day
  • KronsteenKronsteen Stockholm
    Posts: 783
    This is my first ranking in 3 years I think, after I recently finished my 2015 marathon. The only ones I just couldn't separate was TLD and LALD...

    1. From Russia With Love (10/10)
    2. On Her Majestys Secret Service (9½)
    3. The Living Daylights (9)
    3. Live and Let Die (9)
    5. Thunderball (8 )
    6. Dr. No (8 )
    7. Casino Royale (8 )
    8. The Spy Who Loved Me (8 )
    9. For Your Eyes Only (8 )
    10. Goldeneye (8 )
    11. Goldfinger (7½)
    12. A View to a Kill (7)
    13. The Man with the Golden Gun (7)
    14. Octopussy (6)
    15. You Only Live Twice (6)
    16. Skyfall (6)
    17. Licence To Kill (6)
    18. Quantum of Solace (5½)
    19. Moonraker (5)
    20. Diamonds Are Forever (4½)
    21. Die Another Day (4)
    22. The World Is Not Enough (3½)
    23. Tomorrow Never Dies (3)
  • suavejmfsuavejmf Harrogate, North Yorkshire, England
    Posts: 5,131
    WaltherPPK wrote: »
    After my latest marathon, just in time for SPECTRE I might add, my list now looks like this.

    1. Living Daylights
    2. Licence to Kill
    3. Casino Royale
    4. From Russia With Love
    5. Thunderball
    6. On Her Majesty's Secret Service
    7. SkyFall
    8. Live and Let Die
    9. Octopussy
    10. For Your Eyes Only
    11. Diamonds are Forever
    12. Goldfinger
    13. The Spy Who Loved Me
    14. Dr No.
    15. Quantum Of Solace
    16. You Only Live Twice
    17. Goldeneye
    18. The World is Enough
    19. Moonraker
    20. A View to A Kill
    21. The Man with the Golden Gun
    22. Tomorrow Never Dies
    23. Die Another Day

    Not a bad list. I'm surprised a Daltonite would rank DN so low though?
  • WaltherPPKWaltherPPK
    Posts: 50
    suavejmf wrote: »
    WaltherPPK wrote: »
    After my latest marathon, just in time for SPECTRE I might add, my list now looks like this.

    1. Living Daylights
    2. Licence to Kill
    3. Casino Royale
    4. From Russia With Love
    5. Thunderball
    6. On Her Majesty's Secret Service
    7. SkyFall
    8. Live and Let Die
    9. Octopussy
    10. For Your Eyes Only
    11. Diamonds are Forever
    12. Goldfinger
    13. The Spy Who Loved Me
    14. Dr No.
    15. Quantum Of Solace
    16. You Only Live Twice
    17. Goldeneye
    18. The World is Enough
    19. Moonraker
    20. A View to A Kill
    21. The Man with the Golden Gun
    22. Tomorrow Never Dies
    23. Die Another Day

    Not a bad list. I'm surprised a Daltonite would rank DN so low though?

    Funny that you should mention that, I was thinking about it yesterday. I guess it's because the series was in its very beginnings, I didn't enjoy as much as I did next few. I think when you look at FRWL, GF and TB you see three films that we're confidently made, acted by a lead who was completely comfortable and almost "living" that role. DN itself, while enjoyable, to me was just that little bit "tepid"? No one knew exactly what they were doing and, to me, it shows. As I said, I still enjoy the film. I just think that it lacks a little something that the later films have.
  • chrisisallchrisisall Brosnan Defender Of The Realm
    Posts: 17,801
    A Barry score. :))
  • bondjamesbondjames You were expecting someone else?
    Posts: 23,883
    chrisisall wrote: »
    A Barry score. :))

    Exactly. That's all that's missing for me.
  • chrisisallchrisisall Brosnan Defender Of The Realm
    Posts: 17,801
    My list has changed due to a few viewings and the passage of time, AGAIN.

    1. TLD
    2. LTK
    3. TND
    4. DN
    5. FRWL
    6. GF
    7. GE
    8. QOS
    9. TMWTGG
    10. TWINE
    11. YOLT
    12. TB
    13. OHMSS
    14. LALD
    15. OP
    16. CR
    17. FYEO
    18. DAF
    19. DAD
    20. TSWLM
    21. SF
    22. AVTAK
    23. MR


  • MayDayDiVicenzoMayDayDiVicenzo Here and there
    Posts: 5,080
    Mayday's Bondathon Summer 2015: The run-up to SPECTRE

    1. On Her Majesty's Secret Service
    2. For Your Eyes Only
    3. The Spy Who Loved Me
    4. From Russia with Love
    5. Goldfinger
    6. Octopussy
    7. Casino Royale
    8. The Living Daylights
    9. Licence to Kill
    10. A View to a Kill
    11. Live and Let Die
    12. Diamonds are Forever
    13. The Man with the Golden Gun
    14. Skyfall
    15. Tomorrow Never Dies
    16. Goldeneye
    17. Thunderball
    18. You Only Live Twice
    19. Dr. No
    20. Quantum of Solace
    21. The World is not Enough
    22. Moonraker
    23. Die Another Day
  • BondJasonBond006BondJasonBond006 on fb and ajb
    Posts: 9,020
    chrisisall wrote: »
    My list has changed due to a few viewings and the passage of time, AGAIN.

