›

Bond Trilogy Ranking

JamesBondKenyaJamesBondKenya Danny Boyle laughs to himself
in Bond Movies Posts: 2,730
Rank the films as trilogies by there year of release. Fairly simple. I’ll start

1. DN,FRWL,GF
2. LTK,GE,TND
3.OP,AVTAK,TLD
4.TB,YOLT,OHMSS
5.TSWLM,MR,FYEO
6.QOS, SF, SP
7.TWINE,DAD,CR
8.DAF,LALD,TMWTGG

Comments

  • j_w_pepperj_w_pepper Born on the bayou, but I now hear a new dog barkin'
    edited February 2018 Posts: 9,073
    Based on my rating for each movie:

    1. DN, FRWL, GF (in total, 26/30 pts.)
    2. TSWLM, MR, FYEO (23/30)
    ___QOS, SF, SP (23/30)
    4. TB, YOLT, OHMSS (22/30)
    ___LTK, GE, TND (22/30)
    6. OP, AVTAK, TND (19/30)
    7. DAF, LALD, TMWTGG (18/30)
    ___TWINE, DAD, CR (18/30 - includes 9/10 for CR)
  • TheWizardOfIceTheWizardOfIce 'One of the Internet's more toxic individuals'
    edited February 2018 Posts: 9,117
    1. DN,FRWL,GF
    2. OP,AVTAK,TLD
    3. TB,YOLT,OHMSS
    4. TSWLM,MR,FYEO
    5. QOS, SF, SP
    6. TWINE,DAD,CR
    7. LTK,GE,TND
    8.DAF,LALD,TMWTGG

    The first three are fairly easy but after that it gets a bit messy. I'm loathed to have CR so low but the drag factor of DAD is impossible to overcome and coupled with the extremely mediocre TWINE CR finds itself fatally wounded.

    The same applies to OHMSS but obviously TB and YOLT are far better than TWINE and DAD hence it places higher.
  • ThunderfingerThunderfinger Das Boot Hill
    Posts: 45,489
    1 DN, FRWL, GF
    2 QOS, SF, SP
    3 TB, YOLT, OHMSS
    4 TSWLM, MR, FYEO
    5 OP, AVTAK, TLD
    6 DAF, LALD, TMWTGG
    7 TWINE, DAD, CR
    8 LTK, GE, TND
  • bondjamesbondjames You were expecting someone else?
    Posts: 23,883
    Difficult choices after the top three.

    1. DN, FRWL, GF
    2. TB, YOLT, OHMSS
    3. TSWLM, MR, FYEO
    4. LTK, GE, TND
    5. DAF, LALD, TMWTGG
    6. OP, AVTAK, TLD
    7. QOS, SF, SP
    8. TWINE, DAD, CR
  • JamesBondKenyaJamesBondKenya Danny Boyle laughs to himself
    Posts: 2,730
    It’s funny how most people think CR is great including me, but the two films directly before it drop the “trilogy” to near bottom on every list so far
  • Fire_and_Ice_ReturnsFire_and_Ice_Returns I am trying to get away from this mountan!
    Posts: 25,360
    1.TB, YOLT, OHMSS
    2. DN, FRWL, GF
    3. TSWLM, MR, FYEO
    4. DAF, LALD, TMWTGG
    5. OP, AVTAK, TLD
    6. LTK, GE, TND
    7. TWINE, DAD, CR
    8. QOS, SF, SP
  • pachazopachazo Make Your Choice
    Posts: 7,314
    An interesting way to do it. From my last rankings, back in 2016. I really need to update this year.

    1) DN, FRWL, GF
    2) TSWLM, MR, FYEO
    3) QOS, SF, SP
    4) OP, AVTAK, TLD
    5) DAF, LALD, TMWTGG
    6) TB, YOLT, OHMSS
    7) TWINE, DAD, CR
    8) LTK, GE, TND
  • ToTheRightToTheRight
    Posts: 16,204
    1. DR, FRWL, GF
    2. TB, YOLT, OHMSS
    3.OP, AVTAK, TLD
    4. DAF, LALD, TMWTGG
    5. TSWLM, MR, FYEO
    6. LTK, GE, TND
    7. TWINE, DAD, CR
    8. QOS, SF, SP
  • ThunderfingerThunderfinger Das Boot Hill
    Posts: 45,489
    There are some variations here, but a huge majority seem to have DN-GF on top, and TWINE-CR second last.
  • StrogStrog
    edited February 2018 Posts: 684
    1. TB, YOLT, OHMSS
    2. DN, FRWL, GF
    3. TSWLM, MR, FYEO
    4. DAF, LALD, TMWTGG
    5. QOS, SF, SP
    6. LTK, GE, TND
    7. TWINE, DAD, CR
    8. OP, AVTAK, TLD

