It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
^ Back to Top
The MI6 Community is unofficial and in no way associated or linked with EON Productions, MGM, Sony Pictures, Activision or Ian Fleming Publications. Any views expressed on this website are of the individual members and do not necessarily reflect those of the Community owners. Any video or images displayed in topics on MI6 Community are embedded by users from third party sites and as such MI6 Community and its owners take no responsibility for this material.
James Bond News • James Bond Articles • James Bond Magazine
Comments
You are more consistent than I.
I can see your rationale for yours, except for QoS (you already explained TMWTGG)
Lazenby - OHMSS
Moore - LALD
Dalton - TLD
Brosnan - GE
Craig - QoS
No changes since last time I did this.
Lazenby - On Her Majesty's Secret Service
Moore - Octopussy
Dalton - The Living Daylights
Brosnan - GoldenEye
Craig - Casino Royale
Lazenby - Diamonds Are Forever :)>-
Moore - The Man With the Golden Gun (OP is close!)
Dalton - The Living Daylights
Brosnan - Tomorrow Never Dies
Craig - Quantum of Solace (Spectre close)
Octopussy
The Living Daylights
Die Another Day
Spectre
Brave list!
To be totally leftfield though, you probably should have gone LTK, as TLD is the more popular choice? 😁
FRWL
OHMSS
TSWLM
TLD
GE
SF or CR
Favourite:
(See my list three posts up)
Worst:
DAF
OHMSS
AVTAK
LTK (more like less best)
DAD
SP
Least favourite:
DAF
OHMSS
AVTAK
LTK
TWINE (DAD is so stupid it's funny, which puts it ahead of the mediocre TWINE subjectively, both near the bottom though)
CR
Decided to shake things up by using objective and subjective rankings
Agree with you there. DAD gets a response from me, whereas TWINE shows promise but is a snorefest
Yeah, DAD used to be my least favourite Brosnan, but it's gone above TWINE recently
You like LTK! I have a whole new level of respect for your Bond rankings!
TB
FYEO
TLD
TWINE
QOS
Yeah, my lists tend to end up regrettably leftfield. But there is a method to the madness!
I'd say the biggest factors going into how I rate these are "how rewatchable is it?", "does the film know what it is and do it well?", and "does the film deliver a uniquely Bondian experience?"
So, rewatchability. The whole point of these movies for me is sort of that I can watch them over and over. GF is mind-blowing on first watch, but for me, it's less interesting on future go-rounds because the last act is mostly misdirection of the audience. Still a great film, but something gets lost after first viewing. Octopussy, on the other hand, somehow I worry every time that the bomb might go off. And even people who don't love DAF often admit it's extremely rewatchable.
Does the film know what it is and do it well? Goldeneye reinvents Bond as one half of a "dictator-toppling" duo and in the dialogue seems to be embarrassed by the fact that it's a Bond film. Some classics, like TSWLM and YOLT, don't seem to know how silly they kind of are. Diamonds are Forever knows exactly what it is and delivers some hilarious self-satire while still having the Bondian goods.
Does the film deliver a uniquely Bondian experience? Casino Royale, on the whole, doesn't have to be a Bond movie at all. It could be anyone. Octopussy, Die Another Day? These could ONLY be Bond movies. If you wrote Octopussy in a world without Bond, you couldn't make it. Spectre, with its board meetings and ejector seats, has to be a Bond movie.
I'm not trying to make my opinions sound objective, because of course they're not, but given the things I most value in this series, I don't think any of them should be TOO surprising....
To quote Q yet again, "I CONCUR!"
FYEO
TLD
DAD
NTTD
Best: Goldfinger
Favorite: Diamonds Are Forever
Lazenby
Best: OHMSS
Favorite: OHMSS
Moore
Best: TSWLM
Favorite: FYEO
Dalton:
Best: TLD
Favorite: TLD
Brosnan
Best: TWINE
Favorite: TWINE
Craig
Best: Skyfall
Favorite: Casino Royale
Brosnan- (none really) Goldeneye
Dalton: License to Kill
Moore: A View To A Kill
Connery: Thunderball
Sean - FRWL
George - OHMSS ;)
Roger - FYEO
Tim - TLD
Pierce - TND
Dan - CR
George Lazenby - On Her Majesty’s Secret Service
Roger Moore - The Spy Who Loved Me
Timothy Dalton - Licence to Kill
Pierce Brosnan - GoldenEye
Daniel Craig - Casino Royale
All basically set in stone with the exception of Connery, since TB and FRWL is kind of a tossup for me.
On Her Majesty’s Secret Service
For Your Eyes Only
The Living Daylights
Goldeneye
Casino Royale
You Only Live Twice
On Her Majesty's Secret Service (funny how that's everyone's pick)
For Your Eyes Only
Tomorrow Never Dies
SPECTRE
On Her Majesty’s Secret Service
The Spy Who Loved Me
The Living Daylights
Goldeneye
Casino Royal
TSWLM
LTK
GE
CR
OHMSS
Octopussy
The Living Daylights
GoldenEye
No Time To Die
OHMSS
Octopussy
Licence to Kill
Tomorrow Never Dies
Quantum of Solace
On Her Majesty’s Secret Service
Moonraker
The Living Daylights
Goldeneye
Casino Royale
—
These have been my top picks for each actor for years now, but I could see CR wavering as we get some distance and perspective on the Craig era.
Wots the pattern....??