    1. TLD
    2. LTK
    3. TND
    4. DN
    5. FRWL
    6. GF
    7. GE
    8. QOS
    9. TMWTGG
    10. TWINE
    11. YOLT
    12. TB
    13. OHMSS
    14. LALD
    15. OP
    16. CR
    17. FYEO
    18. DAF
    19. DAD
    20. TSWLM
    21. SF
    22. AVTAK
    23. MR

    good Lord, I think I like this list even better than mine
    :))

    Dalton is my favourite and of course I have both of him in my Top 10 (2 and 8).
    I wish I could put him on 1 and 2 ;)
    I admire your love for TND, it was for a long time my No 4 after GE TLD and OHMSS, somehow it slipped down to 9, but it is very crowed in the Top 10.
  • chrisisallchrisisall Brosnan Defender Of The Realm
    edited September 2015 Posts: 17,801
    BondJasonBond006 wrote: »
    chrisisall wrote: »
    My list has changed due to a few viewings and the passage of time, AGAIN.

    1. TLD
    2. LTK
    3. TND
    4. DN
    5. FRWL
    6. GF
    7. GE
    8. QOS
    9. TMWTGG
    10. TWINE
    11. YOLT
    12. TB
    13. OHMSS
    14. LALD
    15. OP
    16. CR
    17. FYEO
    18. DAF
    19. DAD
    20. TSWLM
    21. SF
    22. AVTAK
    23. MR

    good Lord, I think I like this list even better than mine
    :))

    Dalton is my favourite and of course I have both of him in my Top 10 (2 and 8).
    I wish I could put him on 1 and 2 ;)
    I admire your love for TND, it was for a long time my No 4 after GE TLD and OHMSS, somehow it slipped down to 9, but it is very crowded in the Top 10.
    You could say that with ties for favourites, my top 13 REALLY IS my top ten!
    ;)
  • w2bondw2bond is indeed a very rare breed
    Posts: 2,252
    Here's my compilation of rankings from MI6, CBn, AJB and randomly sourced from the web (youtube, entertainment websites, reddit - not truly representative of general population as the list includes Bond fans)

    Interestingly, the tier lists separated by colour match @Gustav_Grave 's MI6 findings (except TND), even though he only did top 10. His community rank is similar with a few movies out of place.

    mZydr8G.png

  • w2bondw2bond is indeed a very rare breed
    edited September 2015 Posts: 2,252
    A few disclaimers:
    - The Bond forum ranks only include post-Skyfall lists.
    - 23 points for 1st rank and 1 point for 23rd. These are all added up per film
    - Website ranks may be missing CR, QoS, SF. 3 lists did not include CR, 6 for QoS and 33 for SF. The number before the slash is the score before extrapolation.
    - The extrapolation was calculated by (23-[average rank]+1)x[number of lists film is missing from]
    - There may be a few overlaps in the Bond forum lists due to some members putting their ranks on multiple sites
    - Some member's like to update their lists every 2nd week, so I use everyone's latest list

    Observations:
    - GF tops the general population list and still ranks highly on Bond Forums, as does GE. Both films seem to be touted as overrated on forums.
    - LTK and FYEO always together with LTK on top.
    - DAD universally hated
    - Despite small groups liking QoS and hating SF, both films are still lower and higher ranked respectively
    - TLD, OHMSS and OP fall a few places on the general list
    - I'll publish this later, but LTK has a very high percentage of 1st place on both CBn and AJB (about 10% compared with MI6's 3%)

    It would be interesting to track rises and falls in average rank over time (eg DAD's from 2002 to 2006) but the sample sizes are too small
  • w2bondw2bond is indeed a very rare breed
    edited September 2015 Posts: 2,252
    Wow, some big surprises in my latest Bondathon. My thoughts on the films have stayed mostly the same throughout the years but there have been shocking changes to the list.

    The Living Daylights remains my favourite film, and unexpectedly, OP jumped from 6th to 2nd. Both are full of tension and move at a quick pace with plenty of action and drama.

    You Only Live Twice and Tomorrow Never Dies are the other big winners, the former from long term last place to 14th and TND up 6 places to 9th.

    The Gilbert films have grown on me hence their higher places, whereas the Hamilton films continue to bore me for the most part even though they have some classic moments and characters - DAF ranks highest at 12th.

    The losers are GE which I used to love and has now fallen to 6th, AVTAK has slipped over the years although I still enjoy it, TB which I thought I liked but the movie just drags, and this brings me to the most controversial placing of Skyfall at 20th. While it's technically very well made and acted, it bores me for the most part, my favourite aspect is the dialogue. I placed DAD above SF, shoot me

    The untouchables. Spectre will have a hard time cracking the top 5. GE is on shaky ground

    1. The Living Daylights (+3)
    2. Octopussy (+4)
    3. Casino Royale (-2)
    4. From Russia With Love (-2)
    5. On Her Majesty's Secret Service (-2)
    6. Goldeneye (-1)

    Excellent, could easily rewatch
    7. For Your Eyes Only (+2)
    8. The Spy Who Loved Me (+4)
    9. Tomorrow Never Dies (+6)
    10. Moonraker (+12)
    11. Dr No (+5)
    12. Diamonds are Forever (+1)
    13. Licence to Kill(-3)

    Flawed but enjoyable
    14. You Only Live Twice (+9)
    15. A View To A Kill
    16. Goldfinger

    Mostly pacing issues (TB) or just downright bad (DAD)
    17. The Man with the Golden Gun (+2)
    18. Die Another Day (+2)
    19. Thunderball (-11)
    20. Skyfall (-13)

    Didn't do much for me (unfortunate because LALD has many good scenes)
    21. LALD (-5)
    22. TWINE (-4)
    23. QOS (-2)
Sign In or Register to comment.