    @Fire_and_Ice_Returns and myself seem to be on our own so far with TB, YOLT, and OHMSS in the top slot. But indeed I will also contribute yet another #7 serving of TWINE, DAD, and CR.
  • SoundofthesinnersSoundofthesinners
    Posts: 3,236
    This is a fascinating idea. Here's my first stab at it:

    1. DN, FRWL, GF
    2. TB, YOLT, OHMSS
    3. LTK, GE, TND
    4. TSWLM, MR, FYEO
    5. TWINE, DAD, CR
    6. QoS, SF, SP
    7. OP, AVTAK, TLD
    8. DAF, LALD, TMWTGG

    It's tough to rank because each trilogy has at least one good to great film and one bad to awful one. There's no real question that the first three Connerys sit at the top, and the early seventies trilogy is at the bottom. But in between it's a crapshoot. How far can Casino Royale elevate a trilogy that contains Die Another Day? Can Moonraker by itself sink Moore's two best entries?

    Also, looked at this way, certain eras get a big boost, and others really suffer. The two more bombastic, decadent Connery films vault up to second place because they're not that bad in themselves and are carried by OHMSS. But the Craig era, which is quite strong, gets stuck between spots 5 and 6. If it had been possible to rank CR/QoS/SF together, it would have been in second place, and just a hair behind the original Connery trilogy.

    Thank you for this great exercise, @JamesBondKenya!
  • Fire_and_Ice_ReturnsFire_and_Ice_Returns I am trying to get away from this mountan!
    Posts: 25,360
    Strog wrote: »
    1. TB, YOLT, OHMSS
    2. DN, FRWL, GF
    3. TSWLM, MR, FYEO
    4. DAF, LALD, TMWTGG
    5. QOS, SF, SP
    6. LTK, GE, TND
    7. TWINE, DAD, CR
    8. OP, AVTAK, TLD

    @Fire_and_Ice_Returns and myself seem to be on our own so far with TB, YOLT, and OHMSS in the top slot. But indeed I will also contribute yet another #7 serving of TWINE, DAD, and CR.

    My Top 3 are FRWL, TB and OHMSS with DN at number 4. There was a fine line between my top two trilogy choices. Not a big fan of GF either so that had a baring on my choice also.
  • StrogStrog
    Posts: 684
    Fire_and_Ice_Returns wrote: »
    Strog wrote: »
    1. TB, YOLT, OHMSS
    2. DN, FRWL, GF
    3. TSWLM, MR, FYEO
    4. DAF, LALD, TMWTGG
    5. QOS, SF, SP
    6. LTK, GE, TND
    7. TWINE, DAD, CR
    8. OP, AVTAK, TLD

    @Fire_and_Ice_Returns and myself seem to be on our own so far with TB, YOLT, and OHMSS in the top slot. But indeed I will also contribute yet another #7 serving of TWINE, DAD, and CR.

    My Top 3 are FRWL, TB and OHMSS with DN at number 4. There was a fine line between my top two trilogy choices. Not a big fan of GF either so that had a baring on my choice also.
    For me it was a matter of FRWL -- I love all the 60s films, but it's FRWL I like least of them.
    Soundofthesinners wrote: »
    It's tough to rank because each trilogy has at least one good to great film and one bad to awful one.
    The trilogy I find most middling, even-keeled is LTK, GE, TND.
  • Fire_and_Ice_ReturnsFire_and_Ice_Returns I am trying to get away from this mountan!
    Posts: 25,360
    Strog wrote: »
    Fire_and_Ice_Returns wrote: »
    Strog wrote: »
    1. TB, YOLT, OHMSS
    2. DN, FRWL, GF
    3. TSWLM, MR, FYEO
    4. DAF, LALD, TMWTGG
    5. QOS, SF, SP
    6. LTK, GE, TND
    7. TWINE, DAD, CR
    8. OP, AVTAK, TLD

    @Fire_and_Ice_Returns and myself seem to be on our own so far with TB, YOLT, and OHMSS in the top slot. But indeed I will also contribute yet another #7 serving of TWINE, DAD, and CR.

    My Top 3 are FRWL, TB and OHMSS with DN at number 4. There was a fine line between my top two trilogy choices. Not a big fan of GF either so that had a baring on my choice also.
    For me it was a matter of FRWL -- I love all the 60s films, but it's FRWL I like least of them.
    Soundofthesinners wrote: »
    It's tough to rank because each trilogy has at least one good to great film and one bad to awful one.
    The trilogy I find most middling, even-keeled is LTK, GE, TND.

    Interesting FRWL and OHMSS often rotate in top spot for me, I love the old school espionage feel to FRWL it's such an atmospheric film for me.
  • SoundofthesinnersSoundofthesinners
    Posts: 3,236
    Strog wrote: »
    Soundofthesinners wrote: »
    It's tough to rank because each trilogy has at least one good to great film and one bad to awful one.
    The trilogy I find most middling, even-keeled is LTK, GE, TND.

    I absolutely love GE, but the other two are pretty good and don't drag it down at all. And so it slips into third place.
  • RemingtonRemington I'll do anything for a woman with a knife.
    Posts: 1,534
    1. LTK, GE, TND
    2. DN, FRWL, GF
    3. TB, YOLT, OHMSS
    4. TSWLM, MR, FYEO
    5. OP, AVTAK, TLD
    6. TWINE, DAD, CR
    7. QOS, SF, SP
    8. DAF, LALD, TMWTGG

    Damn this is hard.
  • JamesBondKenyaJamesBondKenya Danny Boyle laughs to himself
    Posts: 2,730
    I tried to organize how I think the bond films should have come out in terms of similarity in style. Try ranking these between their groups

    Casino Royale
    Quantum of solace
    OHMSS
    Spectre

    Dr. No
    From Russia With Love
    Thunderball

    Goldfinger
    You Only Live Twice
    Diamonds are forever
    MOONRAKER

    Live and Let Die
    The man with the golden gun
    AVTAK

    TSWLM
    OP
    FYEO

    TLD
    LTK
    GE

    TND
    Skyfall
    TWINE
    DAD



  • GoldenGunGoldenGun Per ora e per il momento che verrà
    edited February 2018 Posts: 7,197
    1. DN, FRWL, GF = 93.33% (best: FRWL 10/10)
    2. LTK, GE, TND = 86.67% (best: GE 10/10)
    3. TB, YOLT, OHMSS = 80.00% (best: OHMSS 10/10)
    4. OP, AVTAK, TLD = 76.67% (best: TLD 10/10)
    5. TWINE, DAD, CR = 76.67% (best: CR 9/10)
    6. TSWLM, MR, FYEO = 70.00% (best: FYEO 9/10)
    7. DAF, LALD, TMWTGG = 70.00% (best: TMWTGG 8/10)
    8. QOS, SF, SP = 60.00% (best: SF 7/10)

    OP-TLD and TWINE-CR are tied but TLD has the highest individual score so its group gets the higher spot. Same goes for TSWLM-FYEO and DAF-TMWTGG where FYEO has the highest individual score.
  • ThunderfingerThunderfinger Das Boot Hill
    edited February 2018 Posts: 45,489
    JamesBondKenya wrote: »
    I tried to organize how I think the bond films should have come out in terms of similarity in style. Try ranking these between their groups

    Casino Royale
    Quantum of solace
    OHMSS
    Spectre

    Dr. No
    From Russia With Love
    Thunderball

    Goldfinger
    You Only Live Twice
    Diamonds are forever
    MOONRAKER

    Live and Let Die
    The man with the golden gun
    AVTAK

    TSWLM
    OP
    FYEO

    TLD
    LTK
    GE

    TND
    Skyfall
    TWINE
    DAD



    1 OHMSS
    2 CR
    3 SP
    4 QOS

    1 FRWL
    2 DN
    3 TB

    1 GF
    2 YOLT
    3 DAF
    4 MR

    1 LALD
    2 TMWTGG
    3 AVTAK

    1 FYEO
    2 TSWLM
    3 OP

    1 TLD
    2 LTK
    3 GE

    1 SF
    2 TND
    3 TWINE
    4 DAD

    Or that is maybe ranking within the groups. Did you mean just ranking the groups?
  • ThunderfingerThunderfinger Das Boot Hill
    Posts: 45,489
    Ranking the groups:

    1 OHMSS, CR, QOS, SP
    2 DN, FRWL, TB
    3 TSWLM, FYEO, OP
    4 GF, YOLT, DAF, MR
    5 TLD, LTK, GE
    6 LALD,TMWTGG, AVTAK
    7 TND, TWINE, DAD, SF
  • BondAficionadoBondAficionado Former IMDBer
    Posts: 1,890
    1. TB,YOLT,OHMSS
    2. DN,FRWL,GF
    3. TWINE,DAD,CR
    4. OP,AVTAK,TLD
    5. QOS, SF, SP
    6. LTK,GE,TND
    7. TSWLM,MR,FYEO
    8. DAF,LALD,TMWTGG

    The problem with this really is that there are many trios with one film that is much worse than the other two, or for example, TSWLM getting dragged down for being next to FYEO and MR. But I guess that's the challenge of this.
  • NicNacNicNac Administrator, Moderator
    Posts: 7,584
    TB,YOLT,OHMSS
    DN,FRWL,GF
    QOS, SF, SP
    TSWLM,MR,FYEO
    OP,AVTAK,TLD
    DAF,LALD,TMWTGG
    TWINE,DAD,CR
    LTK,GE,TND


Sign In or Register to comment.